poll Winx Club or W.I.T.C.H?

[orange22]

 

VS.

 

 

Edited August 19, 2023 by orange22

[Virgos Groove]

Only one had MOTHER Nerissa.

[Klein]

Enchaaaaaaaaaaantiiiiiiiiiiiix 

[VeniceBeach]

Witch forever

[X~MoviePoP]

Winx. Period. 

 

I wish they didnt ruin the live action show.

[réveuse]

Winx Club >>>>>>

[Freaky Prince]

Is this a joke?  Winx.

[CBC]

Witch but tbf the comics were much better than the show. Not like Winx was bad they also served hard in the show and video games 

 

We stan both of these legendary franchises tho

[popmusicisdead]

i never actually watched the W.I.T.C.H. cartoon but i loved the comics.

[orange22]

W.I.T.C.H. was maybe Disney’s biggest fumble  no live action or an animated reboot? they didn’t even try with the original series at all

[orange22]

12 minutes ago, X~MoviePoP said:

Winx. Period. 

 

I wish they didnt ruin the live action show.

I couldn’t bring myself to even try it after the trailers and clips started coming out  hideous to even look at 

[Odette Violet]

W.I.T.C.H is great but Winx is Peak  Pop culture. They were like the 2nd coming of Sailor Moon globally during the 00's

 

 

 

 

 

Edited August 19, 2023 by Odette Violet

[AxelFox]

19 minutes ago, Freaky Prince said:

Is this a joke?  Winx.

Have you even watched Witch? It's far better. 
 

I love Winx, the designs and aesthetic were so cool at the time, and it made them become such y2k icons! But the show itself is really puerile and silly that even as a kid I remember being baffled by it.
 

Witch is not as flashy but has far superior plot, storylines, characters and world building. I think you can tell even just by watching the first episode of each series.

 

 

 

The difference is night and day.

[Odette Violet]

2 minutes ago, AxelFox said:

Have you even watched Witch? It's far better. 
 

I love Winx, the designs and aesthetic were so cool at the time, and it made them become such y2k icons! But the show itself is really puerile and silly that even as a kid I remember being baffled by it.
 

Witch is not as flashy but has far superior plot, storylines, characters and world building. I think you can tell even just by watching the first episode of each series.

 

 

 

The difference is night and day.

Not you using the butchered Nick version. This is a better comparison  

 

 

As for the character, plot and world building.  Winx had great diversity within the cast ( you have a latina, east asian and black woman in the group ) the world building fused fantasy with sci-fi whereas W.IT.C.H followed the common fantasy settings we see in most fictions and medias 

[Element]

20 minutes ago, orange22 said:

W.I.T.C.H. was maybe Disney’s biggest fumble  no live action or an animated reboot? they didn’t even try with the original series at all

Literally.... they dropped the ball so hard!!!

[Talento]

I remember liking W.I.T.C.H, could never get into the other one though.

[BOOMBAYAH]

Omg both…I can’t pick. Kind of off topic, but I was talking to my friends the other day about how we (all gay men) grew up watching “girls” cartoons and shows and we were having a randomly deep conversation about how watching those shows as young kids was probably for the best even though we all got weird looks for it because so much of it was about kindness, love, friendship, and a strength that we don’t really get from a lot of “boys” cartoons and shows. I remember watching these shows alongside Sailor Moon, Mew Mew Power, etc. and having anxiety of anyone catching me nnn.

[Element]

Loved both of them. I was a bigger W.I.T.C.H. stan though - the four elements aspect inspired my username (as did Avatar)!

[BOOMBAYAH]

Just now, BOOMBAYAH said:

Omg both…I can’t pick. Kind of off topic, but I was talking to my friends the other day about how we (all gay men) grew up watching “girls” cartoons and shows and we were having a randomly deep conversation about how watching those shows as young kids was probably for the best even though we all got weird looks for it because so much of it was about kindness, love, friendship, and a strength that we don’t really get from a lot of “boys” cartoons and shows. I remember watching these shows alongside Sailor Moon, Mew Mew Power, etc. and having anxiety of anyone catching me nnn.

+ gave me that entry level feminism at 8 years old 

[Club classic]

Liking W.I.T.C.H. was the first thing I got called a *** for

Edited August 19, 2023 by sbenci

[BOOMBAYAH]

Just now, sbenci said:

Liking W.I.T.C.H. was the first thing I got called the *** for

I remember watching it and my cousin walked in with his girlfriend and was calling me out for watching “girls” cartoons only for his girlfriend to go off at him and tell me there’s nothing wrong with it  a queen and ally 

[orange22]

3 minutes ago, BOOMBAYAH said:

Omg both…I can’t pick. Kind of off topic, but I was talking to my friends the other day about how we (all gay men) grew up watching “girls” cartoons and shows and we were having a randomly deep conversation about how watching those shows as young kids was probably for the best even though we all got weird looks for it because so much of it was about kindness, love, friendship, and a strength that we don’t really get from a lot of “boys” cartoons and shows. I remember watching these shows alongside Sailor Moon, Mew Mew Power, etc. and having anxiety of anyone catching me nnn.

The straights loved Totally Spies, Kim Possible, etc. too don’t sleep 

[Odette Violet]

 

 

Like how can W.I.T.C.H top this? ENCHANTIX alone clears  

 

 

[orange22]

1 minute ago, Odette Violet said:

 

 

Like how can W.I.T.C.H top this? ENCHANTIX alone clears  

 

 

Everything post-Enchantix got very tacky I fear…

[BOOMBAYAH]

Just now, Odette Violet said:

 

 

Like how can W.I.T.C.H top this? ENCHANTIX alone clears  

 

 

The universal gag when Bloom got her Enchantix…the “Valtor will never win, ever” opening line…the dragon enveloping her body…the FENTY BEUATY eyeshadow…everyone knows where they were and what they were doing at that moment.