poll Madonna "what it feels like for a girl" vs Xtina "Your Body" vs Gaga Telephone

[Distantconstellation]

Who played the best criminal/killer? This is based on the video not the song. 

 

Madonna "what it feels like for a girl" 

Madonna plays a thief/killer with multiple identities

 

 

Xtina "your body" 

Christina plays a serial killer who seduces men and then murders them

 

 

Lady gaga/Beyonce "telephone"

Lady gaga & Beyonce play serial killers who are on the run.

 

[FreeXone]

What It Feels like for a Girl is a masterpiece. A huge message. 

[bliaz]

WIFLFAG 

[ToMmY]

Madonna snapped with WIFLFAG.

[Mocha]

What It Feels like and the others don't come close although I enjoy Your Body.

[secretgarden]

Madonna ate up with What It FLFAG the others can't compare 

[discosean]

Madonna. The others are not fit to even shine her shoes. 

[ohwow]

the trance remix of "What It Feels Like For A Girl" STOMPS on the others i fear

it also has the best video

Edited September 18, 2023 by ohwow

[superben]

Madonna by far, but Gaga & Xtina produced a lot of memes and gifs at the time of their releases LOL

[Mr. Stratus]

never seen or heard of the first one until now - i didnt think much of it. I mean, if its about acting it wont be madonna

 

Xtina created the computer gif

 

ultimately telephone is still remembered today, had impact, and is a pop culture staple. ATRL please get real

 

Gaga the all rounder.. Gaga wins!

Edited September 18, 2023 by Mr. Stratus

[blown away]

Video-wise it's Telephone > Your Body > What It Feels Like For A Girl for me. I love how camp and messy the Telephone video is, it has a lot of charm to it. On top of that, it's visually great and has some dance scenes (which I love). It has the perfect balance of everything I need in a music video.

 

Your Body is visually even more pleasing than Telephone, but there's less going on to keep me on hooked.

 

I never liked the WIFLFAG video. The message of the song is so beautiful and the video kinda ruins that for me.

She could've done a much better video that actually puts some emphasis on the message of the song.

 

Spoiler

Song wise: Your Body > What It Feels Like For A Girl >>> Telephone.

 

WIFLFAG is a very underrated Madonna song I must add. One of her best post 2000 songs.

 

[GlamSlam]

The absolute FUMES in that one post.

Meanwhile, those with excellent taste will always say Madonna.

[D.Va]

I feel like I'm the only one who HATES this version of What It Feels Like For A Girl, while I of course adore the original. The og version is probably in my top 5 favorite madonna songs 

[Shaner69]

Madonna 

 

Seriously if you watch the videos there is no comparison.

Edited September 18, 2023 by Shaner69

[SinnerCity]

WIFLGAF is a statement

Telephone is a classic

Your Body is a Christina Aguilera video

[Shaner69]

18 minutes ago, D.Va said:

I feel like I'm the only one who HATES this version of What It Feels Like For A Girl, while I of course adore the original. The og version is probably in my top 5 favorite madonna songs 

It's almost like two different songs but she pulled both of them off. 

[HardBambi]

Guy Ritchie 

[Shaner69]

This remix is insane

Edited September 18, 2023 by Shaner69

[Gladiator]

This is my first time seeing that Madonna video and it is immediately my favorite video she's done. It eats up Telephone and Your Body, which are videos I remember watching when they premiered. I think Telephone is too camp for me. I'm not really into camp like that and honestly the murders went above my head in Your Body.

[WEEKND]

Obviously Madonna

[GraceRandolph]

Obviously Godga

[Legend E]

1 hour ago, D.Va said:

I feel like I'm the only one who HATES this version of What It Feels Like For A Girl, while I of course adore the original. The og version is probably in my top 5 favorite madonna songs 

I'm on your side. The original is one of her best songs ever, but the remix ain't it.

 

Telephone wins for me

[Erreur2 La Nature]

The queen of pop

[Marry The Gods]

Madonna 

[Phaunzie]

Your body, even tho WIFLFAG is my favourite song on music