poll Plastic Hearts vs GUTS

[Treason]

 

[josesuxx]

WTF Do I Know alone is better than GUTS lbr 

[Blue Monday]

This is actually pretty tough because they're both great albums (in Miley's case it's easily her best album cover to cover). That said, GUTS is leaner and doesn't have quite as much filler as PH does, but I prefer the ballads on PH to those on GUTS. 

[Kanes]

WTF Do I Know & Midnight Sky clears.

[Rush]

Gimme What I Want >>>>

[Erreur2 La Nature]

The worst song from PH is probably better than the best song from the other album 

[Mr. Peanutbutter]

Night Crawling alone >>>

[Power love]

Miley are you serious 

[Carrie-is-no-1]

Hard choice. I’ll go with PH. Midnight Sky is still one of the most massively underperformed song of Miley’s career and I thoroughly enjoyed the first half of that album.

 

GUTS will have time to prove itself but right now it’s more consistent but less high of high of PH.

[Lil Mxnster]

This one is tough  I've loved GUTS and I've been playing it 24/7 during last week; however, Plastic Hearts is Miley's best album until now. 

[magazine]

Miley, sweetieeeeee  omg

[KatyPrismSpirit]

Guts is the far superior record. Miley has yet to craft a great record.

[mons†er]

GUTS is cute, but Plastic Hearts is gorgeous.

[Aramis]

MC for all.

[Achilles.]

Obviously Miley. 

[Vixen Eyes]

miley is here ---> 

 

 

 

 

the trash is here ---> 

 

 

 

 

 

hell is here --->  

 

 

 

 

 

Olivia is here ---> 

[UnusualBoy]

Miley takes this one.

[zasderfght]

GUTS > Plastic Hearts 

 

That being said, both albums are listening to, like most people on here are saying. 

 

Also, that one user saying Olivia is worth than trash and hell, can you put out your album so we can see if it's better than GUTS? Go ahead, I'll wait. 

[naval23]

The 75 Metacritic album outquality'd >>>

 

Angels Like You alone 

[Jooj]

Never Be Me alone >>>>>>>

[wish]

Guts is good, but Plastic Hearts is iconic & continues to grow over time

[Pink Whitney]

Love Olivia but let me know when she makes a song as good as Midnight Sky, Plastic Hearts, Never Be Me & Angels Like You 

Edited September 20, 2023 by Pink Whitney

[Pink Whitney]

3 hours ago, KatyPrismSpirit said:

Guts is the far superior record. Miley has yet to craft a great record.

saying this as a Katy stan is crazy

[Into The Void]

Plastic Hearts. Guts is actually not good

[blueberries]

guts