poll Midnights vs Guts

[Enrique523]

Which era do you think will be bigger overall? I'm talking sales, streaming numbers,... and i'm not taking into consideration the Eras Tour and the impact it had on Taylor's back catalogue. Just Midnights alone.

 

Which one will be bigger? Discuss.

[naval23]

the setup. Midnights is literally the biggest era of the decade 

[Kanes]

GUTS isn't even out yet.

[Badgalbriel]

Girl..... 

No era can compete with Midnights this decade. Why would you create a thread like this. 

[Klein]

Maybe we could wait until we've at least listened to GUTS before asking this? 

[PoisonedIvy]

The premature need to compare two women’s albums is wild  Can we HEAR Guts first 

[byzantium]

How is anyone supposed to compare this? 

[Supervillain]

The album isn't out and you were ITCHING to make this thread huh? The way y'all can't resist pitting women against each other is so weird...

[Bosque]

The setup

 

guts not even being out yet

[Proseductice]

This feels intentional to drag Olivia down. They’re both successful. 

[Kern]

This feels intentional to drag Taylor down. They’re both successful. 

[JoJo]

Sorry, but this thread makes no sense. Taylor is the biggest artist in the world, and  Midnights is shaping up to be her biggest album after 1989. The answer is obvious 

[KatyPrismSpirit]

stop comparing a 34 year old with 17 years experience to a 20 year old on her second album pls

[fememeist]

You should’ve done Fearless vs GUTS 

[Mitsuki]

Is there anyone Taylor is not compared with? Tiring 

[DeepEnd]

Judging by the performance of Olivia's first two singles, I think Midnights is the clear winner 

[WEEKND]

Lmao

[Alldeezy]

I dont see Guts doing as well as her debut tbh.

 

But midnights killed it

[Communion]

Not some Swifities' perpetual hatred of everyone who isn't Taylor giving them the power to now time travel. 

[Laura Palmer]

The brain cells really are few and far between here these days…

[Jjang]

Midnights is as big as SOUR and there’s no way Olivia is topping that. 

[Jotham]

[Enrique523]

1 hour ago, Supervillain said:

The album isn't out and you were ITCHING to make this thread huh? The way y'all can't resist pitting women against each other is so weird...

I'm asking people which album they THINK will be more successful, not which one is more successful right now. We can already have an idea based on how the Guts singles are doing.

 

And people make comparisons for fun all the time on this forum, there's no need to take this so personally 

[thatsmydemi]

I doubt Olivia will milk GUTS half as much as Taylor has milked Midnights with singles, remixes, deluxe editions, 2933413 versions... so if GUTS ever comes close to Midnights' success, it would be impressive as ****. 

[Vixen Eyes]

does anyone even genuinely WANT to listen to guts?