poll Rank: Toxic, Crazy in Love, Umbrella, Bad Romance, Dark Horse, Blank Space

[Treason]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Edited October 10, 2023 by Taeyong

[Achilles.]

Blank Space - Bad Romance - Crazy In Love

Umbrella

Toxic

Dark Horse

[Treason]

Best: Toxic

Biggest: Umbrella

Video: Toxic

 

My ranking:

Toxic

Umbrella

Dark Horse

Bad Romance

Crazy in Love

Blank Space

Edited October 9, 2023 by Taeyong

[KarmaCat]

Blank Space is objectively the best song of the bunch.

 

Toxic takes the biggest song and best music video - it’s just a pure classic at this point no contest

[Miichael]

Toxic

Toxic/Umbrella

Toxic/Bad Romance

[ninasayers]

Umbrella

Umbrella

Umbrella

 

 

[G.U.Y.]

Toxic, Dark Horse, Bad Romance

[Mocha]

Parapluie for all 

[glitch]

Crazy in Love, Umbrella and Blank Space are all perfectly crafted pop songs. I'd say CIL edges it for me though.

 

Biggest is difficult to say. I'd say they were all pretty ubiquitous when they came out and everyone would remember them. Maybe Toxic?

 

CIL takes best video for me purely because it was such a great introduction to Beyonce as a solo artist.

[Kristie Kuwa]

Blank Space feels like such a nonfactor compared to these other mega smashes

 

[Steve Johnson]

Blank Space for all. BS and Umbrella are easily the most remembered one too. 

[byzantium]

30 minutes ago, Kristie Kuwa said:

Blank Space feels like such a nonfactor compared to these other mega smashes

 

Yet it seems to be the one you are focusing on here.  Go figure. 

[Devin]

Umbrella is def the biggest of the collection. 

[Goaty]

They’re all great pop songs, but Toxic is my favorite. The sample still dazzles me.

Favorite video is Bad Romance. 
 

Biggest is tough - maybe Umbrella? 

[rebeltwat]

Best: Crazy In Love

Biggest: Umbrella

Music Video: Bad Romance

[Kimi]

Bad Romance best song and video without competition

[jdanton2]

Umbrella

[havewemet]

1 hour ago, KarmaCat said:

Blank Space is objectively the best song of the bunch.

 

Toxic takes the biggest song and best music video - it’s just a pure classic at this point no contest

Blank Space is the worst of these options by a mile, no? Maybe on par with Dark Horse but the rest are stone cold classics.

[luckythisway]

Toxic is neither a better song, nor has a better MV than Bad Romance. Nurse 

[brazil]

Toxic

Toxic/Umbrella

Toxic

[GagaChina]

easy the first female diamond song ever —— BR

[rihannafan]

Two of these don't belong here

[Homebrand]

4 hours ago, KarmaCat said:

Blank Space is objectively the best song of the bunch.

 

Toxic takes the biggest song and best music video - it’s just a pure classic at this point no contest

So many lies in such a short post   

[Funnyfatty]

Even the Katy stans don’t vote for her wtf  is she THAT over? 
 

 

[VioletsandRoses]

Best-Blank Space or CIL

Biggest- Bad Romance (solo diamond and #2 ifpi WW despite being spilt between 2 years)

Dark Horse is the biggest in the US 

Best MV-Bad Romance and Blank Space