poll Tate Vs Sabrina Vs Olivia: Biggest in 3 years time?

[Power love]

Olivia
Sabrina

 

 

 

 

 Tate 

[GentleDance]

8 minutes ago, unclefloprry said:

tate

the other 2 are faceless acts

[Sad Serenade]

Olivia is the biggest one right now with the most successful music and bigger base. 

[Beyonnaise]

I think by then Tate will be the biggest hitmaker, Sabrina will have the most consistent fanbase and Olivia will be over.

 

The SOUR to GUTS decline is stunning, even Alanis felt bigger with Supposed Former Infatuation Junkie.

Edited November 3, 2023 by Beyonnaise

[Raphy23]

7 hours ago, Cain said:

Tate and Sabrina will never see Olivia’s heights cmon now 

A lot can happen in 3 years. 

[Raphy23]

7 hours ago, CorbynBlessing said:

Tate? idk her.

She sings mega smash You Broke Me First, and greedy. And moderate smashes She’s All I Wanna Be and 10:35. 

Edited November 4, 2023 by Raphy23

[Cain]

24 minutes ago, Raphy23 said:

A lot can happen in 3 years. 

Sure, but what will not happen is Sabrina Carpeter or Tate McRae getting an era as big as SOUR

[Raphy23]

19 minutes ago, Cain said:

Sure, but what will not happen is Sabrina Carpeter or Tate McRae getting an era as big as SOUR

Sure. But Tate could have a FN type of era. Catchy bops with lots of airplay and payola support helping it succeed. 

[MingYouToo]

Honestly its a mixed bag imo. Olivia has a solid fanbase but her lane and sound just doesn't scream MPG longevity. Pop-rock was a cute novel moment but if she continues down this path she'll head to the same fields as Billie Eilish: big album and touring force with an occasional hit every other year. 

 

Tate and Sabrina is where I think the iffy part is, truth is from a marketing standpoint they occupy very similar niches. Sure Sabrina is more creative and peppy in her step but Tate can do everything Sabrina does while still giving prime Britney-level choreo. We haven't seen that in a white popgirl since... well, Britney. Where its gonna come down to is if Tate's label will go Dua Lipa-levels hard on promo'ing her next era and if Island Records will pull out all the stops and continue with the pop perfection Sabrina has been serving.

 

Honestly I can see both occupying the MPG sphere, Sabrina feels like a Katy-insert and Tate is giving Britney with her unique tone + amazing performance skills.

 

If you were to ask me on the spot I'd say assuming Olivia commits to the poprock sound, in 3 yrs time she'll enter sub A-list popgirl tier and be still successful, occasional Top 40 hits but no longer have the #1 debut power and scan multiplatinum. Think post-2013 Gaga, 2017 Katy, etc. Tate's label has show much promise as has Sabrina, I can see them being big hitmakers.

[MingYouToo]

5 hours ago, Beyonnaise said:

I think by then Tate will be the biggest hitmaker, Sabrina will have the most consistent fanbase and Olivia will be over.

 

The SOUR to GUTS decline is stunning, even Alanis felt bigger with Supposed Former Infatuation Junkie.

Agree. But I wouldn't say over. Probably like late Chromatica era level Lady Gaga minus Rain on Me.

[nostalgia]

Olivia - our generation’s Gaga

Sabrina - our generation’s Katy

Tate - our generation’s Kesha

 

[Machete]

Tate will probably be scoring random radio fodder hits, while Olivia is over over.

[Halcyon Days]

11 hours ago, Raphy23 said:

In Canada Tate already feels the biggest. She has like 5 major radio hits that constantly play on radio despite being older. And now greedy is just starting to get played more.

 

Tate is in Canada what Olivia is in the US, so I would not at all be surprised if she concurred the rest of the world within 3 years. She needs to get more vulnerable with her personality tho.  

isn't there a law in Canada that states they must play certain % of Canadian music on radio? maybe that's why you hear her more often

[J Legend X]

but why is Olivia in this poll? makes no sense lol...

[Galah]

Olivia will always have her songwriting to fall back on. Even if one of the other two are technically a bigger star at this exact point in the calendar year three years from now, I don't see either of them surpassing what Olivia's already achieved with her first two records.

[elevate]

The answer's as obvious as how everyone knew which kind of stan would make this kind of thread. 

[wsurferwayne]

For Tate, if she continues the greedy sound for her next album, she could potentially have her loose/future nostalgia era

For olivia, if she switch to elctro-pop sound like how taylor did with 1989, OR3 will be her 1989

For sabrina, she may have her my everything era if her team does all the payola and the pre-released singles

 

In 3 years time my prediction will be

Top 2: olivia and tate

#3 will be sabrina

Edited November 5, 2023 by wsurferwayne

[Starkboy]

On 11/4/2023 at 5:08 AM, nostalgia said:

Olivia - our generation’s Gaga

Sabrina - our generation’s Katy

Tate - our generation’s Kesha

 

The disrespect... she literally has 0 top40 hits after 5 albums

[Breakdown]

olivia the biggest, sabrina the best in every way

tate is garbage, she's all i wanna be kinda sounds acceptable though and i guess, she's kind of ambitious 

[glitch]

1 hour ago, Starkboy said:

The disrespect... she literally has 0 top40 hits after 5 albums

I mean Katy didn't get her first hit until she was about 7 years into her career

[Escape]

Olivia Rodrigo

[AvadaKedavra]

Olivia needs to call Max Martin of the Flowers-As It Was producer  she needs a reinvention

[AvadaKedavra]

On 11/4/2023 at 1:15 AM, Halcyon Days said:

isn't there a law in Canada that states they must play certain % of Canadian music on radio? maybe that's why you hear her more often

Thats  a great law and should be mandatory everywhere. Great for countries to support their local acts first  of course only its like 40-30%

[wsurferwayne]

On 11/5/2023 at 5:46 PM, wsurferwayne said:

For Tate, if she continues the greedy sound for her next album, she could potentially have her loose/future nostalgia era

For olivia, if she switch to elctro-pop sound like how taylor did with 1989, OR3 will be her 1989

For sabrina, she may have her my everything era if her team does all the payola and the pre-released singles

 

In 3 years time my prediction will be

Top 2: olivia and tate

#3 will be sabrina

Now i take back my words

1) olivia (hits or not, OR3 will do well)

2) sabrina (after snatching 2 consecutive smash hits with espresso and please x3, short n sweet may be another big MPG era incoming, she may even battle #1 spot with olivia)

3) tate (she could have snatched her 3rd hit with run for the hills)

Edited June 8 by wsurferwayne

[prettyinpink940]

Tate