discussion Better director: Robert Eggers vs. Jordan Peele vs. Ari Aster?

[McNulty]

Robert Eggers

The Northman

The Witch

The Lighthouse

 

 

 

Jordan Peele

US

Get Out

Nope

 

 

 

Ari Aster

Hereditary

Midsommar

Beau Is Afraid

 

 

 

The trinity of new Horror Cinema, each of them has 3 movies so far. so who is the better director?

[Johnny Jacobs]

Jordan peele best

 

Us best

 

Worst hereditary 

[RideOrDie]

ari aster. i watched two of robert's movies and i didn't like them and i've only seen nope from jordan which was fine 

[zasderfght]

All three are terrific directors-- I honestly rather judge their work than themselves as directors. 

 

My ranking would go as such (I haven't seen The Northman & I've only seen Nope once, so, this is not a finalized list by any stretch): 

 

1. Midsommar (Director's Cut) 

2. Midsommar (Theatrical Cut) 

3. Us 

4. Hereditary

5. Get Out 

6. The Lighthouse 

7. Nope 

8. Beau is Afraid 

[Uncatena]

this is TOUGH, all three are some of my favorite directors currently working. but each of their current filmography has one movie that is weaker than the others.

 

if I had to rank:

1. Jordan Peele

2. Ari Aster

3. Robert Eggers

 

and their movies:

1. Hereditary

2. Nope

3. The Witch

4. Us

5. The Lighthouse

6. Midsommar

7. Get Out

8. The Northman

9. Beau is Afraid

[vale9001]

Jordan peele 

 

 

.............

 

 

The others two are overrated.

[Draper.]

Voted Ari for best director. I’d say he’s the better director and Jordan is the better writer, but it’s close. Best movie would be between Get Out, Nope, Midsommar, Hereditary and The VVitch, could make a case for any of them but voted for Get Out since it’s the most iconic one. Worst one is definitely The Northman.

Edited September 25, 2023 by Draper.

[Miles.]

All three are great, but for me it's Peele >>> Eggers > Aster

 

Us is my favorite movie out of all those, but I also loved Get Out, Nope and The Witch.

[Lemon]

Ti West clears them. 

 

But if I have to choose - Midsommar would be the best movie here followed by Nope and The VVitch. 

[dussel_06]

Robert Eggers is just on a different level.

 

The Northman alone >>>>>>

 

Hereditary, Us, The Witch and Midsommar are also excellent.

 

I havent seen Beau is Afraid but among the choices, Nope is the worst... by far.

 

 

[KanMap]

Eggers > Aster > Peele

 

The Northman, Hereditary 

Edited September 25, 2023 by KanMap

[Digitalism]

Robert>Jordan>Ari

 

The VVitch is my fav 

The worst is the pretencious BIA

[Brunette Ambition]

Eggert is the best director currently working

Aster is cute, but too letterbox’d

Peele has not one good film, Us and Get Out are AHStories episodes with bigger budget 

[Sanguine]

Beau > The Witch > Hereditary = Get Out >> Midsommar > The Lighthouse >> Us >>>> Nope, haven't seen Northman so Aster for now

[K$Ellie]

The Witch best

The Lighthouse worst by far

still have to watch The Northman but I love everything except The Midthouse

Ari overall

[GraceRandolph]

Ti West>>>> the rest

 

@The Witch 

The way Grace Randolph was right about Ari Aster. 
 

[AllAmericanBitch]

Peele