Armani? Posted December 3, 2023 Posted December 3, 2023 The GP don't like it which is fine. It's clearly not structured/written as a radio jingle 1
Steve Johnson Posted December 3, 2023 Posted December 3, 2023 The song is pure garbage, that's why. 2
OrgVisual Posted December 3, 2023 Posted December 3, 2023 Just listen to the song and u know damn well it's not meant to be a hit. Why act so dense? Lol 2
dumbsparce Posted December 3, 2023 Posted December 3, 2023 It's a sIdE projEcT for the cUlTuRE. It's ok for it to bomb as long as the world vastly alters its ways bc of it. 2
Thor Posted December 3, 2023 Posted December 3, 2023 The song is a giant turd. Her stans were working overtime trying to convince themselves everyone of what a masterpiece it is, just like they did with her previous flops like Spirit and Black Parade 4 1 7
45seconds Posted December 3, 2023 Posted December 3, 2023 41 minutes ago, Margaux said: and this is with the renaissance film promo on full swing. …what promo? Film premieres?
Rotunda Posted December 3, 2023 Posted December 3, 2023 13 minutes ago, Thor said: The song is a giant turd. Her stans were working overtime trying to convince themselves everyone of what a masterpiece it is, just like they did with her previous flops like Spirit and Black Parade The song has been out for like a day. There hasn’t even been enough time for this narrative to exist. 2 1 2
Yakult Posted December 3, 2023 Posted December 3, 2023 15 minutes ago, Thor said: The song is a giant turd. Her stans were working overtime trying to convince themselves everyone of what a masterpiece it is, just like they did with her previous flops like Spirit and Black Parade You're talking ****. Black Parade was divisive and it's not an uncommon sentinment that Spirit is the worst song on The Gift (fans wanted Bigger or Find Your Way Back as the single).
Kristie Kuwa Posted December 3, 2023 Posted December 3, 2023 The song is just a fun closure to the era of Renaissance which serves the purpose of highlighting that Bey, indeed, does not care about formulas or charts anymore. The song is literally not meant to be a hit or anything of the sort
ScorpiosGroove Posted December 3, 2023 Posted December 3, 2023 1 hour ago, TaggedGalaxy said: Song of the year they said absolutely nobody said that 2
Joyride Posted December 3, 2023 Posted December 3, 2023 1 hour ago, Erreur2 La Nature said: It's #5 on TTH. People listened to it on friday and decided they never wanted to hear it again in their house. kind of this. it's not a good song. 1
Digitalism Posted December 3, 2023 Posted December 3, 2023 I don't know whats worse The Beyhive calling people racist for not liking this Or the success stans saying the song wasn't good when we know their fav hasn't served quality for 5 albums now. 1 2
Diocles Posted December 3, 2023 Posted December 3, 2023 58 minutes ago, Margaux said: and this is with the renaissance film promo on full swing. Damn
ScorpiosGroove Posted December 3, 2023 Posted December 3, 2023 (edited) 1 minute ago, Digitalism said: I don't know whats worse The Beyhive calling people racist for not liking this Or the success stans saying the song wasn't good when we know their fav hasn't served quality for 5 albums now. gaga and taylor stans in here talking about shitty, stale music Edited December 3, 2023 by ScorpiosGroove 3 4
Digitalism Posted December 3, 2023 Posted December 3, 2023 1 minute ago, ScorpiosGroove said: gaga and taylor stans in here talking about shitty, stale music The Gaga stans that had to switch to Taylor because their fav doesn't have hits anymore but the quality wasn't there either 2 1 2
Badgalbriel Posted December 3, 2023 Posted December 3, 2023 That's OK. The song was not meant to be a hit.
Gaia Posted December 3, 2023 Posted December 3, 2023 1 hour ago, charot said: No replay value. Girly needs to sing again and serve melodies. It’s really annoying she’s one of the strongest singers in the industry and has for some reason chosen to rap
Seffers Posted December 3, 2023 Posted December 3, 2023 16 minutes ago, Kristie Kuwa said: The song is just a fun closure to the era of Renaissance which serves the purpose of highlighting that Bey, indeed, does not care about formulas or charts anymore. The song is literally not meant to be a hit or anything of the sort very this also it's beyonce who clearly is in a stage of her career where she doesn't have to give a **** about the charts so why do you so much OP
Solaria Posted December 3, 2023 Posted December 3, 2023 37 minutes ago, Thor said: The song is a giant turd. Her stans were working overtime trying to convince themselves everyone of what a masterpiece it is, just like they did with her previous flops like Spirit and Black Parade You guys always wanna push this narrative that the Hive makes every Bey song to ever exist out to be this ''misunderstood masterpiece'' yet that narrative gets pushed more than the Hive actually does what they're accused of ask any sane minded Hive what they thought this song was and most of them will say that it was just a bonus track for the Renaissance film, we're not talking about the lead single for her next album here. Beyhive does nothing but celebrate Beyoncé's output and the joy of the Renaissance era yet bitter OBH constantly post stuff like this because they desperately want to pick a fight and want a reaction from them. Pathetic 1
woohoo Posted December 3, 2023 Posted December 3, 2023 This is literally the first Beyoncé song I haven’t liked. Like I’m not a stan or anything and I enjoy her music almost all the time but this was a rough listen.
Carry My Heart Posted December 3, 2023 Author Posted December 3, 2023 1 hour ago, Love Again said: The desperation by trying to make a point with every thing she releases or does, microanalyzing every aspect of her career and her chart movements.. even the Beyhive doesn’t put this much energy into her. "Microanalyzing" and it's just an acknowledgement of a song doing poorly despite the odds being in its favor. Maybe if the Hive actually streamed it instead of screaming into the void that Bey's bigger than [Insert artist here] based on vibes alone, such threads wouldn't exist. Oh well
Carry My Heart Posted December 3, 2023 Author Posted December 3, 2023 19 minutes ago, Seffers said: also it's beyonce who clearly is in a stage of her career where she doesn't have to give a **** about the charts so why do you so much OP Dare I remind you what site you're saying this on What's the third forum in the ATRL header called? Quickly.
Recommended Posts