base talk Better Selena album: When The Sun Goes Down vs Stars Dance

[Josh]

[305]

Stars Dance sweetie...

 

Slow Down

 

Stars Dance

 

C&GI

 

Undercover

 

Nobody Does It Like You

 

Music Feels Better

[Selegend]

When The Sun Goes Down is teen pop perfection. It is honestly my fave teen pop album ever. 
 

Stars Dance was also a fun time to stan her, the 2 singles are amazing and still goes hard. But it does sound dated (not the singles, the album). So WTSGD wins. 

Edited May 26, 2023 by Selegend

[livelikemusic]

I don't consider When the Sun Goes Down a Selena Gomez album, given it was with the Scene, honestly.

[Michael196]

WTSGD sweetie...

the single great song on SD is slow down

meanwhile WTSGD got: who says, my dilemma, hit the lights, title track and the incredible we own the night!

[MALAMENTE]

1 minute ago, Michael196 said:

WTSGD sweetie...

the single great song on SD is slow down

meanwhile WTSGD got: who says, my dilemma, hit the lights, title track and the incredible we own the night!

And the classic Love You Like A Love Song, hello

- 

OT: WTSGD

[Venice B]

WTSGD has one of the best pop songs ever made aka Love You Like A Love Song so 

[DawnAnti]

Excluding like 2 or 3 songs both these albums are so bad 

[AdrianNicki]

Her magnum opus - When the Sun Goes Down. No skips, besides That's More Like It

[Royal Culture]

Nobody Does It Like You and Undercover alone sell Stars Dance for me, but WTSGD has aged so well

[Happylittlepunk]

I pick stars dance because imo some of those songs hit hard espcially if you getting ready to go to the clubs. 
 

birthday, slow down, undercover etc. 

 

stars dance the song is amazing it feels like selena  is performing in a space opera for a inter space audience. 
 

like a champion and come and get it feel memorable and Catchy. 

[Vixen Eyes]

i think?

 

Love You Like A Love Song vs Birthday

Bang Bang Bang vs Slow Down

Who Says vs Stars Dance

We Own The Night vs Like A Champion

Hit The Lights vs Come & Get It

Whiplash vs Forget Forever

When The Sun Goes Down vs Save The Day

My Dilemma vs B.E.A.T.

That's More Like It vs Write Your Name

Outlaw vs Undercover

Middle Of Nowhere vs Love Will Remember

 

but overall id say Stars Dance since my CD has four bonus tracks <3

[Sad Serenade]

When the sun goes down has many bops: hit the lights, my dilemma, love you like a love song, who says, whiplash,outlaw etc 

 

 

[StarsAllAligned]

5 hours ago, 305 said:

Stars Dance sweetie...

 

Slow Down

 

Stars Dance

 

C&GI

 

Undercover

 

Nobody Does It Like You

 

Music Feels Better Save The Day

Bop after bop 

[StarsAllAligned]

5 hours ago, AdrianNicki said:

Her magnum opus - When the Sun Goes Down. No skips, besides That's More Like It

Also taste, right down to the only skip 

[FightDragonsWithMe]

Anyone voting Stars Dance has no taste. We Own The Night, My Dilemma, Outlaw, Love You Like a Love Song >>>>>

[UnusualBoy]

Probably WTSGD since the only good songs on SD are the title track and Slow Down.

[Taylor fanboy]

WTSGD as an album.

 

Save The Day and CG&I devours every other song though.

[Kiss It Better]

Stars Dance is her best album

[Keeandga]

WTSGD has Dilemma but Stars Dance has the title track. 

[northwest]

Both are good but WTSGD is better. Love You Like A Love Song alone >>

[Julia Fox]

Love You Like A Love Song vs Birthday

Bang Bang Bang vs Slow Down

Who Says vs Stars Dance

We Own The Night vs Like A Champion

Hit The Lights vs Come & Get It

Whiplash vs Forget Forever

When The Sun Goes Down vs Save The Day

My Dilemma vs B.E.A.T.

That's More Like It vs Write Your Name

Outlaw vs Undercover

Middle Of Nowhere vs Love Will Remember

 

SD has Nobody Does It Like You which is her best song ever so…

[aesthetic bih]

WTSGD still feels fresh imo

 

Stars Done overdone the EDM and made a lot of the songs sounded dated

[aesthetic bih]

Love You Like A Love Song vs Birthday

Bang Bang Bang vs Slow Down

Who Says vs Stars Dance

We Own The Night vs Like A Champion

Hit The Lights vs Come & Get It

Whiplash vs Forget Forever

When The Sun Goes Down vs Save The Day

My Dilemma vs B.E.A.T.

That's More Like It vs Write Your Name

Outlaw vs Undercover

Middle Of Nowhere vs Love Will Remember

 

 

 

[Achilles.]

Easily WTSGD, even if Stars Dance does have three of her best songs (C&GI, Slow Down, title track).