poll Tate Vs Sabrina Vs Olivia: Biggest in 3 years time?

[georgechxng]

y'all need to stop comparing those two to olivia. she's clearly leagues ahead the other two. it's almost offensive. 

[Walk_Away21]

On 11/3/2023 at 2:56 PM, ScorpiosGroove said:

that sabrina girl will never fully take off, Tate is just screaming fad and olivia eh, the hype for her has already massively declined after only 2 albums so let's see

 

On 11/3/2023 at 3:00 PM, Timeless said:

It's too early to tell for Tate. It all depends on how well her next album performs. If it's a smash, she could be a future main pop girl for sure.

 

Sabrina Carpenter has been in the game for almost 10 years and still hasn't taken off fully. I think it's pretty much it for her  

 

Olivia Rodrigo will undoubtedly be the biggest out of the three. 

 

On 11/3/2023 at 3:01 PM, KatyPrismSpirit said:

Sabrina will never take off

Tate needs to play her cards right and drop a really good album to become a serious contender 

Olivia is obviously the biggest 

 

On 11/3/2023 at 3:08 PM, Cain said:

Tate and Sabrina will never see Olivia's heights cmon now 

 

On 11/3/2023 at 4:19 PM, fememeist said:

Sabrina is such a basic white woman. Ariana Grande prototype. 

 

Olivia >> tate >>>> GAYLE >>> sabrina

 

On 11/3/2023 at 4:23 PM, Obsession said:

Olivia

Tate

Sabrina 

 

On 11/3/2023 at 4:40 PM, unclefloprry said:

tate

the other 2 are faceless acts

 

On 11/3/2023 at 11:19 PM, Cain said:

Sure, but what will not happen is Sabrina Carpeter or Tate McRae getting an era as big as SOUR

[glitch]

On 11/5/2023 at 11:00 AM, glitch said:

I mean Katy didn't get her first hit until she was about 7 years into her career

Edited June 8 by glitch

[halcyonday]

On 11/4/2023 at 4:19 AM, Cain said:

Sure, but what will not happen is Sabrina Carpeter or Tate McRae getting an era as big as SOUR

bestie...

[Riverbank]

Olivia being over being the only statement that still holds true

 

[RoseBud]

 

Keep crying.....

[fememeist]

3 hours ago, RoseBud said:

 

Keep crying.....

Espresso not even as half as big as drivers license or g4u, but we still got the premature bump

[Frappucino]

Prolly Olivia if she keeps the momentum going for her next album but I'm rooting for Tate 

[Letemtalk]

Olivia and Billie made it without the backing of big name producers/co-writers to make their albums for them. Sabrina is a basic white girl with 5 albums, which had some big name collaborators, and she now appears to be getting a big push by people in the industry.

 

Has she ever done a song by herself with just one co-writer/producer?

 

Even this latest one with Jack Antonoff appeared to need another co-writer "Amy Allen" and Amy has worked with Harry Styles, Tate McRae, Justin Bieber, Halsey, Shawn Mendes, Selena Gomez, Camila Cabello and other big name artists.

 

People compare Sabrina to Taylor Swift, but the similarity is skin deep. Taylor had the song writing talent which gave her a lot of independence.

Sabrina Carpenter will be 28 in three years, and I'm not sure if the payola will continue for that long.

 

Not sure about Tate, but I'm expecting Olivia to be the biggest if she wants to be.

[Walk_Away21]

11 minutes ago, fememeist said:

Espresso not even as half as big as drivers license or g4u, but we still got the premature bump

You were saying? Olivia just had 0 competition because of covid .

 

 

[Papi Juancho]

right now
Sabrina > Tate > Oliv 

[Letemtalk]

15 minutes ago, Walk_Away21 said:

Olivia just had 0 competition because of covid .

Are you seriously suggesting that releasing in early January is a good strategy for getting a big hit? Or that releasing two days after the storming of the United States Capitol, when all the news channels and social media were talking non stop about Trump and the insurrection, that was a great time to release a new pop song?

 

She had to beat Justin Bieber, Ariana Grande, The Weeknd, Morgan Wallen, Dua Lipa and others with her debut single.

I'm not sure how that is 0 competition.

[Lightbringer007]

Olivia will be here for a long time, her debut album has had a long lasting impact in the music industry to this day. She'll be good

 

Sabrina has been gaining everything little by little these last few years, and now is where she's really being realized. Could see her last as well as long as she keeps on making great music 

 

Tate has potential as well, albeit wish she was more active in promoting other songs non-greedy like run for the hills! She just needs to remain consistent and creative 

[Hereforthemess]

Question: how big of a hits were feather and nonsense worldwide? I know it were hits in the us but I've never heard those songs anywhere in Europe.

 

also with songs 'easily' hitting 8+ million stream the last couple of months, i wonder how high would greedy's numbers be if tate released it now

[Raphy23]

Tate at age 20 still has so much potential. I know she's currently on a world tour but she needs to drop a summer banger immediately. 

[wsurferwayne]

On 11/5/2023 at 5:46 PM, wsurferwayne said:

For Tate, if she continues the greedy sound for her next album, she could potentially have her loose/future nostalgia era

For olivia, if she switch to elctro-pop sound like how taylor did with 1989, OR3 will be her 1989

For sabrina, she may have her my everything era if her team does all the payola and the pre-released singles

 

In 3 years time my prediction will be

Top 2: olivia and tate

#3 will be sabrina

now the tables have turned 9 months later

 

sabrina managed to score 3 consecutive global hits from her latest album, she and her team really played it well!!!

 

whereas tate ruined her momentum

 

top 2: olivia and sabrina (it depends on how OR3 or SC7 will perform)

#3 tate

[Rihinvention]

If Tate can deliver a solid album that's not just 1 hit single and 12 filler tracks, I think the three of them will be pretty on par.

 

Olivia eventually needs to prove she can reinvent/try something new. Sabrina needs to prove she can sustain momentum. Tate just needs to keep doing what she's doing by giving people the 2000s Britney fantasy that we've been missing for so long.

 

Out of all of them, I find Tate the most exciting. She's the one I look at and think, "Oh, POP STARS are so back." She tried the singer-songwriter thing too, but her dance training is such a unique selling point for her as a pop star.

[RoseBud]

 

  Well in three years both Olivia and Tate will be 24 and Sabrina will be 28.  Sabrina will always be the smallest though 

[supertiffany]

On 11/4/2023 at 2:47 AM, JoJo said:

Olivia still has a solid fanbase and a sold out arena tour. She'll still be one of the biggest pop girls in a couple years even if she doesn't reach the heights of SOUR again.
 

Greedy is a hit and Tate's upcoming single sounds like a smash, but she still is a faceless artist here in the US. Hopefully that'll change, but who knows?

 

I can see Sabrina getting her biggest hit next year, but I don't think she'll reach MPG status. She'll likely have a dedicated fanbase and a moderate hit like Nonsense every now and then. 

 

On 11/4/2023 at 2:56 AM, ScorpiosGroove said:

that sabrina girl will never fully take off, Tate is just screaming fad and olivia eh, the hype for her has already massively declined after only 2 albums so let's see

 

On 11/4/2023 at 3:00 AM, Timeless said:

It's too early to tell for Tate. It all depends on how well her next album performs. If it's a smash, she could be a future main pop girl for sure.

 

Sabrina Carpenter has been in the game for almost 10 years and still hasn't taken off fully. I think it's pretty much it for her  

 

Olivia Rodrigo will undoubtedly be the biggest out of the three. 

 

On 11/4/2023 at 3:01 AM, KatyPrismSpirit said:

Sabrina will never take off

Tate needs to play her cards right and drop a really good album to become a serious contender 

Olivia is obviously the biggest 

 

Sabrina just proved y'all wrong

[Walk_Away21]

2 minutes ago, supertiffany said:

 

 

 

 

Sabrina just proved y'all wrong

Whack them again for me

 

[Soda Pop Queen]

I went with Sabrina, only because she's been doing music longer than the other two and she just now popping off 10 years (and so many albums) in. The persistence and dedication is obviously there and now that she's seeing success, she's probably not gonna go quietly. When an artist is a fully grown person with years of experience pounding the pavement, they tend to handle their first successes and their careers better.

[Alex]

Sabrina is clearly in it for the long run (if it wasn't clear enough already) so obviously things are only going up for her from here and she's already the biggest of the three now, partly thanks to her phenomenal marketing and heavy investment. Plus she has the motivation to break out of the "flop girl" allegations even further that have been following her career up until this era. 

Tate also seems to be prepping a big comeback for her third album and has been focusing on touring for the past year, but I don't trust RCA to not screw this next era up in some capacity.

Olivia seemed to have peaked with her debut album commercially, but she might overcompensate next era to try and fix that, so as much as I want to, I guess I can't count her out yet. 

 

 

[punisher]

it was obvious sabrina was gonna smash since feather. maybe in 2-3 years sabrina will be the biggest, but if she keeps making that vanilla pop music she wont have the same longevity as olivia. its too early to tell though.

sabrina needs to attend some songwriting classes though cause her lyricism is bad for someone who has been releasing albums for 9 years

[wsurferwayne]

5 hours ago, Alex said:

Sabrina is clearly in it for the long run (if it wasn't clear enough already) so obviously things are only going up for her from here and she's already the biggest of the three now, partly thanks to her phenomenal marketing and heavy investment. Plus she has the motivation to break out of the "flop girl" allegations even further that have been following her career up until this era. 

Tate also seems to be prepping a big comeback for her third album and has been focusing on touring for the past year, but I don't trust RCA to not screw this next era up in some capacity.

Olivia seemed to have peaked with her debut album commercially, but she might overcompensate next era to try and fix that, so as much as I want to, I guess I can't count her out yet. 

 

 

OR3 could possibly her Red/HMHAS era if olivia and her team play their cards right

 

For tate, she should consider switching labels, from RCA to either republic or Colombia.

 

for sabrina, sc7 could possibly be her "arts not charts" era, album will have more acclaim compared to short n sweet and do well as a whole even though it does not have any espresso sized hits

it also depends on sabrina and her team if they play their cards right

Edited August 31 by wsurferwayne

[Poptart89]

6 hours ago, punisher said:

it was obvious sabrina was gonna smash since feather. maybe in 2-3 years sabrina will be the biggest, but if she keeps making that vanilla pop music she wont have the same longevity as olivia. its too early to tell though.

sabrina needs to attend some songwriting classes though cause her lyricism is bad for someone who has been releasing albums for 9 years

I think her whole thing, lyrically, is fun and cheeky. Singing double entendres with a coy vocal wink. And she's gotten a lot of critical praise for that. It's currently a strong suit.
 

The issue I see is that that's not a long term strategy. It works when you're the hot new 20-something. But it doesn't work when you're 35 or 45. She's found a niche that works for now, but she'll need to be able to evolve and not get trapped in what worked for her during her breakout year (lest she fall victim to a Katy Perry type fate).

Edited August 31 by Poptart89