poll Butterfly vs. Ray of Light vs. Velvet Rope

[GlamSlam]

22 minutes ago, RideOrDie said:

cleared 

Which album sold and won the most awards? The answer is Ray of Light for those wondering.

Edited November 10, 2023 by GlamSlam

[Avenger]

People who must’ve witnessed these albums in real time are so blessed, it’s impossible to choose one where all 3 are just 10s I still went with Janet here but no album is less then perfection. 

[blown away]

Each of them is immaculate. Although Janet is my fave, I'mma give it to Mariah for this one. The run from Honey to The Roof and Breakdown to Whenever You Call is mind-blowing.

 

Janet and Madonna delivered some of their best quality records as well. Frozen, The Power Of Goodbye, Sky Fits Heaven, Got Til It's Gone, I Get Lonely, Everytime... So many gems.

 

The best song of em all belongs to Janet though. I Get Lonely is just that *****.

[Schhh]

Ray of Light > Butterfly > The Velvet Rope

[stevyy]

33 minutes ago, GlamSlam said:

Which album sold and won the most awards? The answer is Ray of Light for those wondering.

The rundown is:

 

16m RoL

10m Butterfly

8m TVR

 

I find it fascinating that TVR and B are outstreaming RoL. 

 

All three album were, are and continue to be immaculate. 

[Mystic Boy]

No Pop album reaches the heights of Ray Of Light

[LikeaRebel]

ROL > TVR >>> Butterfly

[GreatestLoveofAll]

not mariah losing. ray of light is nice but its so boring half the time...

 

Anyways for me its Mariah, janet and then madonna in this round.

[PinkLamborghini]

Don't make me choose, they are all perfect!

[John Slayne]

ROL > TVR >>>>>>>>>>> Butterfly

[Price of Fame]

Janet > madonna >> mariah

[CityPop]

TVR > Butterfly >>>>>> ROL

[Mickie]

The Velvet Rope for me, with all due respect to Mariah and Madonna. 

[ParisxHilton]

ROL=TVR>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Butterfly

[slw84]

They are all equally good to me. I can't choose between my triplets.

[ebaby]

1. God of Light

 

 

2.  Velvet Slay 

 

 

3.  Yasifly 

 

and they are all legendary btw

[LOTF]

I miss when WOMEN in pop served QUALITY 

[Virtual_Insanity]

All of these albums are overrated. 

 

My love is your love by Whitney is actually the best album from that time period by a big female artist, by a LONG shot. 

 

Hence it was the most successful globally. 

[robbyds]

The Velvet Rope > Butterfly > Ray Of Light

 

[Homebrand]

Mariah & Madonna > Janet

 

Mariah still has the highest highs for me. My All, The Roof & Breakdown are just all so good. 

 

Although in saying I've warmed up to ROL recently, all of its singles are flawless too. 

[ICLDXU4HS]

Janet > Madonna > Mamoo

[Goaty]

Listened to all three today to do this ranking so - 

 

ROL > TVR >>>> Butterfly

[Mystic Boy]

5 hours ago, Virtual_Insanity said:

All of these albums are overrated. 

 

My love is your love by Whitney is actually the best album from that time period by a big female artist, by a LONG shot. 

 

Hence it was the most successful globally. 

MLIYL deserves a spot here i agree. But it wasnt more successful than ROL anywhere Or Maybe Germany? 

[MadOnHer]

Even though this exact thread has been done to death...

 

1. Ray Of Light

2. The Velvet Rope

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

3. Butterfly

[Raptus]

Why is Butterfly always grouped  with these 2? It's not experimental and lyrically it's a typical Mariah album. Velvet/Ray>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> fried-butter