Yvess Posted November 30, 2023 Author Posted November 30, 2023 (edited) Now, we are entering the second to the last round of our game and it is just fitting to have this round where we get to see who among you has the most well-rounded ERA! Welcome to the "Battle of the Eras" Round In this round, we will be having three categories, BEST AESTHETICS - BEST SINGLE - BEST LIVE PERFORMANCE for each category - you need to choose a different era from your artist WHAT TO DO: 1st Category: SEND IN THE OFFICIAL ALBUM COVER + 1 PROMOTIONAL PHOTO FROM THAT ERA BEYONCE - RENAISSANCE ERA (2022) THE TOP TWO RANKING PLAYERS IN THIS CATEGORY AUTOMATICALLY GETS A TABS TIARA 2nd Category: SEND IN THE MUSIC VIDEO FOR THE SINGLE FROM YOUR ARTIST'S BEST ERA click the gif for video BEYONCE - SINGLE LADIES - I AM SASHA FIERCE ERA (2009) THE TOP TWO RANKING PLAYERS IN THIS CATEGORY AUTOMATICALLY GETS A TABS TIARA 3rd Category: SEND IN THE BEST LIVE PERFORMANCE DONE BY YOUR ARTIST note: the live performance should be in the same timeline of that era you've chosen. click the gif for video BEYONCE - RUN THE WORLD (GIRLS) LIVE AT THE BBMA 2011 - 4 ERA (2011) THE TOP TWO RANKING PLAYERS IN THIS CATEGORY AUTOMATICALLY GETS A TABS TIARA HOW THE JUDGING WORKS: The judges will rank each category submission from 1-9 1 - 11 2 - 10 3 - 9.5 4 - 9 5 - 8.5 6 - 8 7 - 7.5 8 - 7 9 - 6.5 DEADLINE: DECEMBER 4TH, 12:00 AM EDT @Overprotected @Hey Dude @blackoutbaby @Kylie Verzosa @Dessy @ZORBIT @Legend E @Julia Fox @Invisibility Edited November 30, 2023 by Yvess 2
Yvess Posted November 30, 2023 Author Posted November 30, 2023 so, this is just posted so you guys can use the time to polish your entry more while we also wait for the judges to send in their scores and crits for the current round we have wc is the FASHION BALL
Kern Posted November 30, 2023 Posted November 30, 2023 I GAVE BIRTH … to the scores!! Good luck to yous 👍🏻 Finale is coming
Invisibility Posted December 1, 2023 Posted December 1, 2023 2 hours ago, stupidjock said: I GAVE BIRTH … to the scores!! Good luck to yous 👍🏻 Finale is coming Give us critiques hunny
Julia Fox Posted December 1, 2023 Posted December 1, 2023 2 hours ago, stupidjock said: I GAVE BIRTH … to the scores!! Good luck to yous 👍🏻 Finale is coming okay but where are the crits hunny
EriKills Posted December 1, 2023 Posted December 1, 2023 EriKills Critiques Music Video Moment Madonna - it's a very pretty flamenco dress, wish we could see the corset a little better since it's so gorgeous but I love the drama captured in this shot + the styling is great!! The polka dots are a little fugly but that's the only complaint I have. Rosalia - the "SLAY?!!" in the screenshot aksldjfjf we love subliminal messaging!!! The giant cross as the centerpiece, the all blue denim + fur coat, bell bottoms....like everything about this outfit is truly a "SLAY?!!" indeed tbh! Rihanna - Hmmm I think the outfit is cute....I like the coat but the rest of the outfit feels a little bit pedestrian, like something you'd find at the mall... not really a "fashion moment" especially coming after Rosalia's similarly blue denim look. Mariah Carey - Love the color and material of the outfit! It's super interesting, fun and bright. I do just wish the skirt gave a little bit more, like if it was a bit more highwaisted, or a fuller skirt to even out the proportions of the top. Ciara - You picked a great gif to highlight the strengths of this outfit, the flowiness of the dress is gorgeous and I love the color on Ci. The dress itself just looks a smidge off the rack which takes away from the "fashion moment" aspect of the outfit. Tinashe - Oh this is a SERVE!!! I love that the outfit gives us a CONCEPT, Little Bo Peep couture, the structure, the pearls, this is a fashion moment for sure!! Shakira - Oh Shakira looks STUNNING. She oozes sex appeal despite showing no skin, the outfit is tailored well, and I love the color. Another outfit where it gives "fashion moment" Kelly Clarkson - I'm not "wowed" but its certainly not a bad dress by any means. Kelly looks good here, it's simple, cute. FKA Twigs - I loveeee this color on her. It's a very interesting outfit, the bagginess of the sleeves/bottoms contrasting against the skin. I don't know that I LOVE the outfit, I go from thinking it's ugly to appreciating it's uniqueness. I appreciate the risk you took with this choice and it definitely gives fashion MOMENT over some of the other entries. Red Carpet Moment Madonna - Such a good look! I love the risque titties popping out, the thigh high boots, the accessories. The gothic vibes work well on Madonna!!! Rosalia - the head to toe print - a fashion MOMENT! This is a great outfit of her being fashionable while still maintaining - and elevating - her staple streetwear style + it stands out as being the only non dress of this round. Rihanna - queen of the red carpet fashion!! This is perfection, the diamonds from head to toe, on a see through dress at that. Such a stunning outfit. Mariah Carey - it doesn't scream "fashion moment" but this is definitely one of Mariah's best looks. The mermaid dress silhouette, the slimming black, it's classic and simple but she looks great. Ciara - Oh wow the material! LOVE the unconventional feel of the outfit, she looks gorgeous. Wish she had picked a better shoe though nnnn Tinashe - LOVEEE the drama of that big ass bow!! Latex is always a fun material and the bright pink makes this memorable and a "fashion moment" . She could have used a different purse but I love the rest of this outfit! Shakira - the accessories are kind of my favorite part of this outfit. Love the glasses, the purse, the shoes like she really really ate with those. I think the dress itself is cute...not the most exciting but she looks good and hot. Kelly Clarkson - nnn, the shoulders are a bit ill fitting, and not her toes peaking behind the drapes, cmon out dont be shy ladies!!! Can't quite determine if I love or hate the fringe, but it's definitely a very interesting outfit!!! FKA Twigs - Oh STUNNING!!! The veil serves drama, she looks so ethereal here. Love this. Fashion Editorial Moment Madonna - oh wow she's giving GODDESS. I love the headpiece, the angles, the outfit. It's giving budgetttt, she slayed this! Rosalia - Hmmm, this might be your weakest entry this round tbh. The white background is a bit jarring, I love the skin showing yes queen!! but the outfit itself is just okay. It feels a little lackluster especially for being all gold. Rihanna - I've never loved this photoshoot tbh it gives budget but its a bit too busy, Rihanna's beauty is hidden in this shot, the editing is really bad too and Rihanna looks bored. Since we're judging the outfits though, I will say that the headpiece is really nice, and i LOVE that puffy coat moment. Mariah Carey - whew the RISK TAKING!!! Well this IS a fashion moment, it's by far the most memorable picture of the round. The way she matched her outfit with the setting...exactly..... This really is a fun shot and she's trailblazing the comfort glamour sector of the fashion industry. Also idk why but the white ankle socks took me out ajkdfsdf Ciara - Oh this is such a SERVE. The butterflies holding her hair is giving editorial, it wouldn't work anywhere else besides on print. I loveee the outfit too, like we're not used to turtleneck dresses from ADIDAS. Very strong entry, loved this!! Tinashe - The posing - yup!!!! The highlight is definitely her hair, so stun, the outfit itself is cute, the blue with brown together works well, it's a very interesting outfit. Shakira - The posing - yup!!!! [2] I will say though, this feels more like a music video still or an outfit from a tour rather than "fashion editorial". The outfit's a bit too simple and there's not really a concept going on like a lot of the other entries. This doesn't quite give "fashion moment" IMO. Kelly Clarkson - The candid shot oh wow! It's giving punk rock cowgirl, the boots and the ruffly dress are certainly an interesting pairing!!! I love the color. FKA Twigs - FKA serving yet another high fashion look!!! This looks like it was picked fresh from a runway, you definitely made sure to choose a photo that clearly highlighted a fashion forward outfit, and she looks so stunning! @Hey Dude @Kylie Verzosa @blackoutbaby @Overprotected @Dessy @ZORBIT @Julia Fox @Legend E @Invisibility @Yvess 3 1
Yvess Posted December 1, 2023 Author Posted December 1, 2023 7 minutes ago, EriKills said: EriKills Critiques Music Video Moment Madonna - it's a very pretty flamenco dress, wish we could see the corset a little better since it's so gorgeous but I love the drama captured in this shot + the styling is great!! The polka dots are a little fugly but that's the only complaint I have. Rosalia - the "SLAY?!!" in the screenshot aksldjfjf we love subliminal messaging!!! The giant cross as the centerpiece, the all blue denim + fur coat, bell bottoms....like everything about this outfit is truly a "SLAY?!!" indeed tbh! Rihanna - Hmmm I think the outfit is cute....I like the coat but the rest of the outfit feels a little bit pedestrian, like something you'd find at the mall... not really a "fashion moment" especially coming after Rosalia's similarly blue denim look. Mariah Carey - Love the color and material of the outfit! It's super interesting, fun and bright. I do just wish the skirt gave a little bit more, like if it was a bit more highwaisted, or a fuller skirt to even out the proportions of the top. Ciara - You picked a great gif to highlight the strengths of this outfit, the flowiness of the dress is gorgeous and I love the color on Ci. The dress itself just looks a smidge off the rack which takes away from the "fashion moment" aspect of the outfit. Tinashe - Oh this is a SERVE!!! I love that the outfit gives us a CONCEPT, Little Bo Peep couture, the structure, the pearls, this is a fashion moment for sure!! Shakira - Oh Shakira looks STUNNING. She oozes sex appeal despite showing no skin, the outfit is tailored well, and I love the color. Another outfit where it gives "fashion moment" Kelly Clarkson - I'm not "wowed" but its certainly not a bad dress by any means. Kelly looks good here, it's simple, cute. FKA Twigs - I loveeee this color on her. It's a very interesting outfit, the bagginess of the sleeves/bottoms contrasting against the skin. I don't know that I LOVE the outfit, I go from thinking it's ugly to appreciating it's uniqueness. I appreciate the risk you took with this choice and it definitely gives fashion MOMENT over some of the other entries. Red Carpet Moment Madonna - Such a good look! I love the risque titties popping out, the thigh high boots, the accessories. The gothic vibes work well on Madonna!!! Rosalia - the head to toe print - a fashion MOMENT! This is a great outfit of her being fashionable while still maintaining - and elevating - her staple streetwear style + it stands out as being the only non dress of this round. Rihanna - queen of the red carpet fashion!! This is perfection, the diamonds from head to toe, on a see through dress at that. Such a stunning outfit. Mariah Carey - it doesn't scream "fashion moment" but this is definitely one of Mariah's best looks. The mermaid dress silhouette, the slimming black, it's classic and simple but she looks great. Ciara - Oh wow the material! LOVE the unconventional feel of the outfit, she looks gorgeous. Wish she had picked a better shoe though nnnn Tinashe - LOVEEE the drama of that big ass bow!! Latex is always a fun material and the bright pink makes this memorable and a "fashion moment" . She could have used a different purse but I love the rest of this outfit! Shakira - the accessories are kind of my favorite part of this outfit. Love the glasses, the purse, the shoes like she really really ate with those. I think the dress itself is cute...not the most exciting but she looks good and hot. Kelly Clarkson - nnn, the shoulders are a bit ill fitting, and not her toes peaking behind the drapes, cmon out dont be shy ladies!!! Can't quite determine if I love or hate the fringe, but it's definitely a very interesting outfit!!! FKA Twigs - Oh STUNNING!!! The veil serves drama, she looks so ethereal here. Love this. Fashion Editorial Moment Madonna - oh wow she's giving GODDESS. I love the headpiece, the angles, the outfit. It's giving budgetttt, she slayed this! Rosalia - Hmmm, this might be your weakest entry this round tbh. The white background is a bit jarring, I love the skin showing yes queen!! but the outfit itself is just okay. It feels a little lackluster especially for being all gold. Rihanna - I've never loved this photoshoot tbh it gives budget but its a bit too busy, Rihanna's beauty is hidden in this shot, the editing is really bad too and Rihanna looks bored. Since we're judging the outfits though, I will say that the headpiece is really nice, and i LOVE that puffy coat moment. Mariah Carey - whew the RISK TAKING!!! Well this IS a fashion moment, it's by far the most memorable picture of the round. The way she matched her outfit with the setting...exactly..... This really is a fun shot and she's trailblazing the comfort glamour sector of the fashion industry. Also idk why but the white ankle socks took me out ajkdfsdf Ciara - Oh this is such a SERVE. The butterflies holding her hair is giving editorial, it wouldn't work anywhere else besides on print. I loveee the outfit too, like we're not used to turtleneck dresses from ADIDAS. Very strong entry, loved this!! Tinashe - The posing - yup!!!! The highlight is definitely her hair, so stun, the outfit itself is cute, the blue with brown together works well, it's a very interesting outfit. Shakira - The posing - yup!!!! [2] I will say though, this feels more like a music video still or an outfit from a tour rather than "fashion editorial". The outfit's a bit too simple and there's not really a concept going on like a lot of the other entries. This doesn't quite give "fashion moment" IMO. Kelly Clarkson - The candid shot oh wow! It's giving punk rock cowgirl, the boots and the ruffly dress are certainly an interesting pairing!!! I love the color. FKA Twigs - FKA serving yet another high fashion look!!! This looks like it was picked fresh from a runway, you definitely made sure to choose a photo that clearly highlighted a fashion forward outfit, and she looks so stunning! @Hey Dude @Kylie Verzosa @blackoutbaby @Overprotected @Dessy @ZORBIT @Julia Fox @Legend E @Invisibility @Yvess thank you so much for the critiques sis!
poki Posted December 1, 2023 Posted December 1, 2023 Rosalia - The top is really cool I've never thought of using a cross that way! Rihanna - The 3 pieces work really good together to give a modern twist on the double denim style. Mariah Carey - I like how even the purse matches the main outfit's texture that's a really good detail. Ciara - This gif is really good to show the movement of the dress, the floral feel of the dress really fits with the nature environment. Tinashe - Interesting spin on a Victorian dress! The hat accessories are a good detail. I also like that you included the shoes. Shakira - Very sleek and modern Kelly Clarkson - This reminds me of a dress I really like in Sims 4 City Living. I like the matching gold elements, good detail. FKA Twigs - I can feel Xtina inspo for this one, the oversized coat contrasts good with the pants. Rosalia - This reminds me of that one E! episode about the louis vuitton pattern back in 2006, the patterns works good on the clothes. Rihanna - Roaring 20s glam! The see-through section really elevates the dress. Mariah Carey - A very nice dress, I like the subtle striped pattern on it, adds depth to it. Ciara - I love the concept of symmetry in asymmetry. I also like how the heels continue the theme of sharp lines the dress creates. Tinashe - Hiya Barbie! It's a really fun dress and the bow really seals the deal. Shakira - I have such a soft spot for tinted glasses like this. Adds a cool futuristic vibe. The heels are really interesting I didn't notice at first how tall they are. Kelly Clarkson - I love the details on the sleeves and the end of the dress, probably flows really nice IRL. FKA Twigs - The texture is incredible on this dress. Rosalia - Interesting take on a mermaid! The bottom texture looks really detailed. Rihanna - It's amazing how much effort went into her look. Mariah Carey - I love how she fit the color scheme of her outfit to that of Hello Kitty. Ciara - I love the whimsy vibe of the butterflies. Such a cool spin on having your head in the clouds but her outfit shows she is still down to earth. This is really artistic. Tinashe - This is a really interesting look, I also like her pose it seals the deal of the striking vibe of the outfit. Shakira - I like the different poses and those oversized boots are something I've never seen before. Kelly Clarkson - I love the shade of purple and the softness of the dress, a good contrast to the hard leather texture of her shoes, showcases how Kelly can be confident yet emotional and approachable as well. FKA Twigs - Gosh that dress is to die for. I love bandana textures and black & white patterns like this. @Overprotected @Hey Dude @blackoutbaby @Kylie Verzosa @Dessy @ZORBIT @Legend E @Julia Fox @Invisibility 5
ATRL Moderator Legend E Posted December 1, 2023 ATRL Moderator Posted December 1, 2023 PoKi slay judge wbk 2
Kylie Verzosa Posted December 1, 2023 Posted December 1, 2023 (edited) 1 hour ago, EriKills said: EriKills Critiques Music Video Moment Madonna - it's a very pretty flamenco dress, wish we could see the corset a little better since it's so gorgeous but I love the drama captured in this shot + the styling is great!! The polka dots are a little fugly but that's the only complaint I have. Rosalia - the "SLAY?!!" in the screenshot aksldjfjf we love subliminal messaging!!! The giant cross as the centerpiece, the all blue denim + fur coat, bell bottoms....like everything about this outfit is truly a "SLAY?!!" indeed tbh! Rihanna - Hmmm I think the outfit is cute....I like the coat but the rest of the outfit feels a little bit pedestrian, like something you'd find at the mall... not really a "fashion moment" especially coming after Rosalia's similarly blue denim look. Mariah Carey - Love the color and material of the outfit! It's super interesting, fun and bright. I do just wish the skirt gave a little bit more, like if it was a bit more highwaisted, or a fuller skirt to even out the proportions of the top. Ciara - You picked a great gif to highlight the strengths of this outfit, the flowiness of the dress is gorgeous and I love the color on Ci. The dress itself just looks a smidge off the rack which takes away from the "fashion moment" aspect of the outfit. Tinashe - Oh this is a SERVE!!! I love that the outfit gives us a CONCEPT, Little Bo Peep couture, the structure, the pearls, this is a fashion moment for sure!! Shakira - Oh Shakira looks STUNNING. She oozes sex appeal despite showing no skin, the outfit is tailored well, and I love the color. Another outfit where it gives "fashion moment" Kelly Clarkson - I'm not "wowed" but its certainly not a bad dress by any means. Kelly looks good here, it's simple, cute. FKA Twigs - I loveeee this color on her. It's a very interesting outfit, the bagginess of the sleeves/bottoms contrasting against the skin. I don't know that I LOVE the outfit, I go from thinking it's ugly to appreciating it's uniqueness. I appreciate the risk you took with this choice and it definitely gives fashion MOMENT over some of the other entries. Red Carpet Moment Madonna - Such a good look! I love the risque titties popping out, the thigh high boots, the accessories. The gothic vibes work well on Madonna!!! Rosalia - the head to toe print - a fashion MOMENT! This is a great outfit of her being fashionable while still maintaining - and elevating - her staple streetwear style + it stands out as being the only non dress of this round. Rihanna - queen of the red carpet fashion!! This is perfection, the diamonds from head to toe, on a see through dress at that. Such a stunning outfit. Mariah Carey - it doesn't scream "fashion moment" but this is definitely one of Mariah's best looks. The mermaid dress silhouette, the slimming black, it's classic and simple but she looks great. Ciara - Oh wow the material! LOVE the unconventional feel of the outfit, she looks gorgeous. Wish she had picked a better shoe though nnnn Tinashe - LOVEEE the drama of that big ass bow!! Latex is always a fun material and the bright pink makes this memorable and a "fashion moment" . She could have used a different purse but I love the rest of this outfit! Shakira - the accessories are kind of my favorite part of this outfit. Love the glasses, the purse, the shoes like she really really ate with those. I think the dress itself is cute...not the most exciting but she looks good and hot. Kelly Clarkson - nnn, the shoulders are a bit ill fitting, and not her toes peaking behind the drapes, cmon out dont be shy ladies!!! Can't quite determine if I love or hate the fringe, but it's definitely a very interesting outfit!!! FKA Twigs - Oh STUNNING!!! The veil serves drama, she looks so ethereal here. Love this. Fashion Editorial Moment Madonna - oh wow she's giving GODDESS. I love the headpiece, the angles, the outfit. It's giving budgetttt, she slayed this! Rosalia - Hmmm, this might be your weakest entry this round tbh. The white background is a bit jarring, I love the skin showing yes queen!! but the outfit itself is just okay. It feels a little lackluster especially for being all gold. Rihanna - I've never loved this photoshoot tbh it gives budget but its a bit too busy, Rihanna's beauty is hidden in this shot, the editing is really bad too and Rihanna looks bored. Since we're judging the outfits though, I will say that the headpiece is really nice, and i LOVE that puffy coat moment. Mariah Carey - whew the RISK TAKING!!! Well this IS a fashion moment, it's by far the most memorable picture of the round. The way she matched her outfit with the setting...exactly..... This really is a fun shot and she's trailblazing the comfort glamour sector of the fashion industry. Also idk why but the white ankle socks took me out ajkdfsdf Ciara - Oh this is such a SERVE. The butterflies holding her hair is giving editorial, it wouldn't work anywhere else besides on print. I loveee the outfit too, like we're not used to turtleneck dresses from ADIDAS. Very strong entry, loved this!! Tinashe - The posing - yup!!!! The highlight is definitely her hair, so stun, the outfit itself is cute, the blue with brown together works well, it's a very interesting outfit. Shakira - The posing - yup!!!! [2] I will say though, this feels more like a music video still or an outfit from a tour rather than "fashion editorial". The outfit's a bit too simple and there's not really a concept going on like a lot of the other entries. This doesn't quite give "fashion moment" IMO. Kelly Clarkson - The candid shot oh wow! It's giving punk rock cowgirl, the boots and the ruffly dress are certainly an interesting pairing!!! I love the color. FKA Twigs - FKA serving yet another high fashion look!!! This looks like it was picked fresh from a runway, you definitely made sure to choose a photo that clearly highlighted a fashion forward outfit, and she looks so stunning! @Hey Dude @Kylie Verzosa @blackoutbaby @Overprotected @Dessy @ZORBIT @Julia Fox @Legend E @Invisibility @Yvess Thanks for redeeming yourself this round papi. I love you again Edited December 1, 2023 by Kylie Verzosa
blackoutbaby Posted December 1, 2023 Posted December 1, 2023 1 hour ago, EriKills said: EriKills Critiques Music Video Moment Madonna - it's a very pretty flamenco dress, wish we could see the corset a little better since it's so gorgeous but I love the drama captured in this shot + the styling is great!! The polka dots are a little fugly but that's the only complaint I have. Rosalia - the "SLAY?!!" in the screenshot aksldjfjf we love subliminal messaging!!! The giant cross as the centerpiece, the all blue denim + fur coat, bell bottoms....like everything about this outfit is truly a "SLAY?!!" indeed tbh! Rihanna - Hmmm I think the outfit is cute....I like the coat but the rest of the outfit feels a little bit pedestrian, like something you'd find at the mall... not really a "fashion moment" especially coming after Rosalia's similarly blue denim look. Mariah Carey - Love the color and material of the outfit! It's super interesting, fun and bright. I do just wish the skirt gave a little bit more, like if it was a bit more highwaisted, or a fuller skirt to even out the proportions of the top. Ciara - You picked a great gif to highlight the strengths of this outfit, the flowiness of the dress is gorgeous and I love the color on Ci. The dress itself just looks a smidge off the rack which takes away from the "fashion moment" aspect of the outfit. Tinashe - Oh this is a SERVE!!! I love that the outfit gives us a CONCEPT, Little Bo Peep couture, the structure, the pearls, this is a fashion moment for sure!! Shakira - Oh Shakira looks STUNNING. She oozes sex appeal despite showing no skin, the outfit is tailored well, and I love the color. Another outfit where it gives "fashion moment" Kelly Clarkson - I'm not "wowed" but its certainly not a bad dress by any means. Kelly looks good here, it's simple, cute. FKA Twigs - I loveeee this color on her. It's a very interesting outfit, the bagginess of the sleeves/bottoms contrasting against the skin. I don't know that I LOVE the outfit, I go from thinking it's ugly to appreciating it's uniqueness. I appreciate the risk you took with this choice and it definitely gives fashion MOMENT over some of the other entries. Red Carpet Moment Madonna - Such a good look! I love the risque titties popping out, the thigh high boots, the accessories. The gothic vibes work well on Madonna!!! Rosalia - the head to toe print - a fashion MOMENT! This is a great outfit of her being fashionable while still maintaining - and elevating - her staple streetwear style + it stands out as being the only non dress of this round. Rihanna - queen of the red carpet fashion!! This is perfection, the diamonds from head to toe, on a see through dress at that. Such a stunning outfit. Mariah Carey - it doesn't scream "fashion moment" but this is definitely one of Mariah's best looks. The mermaid dress silhouette, the slimming black, it's classic and simple but she looks great. Ciara - Oh wow the material! LOVE the unconventional feel of the outfit, she looks gorgeous. Wish she had picked a better shoe though nnnn Tinashe - LOVEEE the drama of that big ass bow!! Latex is always a fun material and the bright pink makes this memorable and a "fashion moment" . She could have used a different purse but I love the rest of this outfit! Shakira - the accessories are kind of my favorite part of this outfit. Love the glasses, the purse, the shoes like she really really ate with those. I think the dress itself is cute...not the most exciting but she looks good and hot. Kelly Clarkson - nnn, the shoulders are a bit ill fitting, and not her toes peaking behind the drapes, cmon out dont be shy ladies!!! Can't quite determine if I love or hate the fringe, but it's definitely a very interesting outfit!!! FKA Twigs - Oh STUNNING!!! The veil serves drama, she looks so ethereal here. Love this. Fashion Editorial Moment Madonna - oh wow she's giving GODDESS. I love the headpiece, the angles, the outfit. It's giving budgetttt, she slayed this! Rosalia - Hmmm, this might be your weakest entry this round tbh. The white background is a bit jarring, I love the skin showing yes queen!! but the outfit itself is just okay. It feels a little lackluster especially for being all gold. Rihanna - I've never loved this photoshoot tbh it gives budget but its a bit too busy, Rihanna's beauty is hidden in this shot, the editing is really bad too and Rihanna looks bored. Since we're judging the outfits though, I will say that the headpiece is really nice, and i LOVE that puffy coat moment. Mariah Carey - whew the RISK TAKING!!! Well this IS a fashion moment, it's by far the most memorable picture of the round. The way she matched her outfit with the setting...exactly..... This really is a fun shot and she's trailblazing the comfort glamour sector of the fashion industry. Also idk why but the white ankle socks took me out ajkdfsdf Ciara - Oh this is such a SERVE. The butterflies holding her hair is giving editorial, it wouldn't work anywhere else besides on print. I loveee the outfit too, like we're not used to turtleneck dresses from ADIDAS. Very strong entry, loved this!! Tinashe - The posing - yup!!!! The highlight is definitely her hair, so stun, the outfit itself is cute, the blue with brown together works well, it's a very interesting outfit. Shakira - The posing - yup!!!! [2] I will say though, this feels more like a music video still or an outfit from a tour rather than "fashion editorial". The outfit's a bit too simple and there's not really a concept going on like a lot of the other entries. This doesn't quite give "fashion moment" IMO. Kelly Clarkson - The candid shot oh wow! It's giving punk rock cowgirl, the boots and the ruffly dress are certainly an interesting pairing!!! I love the color. FKA Twigs - FKA serving yet another high fashion look!!! This looks like it was picked fresh from a runway, you definitely made sure to choose a photo that clearly highlighted a fashion forward outfit, and she looks so stunning! @Hey Dude @Kylie Verzosa @blackoutbaby @Overprotected @Dessy @ZORBIT @Julia Fox @Legend E @Invisibility @Yvess Now I wanna fight
Kern Posted December 1, 2023 Posted December 1, 2023 the ever rotating roster of guest judges will post crits and we old hags can finally rest
CBC Posted December 1, 2023 Posted December 1, 2023 3 hours ago, stupidjock said: the ever rotating roster of guest judges will post crits and we old hags can finally rest cvnty move by madonna when she hasn't won yet wow
Kern Posted December 1, 2023 Posted December 1, 2023 54 minutes ago, CBC said: cvnty move by madonna when she hasn't won yet wow it's all about legacy
Yvess Posted December 1, 2023 Author Posted December 1, 2023 hello players esp to the players who are asking for critiques from the judges, next round is the final two rounds of the game til we reach finale so i am hoping to also see those. i already requested the resident judges to post their critiques if they can during those final two rounds plus one finale round. hopefully they hear me out. if not, I've done my best already. sorry in advance. thank you for all of your efforts and I can't wait to know who wins this game so I can finally do an atrl hiatus xoxo
Yvess Posted December 1, 2023 Author Posted December 1, 2023 anyways just waiting for @MusicLoverDude then I'll do the results also, happy 10th or 15th year anniversary on atrl legend xoxo
Kylie Verzosa Posted December 1, 2023 Posted December 1, 2023 56 minutes ago, Yvess said: hello players esp to the players who are asking for critiques from the judges, next round is the final two rounds of the game til we reach finale so i am hoping to also see those. i already requested the resident judges to post their critiques if they can during those final two rounds plus one finale round. hopefully they hear me out. if not, I've done my best already. sorry in advance. thank you for all of your efforts and I can't wait to know who wins this game so I can finally do an atrl hiatus xoxo Well you don't need to wait??
MusicLoverDude Posted December 1, 2023 Posted December 1, 2023 5 hours ago, Yvess said: anyways just waiting for @MusicLoverDude then I'll do the results also, happy 10th or 15th year anniversary on atrl legend xoxo Sorry for being so fashionably late. Tonight. I promise.
Invisibility Posted December 2, 2023 Posted December 2, 2023 8 hours ago, MusicLoverDude said: It's 15th anniversary btw happy annivHERsary!
MusicLoverDude Posted December 2, 2023 Posted December 2, 2023 12 minutes ago, Invisibility said: happy annivHERsary! I"m a dude and I have always identified as one... 1
Invisibility Posted December 2, 2023 Posted December 2, 2023 28 minutes ago, MusicLoverDude said: I"m a dude and I have always identified as one...
.thumb.gif.018912544cc5638eccd695a87c978b14.gif)
Recommended Posts