Tylerbv Posted December 10, 2023 Posted December 10, 2023 6 minutes ago, Alexz said: Four one-era-wonders Now HOW are you gonna sit here and call Whitney a one era wonder? Or Shania? Doesn't she have 3 consecutive diamond albums?
Alexz Posted December 10, 2023 Posted December 10, 2023 8 minutes ago, Tylerbv said: Now HOW are you gonna sit here and call Whitney a one era wonder? Or Shania? Doesn't she have 3 consecutive diamond albums? This is ATRL
burninredhot Posted December 10, 2023 Posted December 10, 2023 I'm always surprised to see how BTW only spent 6 weeks in top 10 tho it debuted with a million. OT: Who cares? 1
Into The Void Posted December 10, 2023 Posted December 10, 2023 Yall have obsessions with the weirdest things. if its not weeks at #1 its week in top 10 or weeks on top 13. Stop living thru ur faves success
KMO Posted December 10, 2023 Posted December 10, 2023 Damn you even woke the old ModGas up with this one. OT: because longevity, hard work and quality music > migraine medication, sweatshop anniversary merchandise and trips to Epione LA. 2
GraceRandolph Posted December 10, 2023 Posted December 10, 2023 So it didn’t spend more time in the top 10 than any Gaga album? Why is this thread still open. The bias towards Gaga on ATRL is getting ridiculous.
Mystic Boy Posted December 10, 2023 Posted December 10, 2023 7 hours ago, alejandreaux said: A Star is Born Soundtrack: 1-1-1-2-2-5-4-4-7-4-3-4-10-7-6-8-4-5-2-3-1-3-3-3-6-8 (26 weeks) The backfire is delicious Since we're speaking about Breathless dont forget to stream this gem 1
suburbannature Posted December 10, 2023 Posted December 10, 2023 I can't tell if the OP or the people replying are fuming more
superben Posted December 10, 2023 Posted December 10, 2023 Longevity in album charts back there was quite impressive as it was all from sales. 1
Mr. Stratus Posted December 10, 2023 Posted December 10, 2023 8 hours ago, UseYourIllusion2002 said: *besides her debut, The Fame I'm Breathless was released in May 1990, eight years into Madonna's career. Some consider it her fifth studio album or her second soundtrack, but it's her overall 7th major release. The album barely got any promotion and consisted of little cute jazz-inspired tracks and only had two singles. It was released two months after Vogue was released at a time when albums were released three weeks after their leads, and was replaced by The Immaculate Collection, leading to its short chart run. Yet, the album has spent more weeks in the top 10 on the Billboard 200 than any Lady Gaga album besides her debut album, The Fame. The question is, why? Why did Madonna's little side album, sandwiched between the massive albums Like a Prayer and The Immaculate Collection, out perform every Gaga album? I'm Breathless: 3-2-3-3-3-2-2-4-5-8-9 (11 weeks) The Fame Monster: 5-OUT-9-10-6 (4 weeks) Born This Way: 1-1-2-4-8-OUT-8 (6 weeks) ARTPOP: 1-8-7 (3 weeks) Joanne: 1-5-OUT-2-8 (4 weeks) Chromatica: 1-2-6 (3 weeks) Great. No one cares or remembers ‘im breathless’ …you’re talking about an acclaimed actress and vocalist, show some respect and please don’t embarrass yourself
GlamSlam Posted December 10, 2023 Posted December 10, 2023 7 hours ago, BrandNewBrandon said: Gaga had TWO albums with over 25 weeks in the Top 10 (The Fame and ASIB) out of six original albums. No shade to Madonna but your thread is a flop. She didn't sing on all the ASIB songs, so it's not entirely a Gaga album. Madonna's Like a Virgin album spent 33 weeks in the top 10. She also had the biggest selling album of 1986, 1989, and 1990. Gaga only has one on that list, and that's The Fame. ASIB was the 8th best seller of 2018. https://bestsellingalbums.org/year/1986 https://bestsellingalbums.org/year/1989 https://bestsellingalbums.org/year/1990 1 1
alejandreaux Posted December 10, 2023 Posted December 10, 2023 5 hours ago, GlamSlam said: She didn't sing on all the ASIB songs, so it's not entirely a Gaga album. Madonna's Like a Virgin album spent 33 weeks in the top 10. She also had the biggest selling album of 1986, 1989, and 1990. Gaga only has one on that list, and that's The Fame. ASIB was the 8th best seller of 2018. https://bestsellingalbums.org/year/1986 https://bestsellingalbums.org/year/1989 https://bestsellingalbums.org/year/1990 ASIB has 19 songs total (not including dialogue tracks) Gaga is a singer on 14/19 songs a writer on 13/19 songs and a producer on 16/19 songs so she’s a lead singer and writer on the majority of the albums songs and provided enough content to constitute a traditional full length solo album. it’s also officially credited under her name, unlike most movie soundtracks which are credited as “various artists”. which is why Billboard, RIAA, The Grammys, and every other established organization in the music industry classify it as a Lady Gaga album just as much as they do her studio albums. the only group of people who don’t count it as “her album” exist on ATRL exclusively. also Madonna’s stats are undeniably impressive and there’s a reason why she’ll always be the standard, but bringing them up doesn’t change or even address the fact the OP built a thread around a statement that is observably false, which is why they are rightfully getting dragged. 1
Tovitov Posted December 10, 2023 Posted December 10, 2023 "I'm Breathless: Music from and inspired by the film Dick Tracy" It's connected to a film, so then why are you excluding ASIB?
Recommended Posts