base talk Style (Taylor) vs Thinking Of You (Katy)

[Josh]

[vuelve88]

Weird comparison, but Style still wins. 

[Katamari]

Indian summer chanteuse kind of won 

[GraceRandolph]

Comparisons are easily done
Once you've had a taste of perfection
Like an apple hanging from a tree
I picked the ripest one
I still got the seed

[havewemet]

Oh god, neither.

[NoisYBoY]

Thinking of GOD 

[Mordecai]

Thinking of You is one of Katy's best, if not her best song

[Iceland]

TOY > Style (Scooter version) > style (Taylor’s version)

[ImsoLOUD]

both tbhhhh 

[SylMacPer]

both (but TOY> just by a biiiiit)

[wastedpotential]

1 hour ago, GraceRandolph said:

Comparisons are easily done
Once you've had a taste of perfection
Like an apple hanging from a tree
I picked the ripest one
I still got the seed

I've always found this lyric kinda stupid since... every apple still has seeds in it? 

 

It's actually a good example of my main criticism of ToY, that it's overwrought and lyrically clunky (which is very fitting as the "best" example of Katy's lyrical tendencies). Style is better produced and the writing is much tighter. The song is melodically constructed much better - see the literal analysis videos made about how perfect the sonic structure is - and the vocals are better on both versions (but especially the re-recording). 

[Alexz]

Style.

[DirtyPony87]

Style is one of the best pop songs of all time. The other one is just fine.

[Pillz]

Katy's by far

[Soda Pop Queen]

Style is cute but I haven't listened to it since 2015. Thinking of You eats. It's quite a sublime Rock ballad. Katy really sells the emotion and drama of the song.

[Rv1709]

The intro of style defeats Katy’s discography 

[362]

be so fr

[naval23]

The self written classic 

 

Style is cute but it's overrated

[1000 forms of queer]

Thinking of you is Katy’s best song, so that.

I love both songs but i find myself playing ToY a lot more than Style nowadays

[dirrtydiana]

TOY solely because it sounds more unique and original as where the other one sounds like Love Me Harder and I don’t like the singer nor the guy it’s about 

[Johnny Jacobs]

Your eyes

Looking into your eyesssssss

 

[Hallad173]

Taylor’s Style lacks punch so Katy wins. Scooters Style eats tho.

[AxelFox]

3 hours ago, wastedpotential said:

I've always found this lyric kinda stupid since... every apple still has seeds in it? 

 

It's actually a good example of my main criticism of ToY, that it's overwrought and lyrically clunky (which is very fitting as the "best" example of Katy's lyrical tendencies). Style is better produced and the writing is much tighter. The song is melodically constructed much better - see the literal analysis videos made about how perfect the sonic structure is - and the vocals are better on both versions (but especially the re-recording). 

I wasn't sure when I entered the thread but after reading this load of horse **** I went on and voted Thinking Of You x2

[Orsay]

He kissed my lips I taste your mouth

He pulled me in I was disgusted with myself

[davidson]

Style > 

Love TOY tho