base talk Rank Their Sophomore Albums: Selena, Ariana, Lorde, Halsey, Doja, Dua, Billie, Olivia

[SimpleKindofLife]

GUTS (maybe it’s the recency bias but I really enjoy this album)

Future Nostalgia

Hot Pink

Happier Than Ever

Melodrama

My Everything

hopeless fountain kingdom

Revival

Edited November 7, 2023 by SimpleKindofLife

[ariesgroove]

1. happier than ever

2. melodrama

3. future nostalgia 

4. guts

5. my everything 

6. hot pink

7. hopeless fountain kingdom

8. revival

[99sandthe2000s]

 Hot Pink

 Happier Than Ever

 My Everything = Future Nostalgia (TIE)

GUTS

[Aaron]

These all kinda aged like milk  

FN is doctor’s office/grocery store music and I never understood the Melodrama hype. Halsey shouldn’t even still be being discussed on this site. 

I guess I like GUTS the most. HTE, Revival, Hot Pink, and ME are okay. 

Edited November 7, 2023 by Aaron

[OnlyManInTheWorld]

GUTS, Melodrama and Future Nostalgia >>>>>

[badgirlriri]

Melodrama/HTE best

Halsey worst

[Robburro]

A Year Without Rain > Revival

[DawnAnti]

How is revival selena’s second album when she has tons before it 💀

[DawnAnti]

Best : future nostalgia 

worst : revival 

[Sabrina Carpenter]

Melodrama > Happier Than Ever > Hot Pink > Future Nostalgia > Revival > hfk > My Everything > Guts

Edited November 8, 2023 by Sabrina Carpenter

[Timeless]

1. Melodrama
2. Future Nostalgia
3. Revival
4. GUTS
5. Happier Than Ever
6. Hot Pink
7. My Everything

[secretgarden]

All garbage, but from best to worst imo

 

My Everything > Future Nostalgia > Hot Pink > Melodrama > Revival > HFK > HTE  > GUTS

 

 

[Kimi]

Melodrama best Guts worst

[Reverse Warholian]

HTE > Melodrama > FN > HFK > Guts > HP > ME > Revival 

 

HTE and Melodrama are the best without a doubt. I still don't love either. 

 

FN was a major improvement over DL and I guess the most fun to experience among the batch. 

 

HFK is my least favorite Halsey album but has some sentimental gems. 

 

HP was my proper introduction to Doja, but I'm not crazy about any deep cuts. 

 

The production / instrumentation on ME and Revival aged like iceberg lettuce. Their support here are nothing more than a stan service  

 

I kinda don't use any of them atm though except some of Guts since it's recent