poll Plastic Hearts vs. Chromatica; bigger album?

[Aethereal]

Chromatica has significantly higher pure sales than Plastic Hearts, while Plastic Hearts has more streams in Spotify. 

The overall estimates for Chromatica are at 650K WW, Plastic Heart doesn't have  any estimates revealed but it is probably much lower. 

 

Chromatica - 2,444,299,771

Plastic Hearts - 3,035,693,700

 

 

So it is a tough call. I believe PL will end up being the bigger one even if it is not now given that it has much better recurrent streams. 

 

 

[Post Malone]

The one BLACKPINK touched 

[PMM]

chromatica is bigger but PH is better

[josesuxx]

Plastic Hearts is both bigger and better 

[Wildcat]

Plastic Hearts - 2,234,225

Chromatica - 647,417

 

PH is bigger and better.

[HEAVYONIT]

The one that had a capactiy record-breaking football stadium tour alongside it 

[By the Water]

PH has a 600M streams lead that's only getting bigger. No amount of jockstraps can make up for that

 

[Mr. Stratus]

Chromatica for now but PH will overtake . Honestly? It’s  the more versatile timeless album. Chromatica is more for core Gaga fans that wanted a TF tea 

[Achilles.]

27 minutes ago, Aristotle said:

Chromatica has significantly higher pure sales

The way that’s courtesy of her selling ticket bundles during covid.

[thismoment]

Plastic Hearts is better and bigger than the jockstrap album 

[Bloodflowers.]

I'm gonna go with the "Gimme What I Want" containing album

 

 

[Aethereal]

2 minutes ago, Achilles. said:

The way that’s courtesy of her selling ticket bundles during covid.

Did ticket bundles have a radical influence on Chromatica's pure sales? Someone provide receipts, please.

[Sonny]

The one that debuted at #1, had a #1 single, BLACKPINK touched and had jockstraps as merch.

[DoubleRainbow!]

PH bigger and waaay better 

[Timeless]

Unfortunately, Chromatica is the bigger album. Rain On Me alone is bigger than any Plastic Hearts song let's be realistic here. But I still voted for Plastic Hearts because it deserves love 

[Moloko Plus]

Chromatica. Walk up to a group of random gays and not a single one will know what ‘Plastic Hearts’ is but they’ll all know what Chromatica is lmao. Miley’s era started and ended with the generic Flowers.

[Smarticle]

Why not compare it to ESV since u have all the OGHs swarming already ?

[ChrisTheLoner]

7 minutes ago, Moloko Plus said:

Chromatica. Walk up to a group of random gays and not a single one will know what ‘Plastic Hearts’ is but they’ll all know what Chromatica is lmao. Miley’s era started and ended with the generic Flowers.

If you're gonna try dragging Plastic Hearts at least get the lead single right (It's Midnight Sky)

 

ot: Plastic Hearts is bigger and better 

[Moloko Plus]

1 minute ago, ChrisTheLoner said:

If you're gonna try dragging Plastic Hearts at least get the lead single right (It's Midnight Sky)

 

ot: Plastic Hearts is bigger and better 

It’s all forgettable anyways chile

[Aethereal]

1 minute ago, Smarticle said:

Why not compare it to ESV?

PL is objectively bigger than ESV. The pure sales for ESV are somewhat bigger compared to PL but the gap in streams is too big and ESV will fall behind PL in daily streaming within some months.

[ChrisTheLoner]

1 minute ago, Moloko Plus said:

It’s all forgettable anyways chile

[Scars]

Plastic Hearts has a much bigger lead on streaming, which is only getting even bigger. It also has more certifications worldwide. Longevity will always win over quick peaks.

 

Plastic Hearts - 3,035,693,700  (+2,234,225 daily streams)

Chromatica - 2,444,299,771  (+647,417)

 

Edited October 23, 2023 by Scars

[Rev8]

I mean it's obviously Chromatica

 

but if both had the same opportunities, PH would've stood bigger probably

or at least equal

[Smarticle]

3 minutes ago, Aristotle said:

PL is objectively bigger than ESV. The pure sales for ESV are somewhat bigger compared to PL but the gap in streams is too big and ESV will fall behind PL in daily streaming within some months.

ESV being a quick lil peak with Flowers

[JoeAg]

both are excellent albums! honestly, maybe i'm in the minority, but I prefer Chromatica, it feels like the highlights are more evenly distributed, while Plastic Hearts is front-heavy

 

I think Chromatica is just SLIGHTLY bigger