base talk Pitchfork: For All the Dogs 6.5 | MC: 47

[Just a Gay on ATRL]

His massive drop in quality in a decade is pretty shocking. I can't believe this is the same guy who released Take Care & Nothing Was the Same. Hell, even Views is a cohesive masterpiece compared to this. The streaming era ruined him - he said charts, not arts and it shows really badly.

[Apolonio ₃₄]

Omg 

 

[theoghon]

SURELY with all the duds scores he's been getting for the past several releases, the critics/gp must be getting something wrong...?

 

I lowkey predict critical REAPPRAISAL for a few of the by them end of the decade 

 

Edited October 8, 2023 by theoghon

[orange22]

For All The DUDS

[Ms. Togekiss]

Everything since CLB has been panned by the GP and even some fans too. I’ve seen nothing but drags on Twitter from the straights that are his core audience 

[Pheromosa]

[DammnBaby]

The AMG review hits the nail on the head. Dire album.

[liquiddiamonds]

Honestly Nevermind was the last time he did something interesting and since that flopped he’s back to what people want from him, which is by the numbers and formulaic. He goes after women and the mentally ill because the skill just isnt there to go after other more talented male rappers 

[cloudbusting]

a 47 when most big names are easily snatching 75-89 releasing almost anything is WILD 

[AvadaKedavra]

Screaming 

[ICLDXU4HS]

Cheers to the freakin' Drake-end
I drink to that, yeah-e-yeah

 

 

[terrorblade]

[Starkboy]

Sounds fair tbh. there are like 4 good songs there

[fijitears]

Not this being lower than Scarlet, what went wrong? 

Edited October 8, 2023 by fijitears

[DoctorIce]

I expect nothing less from the Ed Sheeran of hip-hop.

[naval23]

47 in this era is shocking

 

I wonder if his Twelve Tooth Carat Toothache and Austin era are coming 

[theweekend]

too generous I guess

[worldwide angel]

[KOMH]

The most panned album of the year

[Karla Cabello]

im not listening to that mess but i know it is too high

[modeblock]

panned, fat, and over 

 

love to see it 

[Pheromosa]

Congrats Drake! 

[B-Luke]

Decent score (6.5) from Pitchfork  x

[Wewee]

[Frozen99]

pitchfork gave it 6.5?  clowns.