base talk HTE vs GUTS, did Billie get the last laugh?

[bad guy]

On 11/14/2023 at 3:05 PM, naval23 said:

But GUTS had a #1 single, multiple top 10s, a 90+ on Metacritic 

HTE had more Top 10s if that’s what the metric of success is plus we’ll see if that Metacritic score for GUTS translates into the acclaim that matters (YE lists, decade-end lists) like Billie’s projects tend to do.

 

 

OT: Yes and the bandwagon success stans of SOUR lost

[znake]

On 11/15/2023 at 4:24 AM, Ron Ng said:

Yes, I remember ATRL made fun of HTE's underperformance 2 years ago and they said Olivia has replaced Billie as the Genz queen, now we can clearly see the tables have turned when GUTS is doing even worse than HTE

GUTS first 3 months are bigger than HTE, eat your words

[bad guy]

7 minutes ago, znake said:

GUTS first 3 months are bigger than HTE, eat your words

In the US and not even by much. HTE was doing much better globally. And if you think her tour numbers overseas are gonna beat Billie, the global stadium filler and bigger performer, then yes start eating.

 

[Blackout2006]

17 hours ago, znake said:

This thread is so stupid 

Olivia's sould out tour hasnt started yet, she is bigger than Billie , stop it 

Keep dreaming about that

[lef]

Both are excellent albums and aoty contenders of their respective years.

[AaronBryceSufjan]

whatever billie will always find a way to be relevant

if she becomes irrelevant one day she could still be the indie queen just like dsam era