poll Best/Worst re-recordings vault

[burninredhot]

What in your opinion are the best/worst set of vault tracks?

[Monster Queen]

Red > 1989 > Fearless > Speak Now

[rebeltwat]

They're all kind of useless besides Red, which are mostly stronger than half the original album. Speak Now's was definitely the worst. I Can See You had literally zero resemblance to SN's sound or genre, what saved it was it being a semi bop. 

[Selegend]

most of them have one amazing track and thats it. 

 

different from most people, 1989 the vault wasn't what i was expecting but i find it cohesive and enjoyable as a whole so it wins for me 

the other 3 have 1 or 2 tracks that i love and that's it 

 

[Raphy23]

Speak Now disappointed me so much. I was expecting heavier rock vibes (like Haunted and Eyes Open) knowing the features were Paramore and Fall Out Boy, and we got that fluff instead

 

I very much enjoy 1989. 

[1989]

1989 = Speak Now > Fearless > Red 

[Feanor]

'RED' >> '1989' >> 'Fearless' >> 'Speak Now'

[Vixen Eyes]

Red > Speak Now > 1989 > Fearless

[naval23]

RED is the best

 

1989 is worst

[TaggedGalaxy]

Red>>>>>>> 1989 > Speak Now > Fearless

[Bloo]

Red is the only standout one. 
 

I think 1989 and SN are usable. The only song from Fearless I’ll listen to is Mr. Perfectly Fine. 

[MidnightsAtPeace]

Red >>> Speak Now >> 1989 >>> Fearless

 

Red vault tracks are some of her best songs and almost half of them are career highlights. 10s all across the board. She will never top these vault tracks with newer vault tracks. 

 

Speak Now vault tracks are great too, though they may not be better than the original songs on the album, but they are still great. Timeless and Foolish One are 10/10 songs btw.

 

1989 vault tracks don't feel like 1989 songs, but they're still enjoyable and fun. Say Don't Go and NTWDT are perfect.

 

Fearless vault tracks are cute ig. I personally love Don't You. Mr. Perfectly Fine and That's When are song that I listen to every now and then, and I really don't care about the rest of them.

[americanlife]

Speak Now > Red > 1989 > Fearless

[Queen Of Slay]

RED > Speak Now > Fearless > Nineteen SNOOZTY Nine

[PrismaticOwen]

red > 1989 > fearless > speak now

[Mau]

I think Fearless and Red are both amazing vaults, they represent the album well and most of the songs could very well be on the standard albums replacing other songs.

 

Mr Perfectly Fine, Bye Bye Baby, Better Man, Nothing New, ATW10MV are all highlights and unfortunately there's no such song on the last two vaults. 

 

Both Speak Now and 1989 vaults left me a little disappointed, they're... mid and I don't think they really belong to the album, at least sonically. 

 

Maybe it's because I always loved SN and 1989 so I had higher expectations for them, but that's how I feel about them. 

 

Red > Fearless >>>>>>>>>>> Speak Now > 1989

 

Ngl I'm scared for Rep vault tracks

 

 

 

[shookspeare]

Speak Now > Red > Fearless> 1989

 

 

It's genuinely shocking to me that so many of you all are ranking SN last, gems like Timeless, When Emma Falls In Love, and I Can See You absolutely wash the other vaults

[NumbSoul]

For me: Red > Speak Now > 1989 > Fearless

[RihannaLoverrr]

Speak Now winning the worst poll when it has Timeless, Castles Crumble & I Can See You 

 

 

Red's is the best though. 

[Maroonx]

Best: Red

Worst: 1989/Fearless

[naval23]

Message in a Bottle is her best vault track and that's on that 

[Treason]

Red
Speak Now

1989

Fearless

[Treason]

17 minutes ago, RihannaLoverrr said:

Speak Now winning the worst poll when it has Timeless, Castles Crumble & I Can See You 

 

Literally. But we knew ATRL had no taste

[Achilles.]

All Too Well 10

Better Man

Timeless

Forever Winter

Say Don’t Go

 

Nothing New

Now That We Don’t Talk

Is It Over Now

Don’t You

I Can See You

 

Foolish One

Sl*t!

When Emma Falls In Love

Castles Crumbling

Mr Perfectly Fine

 

We Were Happy

Electric Touch

Suburban Legends

Babe

I Bet You Think About Me

 

Run

Bye Bye Baby

The Very First Night

Message in a Bottle

That’s When

 

You All Over Me

 

 

The entire bottom 6 is Fearless and Red, but Fearless has no songs in the top 5 while Red has the top 2. So Fearless gets the vote for worst. I don’t think I want to give Red my vote for best, even though it has the top 2 and the most in the top 10. I’ll go with Speak Now, which I feel is the best in overall average quality, and has the songs that best feel like a companion / continuation of the original album. 

[ZIVERT]

idk about best or worst vaults as a whole, but what I do know is that this song went #1 for 5 months in an alternate universe