poll Forbidden Love vs Forbidden Love

[crf13]

 

 

 

[RideOrDie]

forbidden love sweetie... 

[Holiest Dreams]

Both are good 

 

But the 2005 version is my favorite song on Confessions, so that one wins 

[Lachlan]

Both are excellent but the 2005 one is just otherworldly. 

[Mitsouko]

2005 but I adore both

[Oktober Knight]

I adore both but 2005 is slightly better 

[Janet]

If I only had one wish… love would always feel like this. X

[Legend E]

the underrated 94 one >

[Phaunzie]

Foribbean Love of course, secretly 1994 but 2005 has me in a hold

[Melancholy]

1994 >>>>> 

 

2005 is a whatever disco song

[Escape]

2005

[ZIVERT]

2005 >>>

Ugh Confessions, the album that you are

[Chris]

Bedtime Stories >>>

[Soda Pop Queen]

These poll results are abysmal. Y'all didn't give the OG one a fighting chance at all. 

 

The 2005 version isn't bad but it's very surface level and doesn't have the sexy mystery of the '94 version. Like unless there is some illegality or adultery going on, why the hell would a generic story of boy and girl falling in love be "forbidden love"? and in 2005 no less?? A complete laugh.

 

Justice for the saxophone assisted Madonna and Babyface version! It also has harmony and better lyrics... and hell, I even like M's vocals better here.

 

 

[Dragonfly]

Lemme give 1994 a vote, since I revisited Bedtime Stories last week. But 2005 is nice too

[LikeaRebel]

I adore both but 1994 wins by an inch. 

[Melancholy]

2 hours ago, Soda Pop Queen said:

These poll results are abysmal. Y'all didn't give the OG one a fighting chance at all. 

 

The 2005 version isn't bad but it's very surface level and doesn't have the sexy mystery of the '94 version. Like unless there is some illegality or adultery going on, why the hell would a generic story of boy and girl falling in love be "forbidden love"? and in 2005 no less?? A complete laugh.

 

Justice for the saxophone assisted Madonna and Babyface version! It also has harmony and better lyrics... and hell, I even like M's vocals better here.

 

 

All of this....The sultriness and sexiness of Bedtime Stories is UNMATCHED uhhhh the layers!!!

[hallucinate]

2005 wins

[davidson]

Both are one of the best songs on their albums. 2005 slightly wins it for me.

[tiagol88]

Gays are just so basic and predictable 

I love Confessions but it's so overrated i swear...

 

1994 all the way...

[theweekend]

it depends on the mood

 

but the 1994 will always have a special place in my heart