base talk Taylor gets criticized on twitter for labelling Reputation as “goth-punk”

[Space Cowboy]

 

 

What do you think? Is Reputation truly a goth-punk moment of female rage? Or is Taylor lying and these tweets made several points?

 

Discuss.

 

 

Edited December 7, 2023 by Space Cowboy

[By the Water]

Oh no the goth police is here

[needs]

Nothing about Reputa is goth or punk lol.

[Mr.X]

Taylor is lying, again, so she can promote her next re-recording and create drama, whilst diluting the artistic and political merits of the art and artists she wants to align herself to. AGAIN.

 

It's not a goth-punk, it's pop and embarrassing. it's baffling how her rabbid fans can't see the fakeness of TS

Edited December 7, 2023 by Mr.X

[istan4badgalriri]

"goth-punk" "female rage" "gaslit by an entire social structure"  that entire quote is embarrassing asf

[Daddy]

She's a musician, she should know the difference between mainstream pop and punk.

[Nightglitch]

Taylor Swift is the antithesis of punk.

[enchanted0]

:

12 minutes ago, Space Cowboy said:

 

 

 

The lack of self awareness of this tweet.... I just can't take Twitter seriously

[Jjang]

3 minutes ago, istan4badgalriri said:

"goth-punk" "female rage" "gaslit by an entire social structure"  that entire quote is embarrassing asf

tbh. 

[Revolution]

it takes a certain level of intelligence to understand reputa's brilliance.

[Pepo]

That's what a poser would say 

[Khal]

Maybe she will be re-recording the entire album to the point of scrapping all the tracks and putting new ones in their place. She can’t possibly be referring to the same album

[Dragonfly]

It's true. Dress is my favourite punk song

[Afterglow]

I feel like she meant the image and not so much the music. But go awf. She should've used a different phrase though. 

[Feanor]

And she did not lie.  

[Mandalore]

No lies detected! I too, have only seen the light recently and can now appreciate the mastery of Reputa' that I couldn't fully process when it came out. 

Edited December 7, 2023 by Mandalore

[RideOrDie]

are people really thinking she meant the album is sonically goth-punk when she said that?  are y'all intentionally obtuse

[TaylorNation]

as always, her second fanbase always do the most  

 

she was obviously kidding and exaggerating on purpose 

[Gaia]

There’s nothing wrong with pointing out that the quote is largely exaggerated for the sake of seeming “deep” after being selected as Person of the Year. 
 

no one in the world would consider Reputation a goth punk era because she maybe work black lipstick once(?) or something. 
 

It’s not like those tweets are trying to cancel her or anything

Edited December 7, 2023 by Gaia

[Dolce Vita]

in the sense that- 

[barbiegrande]

8 minutes ago, Nightglitch said:

Taylor Swift is the antithesis of punk.

The girl who made ME! Thinking she ever had a punk moment in her career

[Mandalore]

Just now, RideOrDie said:

are people really thinking she meant the album is sonically goth-punk when she said that?  are y'all intentionally obtuse

Shhh never talk to atrls like they're people with reading comprehension. Just play along with the circus! Yes Reputa, yes PUNK!

[MidnightsAtPeace]

13 minutes ago, Mr.X said:

Taylor is lying, again, so she can promote her next re-recording and create drama, whilst diluting the artistic and political merits of the art and artists she wants to align herself to. AGAIN.

 

It's not a goth-punk, it's pop and embarrassing. it's baffling how her rabbid fans can't see the fakeness of TS

you know what it never was? that serious

it was never that serious 

[Lyrica]

I am every genre

 

 

[istan4badgalriri]

1 minute ago, Mr.X said:

Taylor is lying, again, so she can promote her next re-recording and create drama, whilst diluting the artistic and political merits of the art and artists she wants to align herself to. AGAIN.

 

It's not a goth-punk, it's pop and embarrassing. it's baffling how her rabbid fans can't see the fakeness of TS

Literally