poll Reputation vs Lover

[ScubaDive]

Better album? 

[Trent W]

This thread is so so overdone

 

I refuse to answer

[ScubaDive]

Just now, Trent W said:

This thread is so so overdone

 

I refuse to answer

I'm new to the site. I was active when Reputation was but I slept on Lover because I wasn't a huge fan then. 

[kimberly]

the one that has Death by a Thousand Cuts on it 

[Revolution]

the one that has Delicate on it 

[PoisonedIvy]

No matter how many times this thread is made, Lover will always LOSE to reputation. 

[magazine]

Reputation is taylor's best album, therefore, it's better than Lover

Duh

 

[Trent W]

4 minutes ago, ScubaDive said:

I'm new to the site. I was active when Reputation was but I slept on Lover because I wasn't a huge fan then. 

No worries I still always vote for Reputa

 

Even with CS and Lover smashing it will always be reputa

[Devin]

[dussel_06]

reputation is definitely one of the best pop albums of all time!

 

But lover is better of course. 

[Goaty]

Rep has fewer lows. I can usually listen to the entire thing w/out skipping any songs. Can’t say that for Lover 

[WitnessOblivia]

Reputation has higher highs, but Lover is more consistent. I prefer Lover.

[50thStateofMind]

CS smashing will not change the answer..it's still Rep

[Michael196]

puta can always have the atrl bubble, since the rest of the world knows which one is superior in every aspect…

[aotearoa]

the one with False God ofc 

[suburbannature]

Her worst albums, but Lover wins since it has higher highs.

 

The writing on these two is laughable.

[chiliam]

Stop making these thread.

Its always Rep.

[KOMH]

Reputation by a LANDSLIDE as we can see from the poll.  

[naval23]

20 minutes ago, ScubaDive said:

I'm new to the site. I was active when Reputation was but I slept on Lover because I wasn't a huge fan then. 

who could blame u tbh 

[KOMH]

2 minutes ago, Michael196 said:

puta can always have the atrl bubble, since the rest of the world knows which one is superior in every aspect…

Bringing charts into this as if Loser isn't THE entry level Taylor Swift album for locals and Tiktokers to get into, hence the palate cleanser designation by Taylor herself  

[Michael196]

10 minutes ago, KOMH said:

Bringing charts into this as if Loser isn't THE entry level Taylor Swift album for locals and Tiktokers to get into, hence the palate cleanser designation by Taylor herself  

I said aspectS, charts is only one of them, but you can CIWYW, matter of a FACT the first half of puta is and will always remain the lowest point of her career 

[byzantium]

Why are we so obsessed about her worst two albums? 

[Tusk]

Let’s be honest.

 

It’s 50/50

[KOMH]

4 minutes ago, Michael196 said:

I said aspectS, charts is only one of them, but you can CIWYW, matter of a FACT the first half of puta is and will always remain the lowest point of her career 

No way you're trying to argue the lowest point of her career as a musician isn't the universally reviled ME!asles and the clunkfests that followed  literally everything attached to that era besides the reputa-sounding Cruel Summer is a CATASTROPHE

[Holiest Dreams]

I don't think there's a big quality difference between them. I have things I dislike and like about both. I voted for reputation just because it's much more cohesive, has less lows, etc but I think Lover's highs are higher. 
 

Both of them won in the end anyway (even if Lover is bigger), I mean they're both smashing globally right now. The way she always wins.

Edited September 29, 2023 by Holiest Dreams