base talk Taylor gets criticized on twitter for labelling Reputation as “goth-punk”

[Mr.X]

19 minutes ago, MidnightsAtPeace said:

you know what it never was? that serious

it was never that serious 

the coopting of genuine art and activism for profit is quite a serious matter, actually, and it is one of the ways that capitalism destroys art and political movements.

 

So yep, it is actually that serious.

[vale9001]

anyways you all seems these basic straight men going for journalists when someone writes Madonna is a rockstar.

You can say something is rock, dark or punk in terms of mood and vibes lol 

 

 

 

Edited December 7, 2023 by vale9001

[PopKills]

I don’t think it’s that deep or that she meant Reputation was a goth punk album sonically but the way she sees herself is giving Witness era 

[GoatGly]

Purposely taking her words out of context to make her look stupid when she was making a joke  don’t yall get exhausted creating fake reasons to be mad

[Space Cowboy]

1 minute ago, GoatGly said:

I guess viral threads that don’t meet the threshold remain open only if it drags Taylor 

I already changed the title, I didn’t know about that rule. I’ll do better next time 

[GoatGly]

Just now, Space Cowboy said:

I already changed the title, I didn’t know about that rule. I’ll do better next time 

Ate that 

[RideOrDie]

3 minutes ago, barbiegrande said:

We are literally taking her own words for face value. Maybe she should be more clear next time instead of saying dumb ****.  We know exactly what she meant, which is why using the term Punk for such a g-rated, corporatized artists is so funny
 

Swifties know that was an objectively stupid statement but yall will never admit to Taylor having a fault  

you are brave talking about "not admitting having a fault" with that pfp mr barbie, projecting much? 

"taking her words for face value" just say you are ignoring the actual meaning of what she said for your own personal agenda and go

 

[ugo]

1 minute ago, Space Cowboy said:

I already changed the title, I didn’t know about that rule. I’ll do better next time 

There’s literally a banner to remind users of the viral  threshold it’s been there for months 

 

Anyway it’s the negative energy we wanted for rep she’s so smart 

[Dear Reader]

3 minutes ago, GoatGly said:

Purposely taking her words out of context to make her look stupid when she was making a joke  don’t yall get exhausted creating fake reasons to be mad

And putting some random people tweets () on the OP to further push their false narrative. Two of them aren’t even at 20k

[SlimyGhoul]

Who cares?

[vale9001]

6 minutes ago, ugo said:

There’s literally a banner to remind users of the viral  threshold it’s been there for months 

 

Anyway it’s the negative energy we wanted for rep she’s so smart 

the difference is if the tweet is not viral and about Britney and Gaga the thread gets closed.

If the not viral tweet is about Taylor or someone else they change the title about the virality but the thread stays....when the rule it's literally  not viral- not thread worthy

 

 

 

Edited December 7, 2023 by vale9001

[Erreur2 La Nature]

LOVE Reputation but there's nothing "goth punk" about it lmao

[Shinning]

I do take the hats off to Swifties that indocrinated the internet that reputation is anything but a mid-boring pop album with no artistic merit and convoluted "bad-ass" imagery

[Kh-Loud]

I’m sorry but this girl is a bigger victim than her career. I don’t think she will ever grow out of being a victim. Every interview, every chance she gets, someone, something always wrong her, yet she’s the one who feuding with the entire industry for almost two decades 

[FailSafe]

Her goth pop could mean anything 

[ugo]

19 minutes ago, Mr.X said:

the coopting of genuine art and activism for profit is quite a serious matter, actually, and it is one of the ways that capitalism destroys art and political movements.

 

So yep, it is actually that serious.

Reputation destroyed what art or political movement? 

[Bosque]

Quote

Person gets criticized on Twitter

[SecretSecret]

53 minutes ago, Afterglow said:

I feel like she meant the image and not so much the music.

Well I don't think that wearing black lipstick is enough to say that the image is goth-punk either. She's trying to intellectualize that whole era, making it seem like something more profound than it actually was, but it's a reach.

 

Like what is punk about the LWYMMD video? The cover is goth because it's in black and white? If anything, it's the cliché of good-girl-gone-bad that we had already seen almost every pop girl do before her. And even then, it wasn't even particularly provocative, compared with Miley for example. Her "bad girl" pose was mostly about vicimitizing herself anyway.

Edited December 7, 2023 by SecretSecret

[Mr.X]

1 minute ago, ugo said:

Reputation destroyed what art or political movement? 

lol I didnt say that but as per usual, swifties love be as deluded as their own hero

[Rev8]

I get that the "goth" part is a bit too much - but it's still goth for what She stands for, which is mostly a colorful pop aesthetic

while Reputation was quite dark of an era for her.

 

And her adding the "punk" part to it, has its logic. She literally said it.

She obviously doesn't think that it's a strictly gothic punk genre. It's much more of an overall description than just for the music even.

 

Are people really acting obtuse to not get that

[fememeist]

The tweets made several points i fear, but the swifties on this website insist that we’re reading an doctoral dissertation from Taylor and that she’s taken out of context

 

Edited December 7, 2023 by fememeist

[Meev]

All the usual suspects chiming into this thread 

 

And yes, if if Taylor says puta is goth and punk, it is indeed goth punk 

[Julián]

Love how these “haters” have clearly heard the album multiple times. They really do what she commands them to everytime. The TIME’s Person of the Year is so powerful

[Rev8]

16 minutes ago, vale9001 said:

the difference is if the tweet is not viral and about Britney and Gaga the thread gets closed.

If the not viral tweet is about Taylor or someone else they change the title about the virality but the thread stays....when the rule it's literally  not viral- not thread worthy

What is with some of yall and constantly putting Gaga/Britney in every bitсh comment yall make

 

Constantly acting like victims and as if No other fanbase has had these problems - when Monsters used to Constantly be in HQ crying about the same thing

 

 

Get a grip

[flashfox]

I believe her on this, we are all just dumb to understand her genius