discussion PokéRate: The Original Generation [Finale : Pg #100 - End]

[Magickarp]

PLA ICON

 

[Gourgeist]

1 minute ago, Hey Dude said:

Ponyta is top 20 material oh my God 

If this was a gen 5 rate maybe

 

[poki]

This in the top 75 

 

[Graves]

11 minutes ago, TaggedGalaxy said:

Rhydon is kinda iconic I should have given her a higher score

 

 

the way the reactions to this post have changed like four times from hearts to confused faces to laugh faces oml y'all messy

[poki]

Voltorb - #150

Ghastly - Top 75

 

 

C'mon...

[Canon]

#73 : Sandshrew

Final Score : 6.16

-

Rated 15

n/a

 

Rated 0

n/a

 

Comments:

 5 - Death to ground pokemon - Love Again

 

7 - Minds her business, never involved in drama, serves above average porcupine realness and stays in her lane. - BoyLikeYouSuxx

 

10 - Icon - Hey Dude

10 - I have an emotional bonding with him i guess this is the first pokemon i ever saw in my live. I remember the pokemon card i saw and i was so excited. - Funnyfatty

 

Score Breakdown

[Desire]

Justice for Ponyta! 

[Graves]

Sand is cutest Gen 1 pokemon, no contest.

[plaidarms]

1 minute ago, Canon said:

#73 : Sandshrew

Final Score : 6.16

-

Rated 15

n/a

 

Rated 0

n/a

 

Comments:

 5 - Death to ground pokemon - Love Again

 

7 - Minds her business, never involved in drama, serves above average porcupine realness and stays in her lane. - BoyLikeYouSuxx

 

10 - Icon - Hey Dude

10 - I have an emotional bonding with him i guess this is the first pokemon i ever saw in my live. I remember the pokemon card i saw and i was so excited. - Funnyfatty

 

Score Breakdown

Deserved better

[panochita]

Charinocent closer and closer to top 50 

[Katamari]

7 minutes ago, Hey Dude said:

This in the top 75 

 

Gastly is infinitely more useful than the fire horse and serves top 30 for that alone  

[Almodusa]

Yeah the Sandshrew line is very UwU 

They mind their business. The capybara of Pokémon me thinks 

[PMM]

6 minutes ago, Hey Dude said:

Voltorb - #150

Ghastly - Top 75

 

 

C'mon...

really?

ask yourself: which pokemon is better for gameplay in gen 1

there were only 3 ghost type pokemons while for electric everyboyd was using electabuzz 

[Canon]

#72 : Wartortle

Final Score : 6.18

-

Rated 15

n/a

 

Rated 0

n/a

 

Comments:

5 - No flavor - Panochita
 

Score Breakdown

[Graves]

Ivysaur best middle stage? Wbk.

[Almodusa]

Ugly WART

[Graves]

Also, Wartortle ain't bad or anything, but why give him the weird ears and tail and then take it away again when he evolves?

[Canon]

Since wartortle is kind of a non-event, lemme post a spicier reveal  

[Canon]

#71 : Kadabra

Final Score : 6.2

-

Rated 15

n/a

 

Rated 0

n/a

 

Comments:

n/a
 

Score Breakdown

[Almodusa]

Abra and Alakazam >

[Canon]

Just now, sugrbby666 said:

Cadaver is even more of a non-event I fear

She cleared Gen 1 runs even without having to get Alakazam tho 

[PMM]

i love abra line. kadabra should be higher

[Heldenzeit]

24 minutes ago, Hey Dude said:

So a literal circle is top 75 because it's Ghost type. Cool. 

I love to see you fume. 

[Canon]

#70 : Persian

Final Score : 6.22

-

Rated 15

n/a

 

Rated 0

n/a

 

Comments:

1 - Trash - Hey Dude

 

7 - missed opportunity for a Psychic/Normal powerhouse, then making her Giovanni's right hand in the anime despite being a nonfactor... I'm just confused - BoyLikeYouSuxx

 

10 - Ugh so elegant and beautiful. It is criminal what they did to it’s regional form with that puffy head. - AbeHicks
 

Score Breakdown

[Graves]

them: hey, can you draw a persian just from memory?

 

me: