base talk Olivia's last two singles depart Global and US Spotify. What went wrong?

[jdanton2]

Vampire is #30 and that is easily my favorite recent Olivia song.atrl might hate it but it is her most popular this era with more streams than the other singles combined.

[Taylena]

Swifties were left with a Sour taste in their mouths since she didn't say anything to defend her supposed fave from accusations of demanding credits from her. That's what happened. 

[M.R.]

1 hour ago, honestopinion said:

Well pop rock trend is fading away so it makes sense those 2 singles didn't click with GP

Yeah this is pretty much it. The sound of singles is simply not popular anymore in 2023 and GP only care for her ballads.

[Dula Peep]

She’s an indie girlie now 

[L0verb0y]

Pretty Isn't Pretty could save the era!

[glitch]

She needs to push Love is Embarrassing as a single to save the era

[Machete]

ATRL told me she hasn’t seen a decline from SOUR so I’m very confused!

[supertiffany]

1 hour ago, DeadInside said:

She's trying too hard to be this alternative indie rock punk girl. Miss girlie grew up rich and working for Disney. There's a disconnect with her image and what she wants her sound to be. She needs to stop being pretentious and give the GP safe fun pop songs. 

bring back dejavu or g4u

[Karla Cabello]

boring album + safe for her.

if you compare it to happier than ever, billie served something fresh, new sounds and more eclectic. it helped her to broaden her base. i started listening to billie and taking her more seriously after hte

[kellebrity98]

nothing? if you saw that you probably saw that 40 holiday track too and also love how swifties always coming for her just proving the paint again that it’s the most trash fanbase ever (i’m also a swiftie but i just hate most of them like everyone)

[Virtual_Insanity]

Her schtick is tired. 

[ronelmaano13]

The real test is after the holidays, probably in January. If they don't return to the charts, then it's an underperformance, but if they do return, it's just Christmas music clogging the charts. 

 

For me, it's just Christmas music. Half of the charts by December will be Christmas music and most songs of our faves will be gone for a month or two. 

[OrgVisual]

She's "underperforming" the moment Swifties turn on her. It's very telling

Edited November 26, 2023 by Sept

[lillavend3r]

Deserved for not releasing making the bed a single 

[AvadaKedavra]

Its time to drop the Pop Punk sound.
We need more poppy songs and some sort of reinvention and some edge too

[Magdalene]

it got a #1 song #1 album aoty nomination 

 

**** it, it’s fine

[Taemira]

Swifties' streaming farms doesn't help her anymore. guts is more critically acclaimed than any Taylor album so it's understandable.

[What_A_Mess]

It’s because she changed her management team from SOUR era. That team was immaculate. (Plus the GP wants emo Olivia)

[Maroonx]

Naturally this thread has some Billie/Olivia comparison... smh, yoll need to find more interesting to compare, coz this is getting old x

[theintriguingone]

She didn’t have a narrative this era and therefore people weren’t as tuned in to guts as they were sour. I think that’s mainly it. Also she needs to ditch pop rock for good, nobody cares for that sound anymore. She can definitely rebound though. Can’t Catch Me Now is gorgeous. If i were her i’d explore that indie folk rock sound for the next album. It suits her voice beautifully and it can help her expand her lyricism/songwriting.

[Steve Johnson]

Horrible songs

[ICLDXU4HS]

I think her music just kind of exclusively appeals to teenagers and very young twens and that’s not enough to keep her afloat forever.

[Anti-Hero]

Liv has been replaced by Tate as the it gen z girl.

[KOMH]

6 hours ago, Taemira said:

Swifties' streaming farms doesn't help her anymore. guts is more critically acclaimed than any Taylor album so it's understandable.

Red, its rerecording and Folklore are all easily more acclaimed. Lying is a sin. 

[thatsmydemi]

why are Taylor's stans so concerned about Olivia's chart performance?