poll Better set of 5 albums: Janet Jackson vs. Madonna

[GlamSlam]

Love Janet, but it's easily Madonna. Her albums are much more diverse, tbh.

Ray of Light alone... 

[Spooky Mulder]

Janet

From that list only Music is better than all for you

[whitehotforever]

4 hours ago, Madonno said:

Madonna for all

 

[Jjang]

Honestly aside from maybe 2 albums all of these serve excellence and it's just a matter of personal taste. I don't have an answer, it really depends on the day for me. 

Edited September 3, 2023 by Jjang

[Kimi]

Madonna clearly

[holyground13]

I slightly prefer Janet's albums but both are great. 

 

Imagine a collaboration  I know they didn't get along in the 90s but it would be a collapse.

[Devin]

Both are great but I’m going with Janet.

 

That 1-2-3-4-5 punch 

[Glamthony]

Madonna.

 

But it would be a tie for me, if Janet's albums had less fillers and less interludes, it's hard to go through some of her albums.

[Mystic Boy]

Madonna and it's not even close ! 

TOO many fillers in miss Jackson discography 

[Mr. Wonder]

It's very telling that Janet's are consecutive while covering the same timeframe of the selected Madonna albums. 

[Oktober Knight]

I'm not the biggest fan of Erotica and ROL (I know - unpopular opinion) so I'm giving this to Janet. 

[DamianSolo]

Janet, without a doubt or second guess. It's just gem after gem... after gem.

[ReH2o]

Miss Jackson

[worldwide angel]

love madonna but janet for all

 

tvr and rol are close calls for obvious reasons but only one queen of pop released empty

 

skin is one of the best songs ever

[Jjang]

13 hours ago, Mr. Wonder said:

It's very telling that Janet's are consecutive while covering the same timeframe of the selected Madonna albums. 

it could have been LAP -> Erotica -> BS -> ROL -> Music and it would have been a better case for Madonna so good luck trying to sound sensical next time. 

[lifeofsucktits]

ROL

TVR

LAP 

Erotica

Rhythm Nation

Janet.

Madonna

Music

Control

All For You

[Power love]

On 9/3/2023 at 12:00 AM, blown away said:

Janet easily. Her first six albums*, up until Damita Jo are straight up gold.

[ebaby]

both mothers I can't decide

[iammadmat]

Madonna for all. 

[KLatz]

Damn, these album runs are iconic! Janet gets the win though solely because I'm not a big fan of the Like a Prayer album

[willmcclure9]

Both mothers and some of the best pop music of all time, but Madonna