base talk Is Beyoncé and Shakira's Longevity impressive?

[shoganai]

Yes and totally deserved. 

[bijonse]

Yes, they’re both still relevant and popular after all this time in a way no other before has been  like I don’t see either of them falling off ever

[Sylpher]

Why would I be impressed with the Renaissamples singer? Get some authenticity!

[Bears01]

54 minutes ago, TheVelvetFg said:

Not when both are incredibly local and Beyoncé is PR-driven and radio driven to the point that the stats don’t hold up

Both have much bigger careers than the girl in your avi, babe 

[Frappucino]

Sure

[Jooj]

1 hour ago, Aristotle said:

Yes but Beyonce's longevity is more impressive, especially considering Renaissance could've done more if it was handled properly. 

Shakira literally repeaked and had 5 back to back hits incluiding 2 of the biggest songs of 2023.

 

Also she debuted before Beyonce. Both have equally impressive longevity.

[Jooj]

1 hour ago, TheVelvetFg said:

And? She’s more of a household name than either one of these 

[Aethereal]

13 hours ago, Jooj said:

Shakira literally repeaked and had 5 back to back hits incluiding 2 of the biggest songs of 2023.

 

Also she debuted before Beyonce. Both have equally impressive longevity.

ST Beyonce 2013 - 9.4M CSPC

ST Shakira 2014 - 2.8M CSPC

 

Lemonade - 6.5M CSPC

El Dorado -  4.8M CSPC

 

[Jooj]

2 hours ago, Aristotle said:

ST Beyonce 2013 - 9.4M CSPC

ST Shakira 2014 - 2.8M CSPC

 

Lemonade - 6.5M CSPC

El Dorado -  4.8M CSPC

 

El Dorado having almost 5M despite being a spanish album 

 

Also, none of these numbers contradict what i said about Shakira repeaking during these last 2 years. In fact, Shakira increasing from ST to ED while Beyonce decreasing from ST to L is actually a self own 

[Aethereal]

1 minute ago, Jooj said:

El Dorado having almost 5M despite being a spanish album 

 

Also, none of these numbers contradict what i said about Shakira repeaking during these last 2 years. In fact, Shakira increasing from ST to ED while Beyonce decreasing from ST to L is actually a self own 

Shakira does better with Spanish albums though. Can't blame the GP though, La Tortura>>>.

 

It would be interesting to see how much Shakira's album would do compared to Renaissance.

[Chris]

Yet they never performed Beautiful Liar live so I don't know about that.