discussion Rolling Stone Ranks Disney Movies

[poki]

What do you think?

 

https://www.rollingstone.com/tv-movies/tv-movie-lists/walt-disney-animated-movie-ranking-1234892890/home-on-the-range-2004-1234892893/

[Blue Rose]

Beyoncé’s Lion King at #1 as it should

 

[lawmak]

I've just seen this and... no? 

 

Could this be any more random?

[Da Vinci]

I could never finish Bambi for some reason, I get so bored  I think I only read its picture book as a kid but that's it

 

On an objective and technical level though, I think either Pinocchio, Snow White, or Beauty and the Beast should be #1. They were truly groundbreaking in their time. 

[poki]

This makes me want to host another Disney rate like I did in 2017 and 2019. 

 

We got a lot of new movies since then. 

 

[holyground13]

Had a quick look at the top 20 and I approve  The Emperor's New Groove at 5 is immaculate taste.

[KatyPrismSpirit]

I agree with the top 5. Snow White and Bambi are my favorites. My childhood essentially.

[50thStateofMind]

so shocked TENG is at #5...I love that movie, but didn't know critics liked it

[SleepNoMore]

Some of the top 10 seems random. Tarzan? Emperors New Groove?  Instead of Frozen or Moana or Sleeping Beauty? But Little Mermaid deserves top 3 (should have been number 1). 

[Matthew4815]

The Emperor's New Groove stanning 

[Alaska.]

How the hell is Raya so high?

 

Hercules should be top 10 from the soundtrack alone, but I'm happy that The Great Mouse Detective is getting some praise

[Bears01]

The Lion King should be #1. That movie is immaculate 

[Goaty]

101 Dalmatians at #6 

[Matthew]

#JusticeForHomeOnTheRange 

[Miles.]

1: Lion King

2: Aladdin

3-62: The rest

[ScorpiosGroove]

Yzma is the mother i never had, the sister everybody would want, i don’t know a better person 

[rhaenyra]

I'm so sorry Bambi, but you deserve Top 30 at most lbr with ourselves 

[lovecatt]

Top 10 outside of the little mermaid & emperor's new groove is trash 

[Jotham]

Great Mouse Detective at #9? Really?

[brazil]

I dont really remember a lot of these or never really watched, but it's not as controversial as some of their latest music lists. Aladdin deserved top 10 though 

[SlowGinFizzzz]

Seems very random for the most part, and most of the top five seems awfully predictable. Bambi is literally one of the most boring Disney movies of all time. The one thing they got right with this list is ranking The Emperor's New Groove at number five, although honestly it should be number one even just for Yzma alone. 

[UnanimousBB16]

"Home on the Range" shouldn't be last, but definitely not far off.

 

Don't think "Frozen", "The Jungle Book", "The Rescuers", "Bolt" should have been that low.

 

"The Black Cauldron" should have been lower.

 

"Wreck-It Ralph" SHOULD NOT be that low, ESPECIALLY over its sequel.

 

"Ralph Breaks The Internet" and "Pocahontas" are WAY TOO HIGH.

 

"Bambi" being the top ain't it.

[Gorjesspazze9]

Hercules is top 5 and always will be. Idk what they say

[jezebelvictoria]

The Little Mermaid is one of my favorite movies from my life. Of course #1 is what I wanted but #3 isn’t terrible considering the top 2. Top Disney Princess movie at least. 

[Outlaws]

Not The Lion King being at 17