track BLACKPINK - "The Girls"

[whirly]

Honestly... The other version might be better  I think it's a demo by Chaennie when they went to LA because it has Rosé (and someone else) but no Lisoo

Edited August 23, 2023 by whirly

[k.money]

11 minutes ago, whirly said:

Honestly... The other version might be better  I think it's a demo by Chaennie when they went to LA because it has those 2 (and other singers) but no Lisoo

I’ll just insert Lisa’s rap 💅🏼 and make my own version. 

[whirly]

4 minutes ago, k.money said:

I’ll just insert Lisa’s rap 💅🏼 and make my own version. 

I'm sat here listening to both at the same time, one in each ear  I prefer the original verse and Lisa could've easily copied that instead of whatever fast rap they decided to give her instead

[Post Malone]

There's no Jennie on that

And I'm thinking it's not Rose either

[whirly]

7 minutes ago, Post Malone said:

There's no Jennie on that

And I'm thinking it's not Rose either

Rosé's voice is so easy to spot and it's identical in both versions. But I agree it's not Jennie

Edited August 23, 2023 by whirly

[Post Malone]

3 minutes ago, whirly said:

Rosé's voice is so easy to spot and it's identical in both versions. But I agree it's not Jennie

It's not identical, it's actually quite different 

If it is her it's giving cursed, her still having vocals in Dua's solo K&MU demo tease

[whirly]

4 minutes ago, Post Malone said:

It's not identical, it's actually quite different 

If it is her it's giving cursed, her still having vocals in Dua's solo K&MU demo tease

Alright I'm gonna need other people to chime in because that sounds identical to me

[k.money]

11 minutes ago, whirly said:

Alright I'm gonna need other people to chime in because that sounds identical to me

The 3:31 is 100% a demo singer.

 

Intro is definitely not Jennie.

Pre-Chorus is definitely Rose.

 

Chorus is combination of "not Jennie" and Rose.

 

From what I recall, Rose was in the studio with him Ryan Tedder at some point, but IDK if any of the other girls were with them.

 

Listening again to the 3:31 version with headphones, it sounds like an edit. It goes from Outro/Empty Bridge at 2:39 back to the pre-chorus with off timing.

There's no Rose pre-chorus after the second verse, and the final chorus that it ends with has a different instrumental.

 

All that said, I don't know where the 2:38 one came from. It's them, but it doesn't sound finished. I can only assume it was released in game...?

Edited August 23, 2023 by k.money

[whirly]

21 minutes ago, k.money said:

The 3:31 is 100% a demo singer.

 

Intro is definitely not Jennie.

Pre-Chorus is definitely Rose.

 

Chorus is combination of "not Jennie" and Rose.

 

From what I recall, Rose was in the studio with him Ryan Tedder at some point, but IDK if any of the other girls were with them.

 

Listening again to the 3:31 version with headphones, it sounds like an edit. It goes from Outro/Empty Bridge at 2:39 back to the pre-chorus with off timing.

There's no Rose pre-chorus after the second verse, and the final chorus that it ends with has a different instrumental.

 

All that said, I don't know where the 2:38 one came from. It's them, but it doesn't sound finished. I can only assume it was released in game...?

Yeah the shorter one was released in-game and is releasing on digitals Friday 12am EST

[SchmoodRing]

On 7/5/2023 at 6:24 AM, Adama said:

oh wow! But hope it's not Bebe Rhexa 

She could honestly write them a good song and anyone would do anything to have a feature with them so. They did end up using one of her songs from her last album so you never know. 

On 7/5/2023 at 8:25 AM, whirly said:

Hold on so you're telling me that they got a featured artist on a song that's an OST for their own mobile game and that most people believe won't be on Spotify etc? 

 

Oh and for the love of god I hope the full version doesn't have Jennie's recycled "blackpink in your area" line from Boombayah in it like the MV teaser did.  

Yeah I think they learned their lesson from the rightful backlash that they got from ready to love. Instead of investing time effort and energy into a video game that nobody wants give us more music. Also not you complaining about them using their group slogan/catch phrase. 

On 7/5/2023 at 10:23 AM, whirly said:

Also, it's an animated music video with digital avatars. What are they gonna do, create another digital character for a featured artist? For the Blackpink game? It doesn't make much sense

Just have them.avatars dancing to the featured artists verse simple

On 7/16/2023 at 12:31 PM, Axel. said:

I don't even care if they release it or not at this point 

Yet here you are 

 

[whirly]

6 minutes ago, SchmoodRing said:

Also not you complaining about them using their group slogan/catch phrase. 

It ain't about them using their catch phrase. It's about the producer reusing the same recording from their debut song instead of something new. Every other song they've never reused an old recording

Edited August 23, 2023 by whirly

[Josh]

3 minutes ago, whirly said:

It ain't about them using their catch phrase. It's about them reusing the same recording from their debut song when every other time they've used it it's been a new recording for the new song

that intro tagline is deffo from BOOMBAYAH 

[SchmoodRing]

On 7/26/2023 at 11:33 AM, k.money said:

Honestly we could almost be so lucky at this point.

I love BP, but the sad, short discography is NOT it for 7 years as a group.

 

I'd prefer to actually see some solo stuff from them as opposed to them being so restricted from releasing literally anything.

 

(With the amount of money the bring YG and the amount of money and endorsements they have, there's zero way they won't sign)

Can they do more collaborations with them being features on other people's songs so that we can finally in some way get more music from them

[SchmoodRing]

26 minutes ago, whirly said:

It ain't about them using their catch phrase. It's about the producer reusing the same recording from their debut song instead of something new. Every other song they've never reused an old recording

Do we know for a fact that was the case or are we just assuming 

[k.money]

 

8 minutes ago, SchmoodRing said:

Can they do more collaborations with them being features on other people's songs so that we can finally in some way get more music from them

I do remember Rose being in the studio a lot a few years back (in LA). She’s my favorite anyways so I need her to serve some features. 

[SchmoodRing]

On 8/3/2023 at 10:41 PM, Post Malone said:

Glad it's finally coming

but the 26 essays over months for this ONE song that is literally a reject from a year old album is sending me, the drama 

This is what happens when you starve your fans and gatekeep your artist

On 8/4/2023 at 8:15 AM, LiamVillain said:

 

not Ice Spice
they can keep it

Same she hasn't earned a collab with them and isn't worth it either

 

[whirly]

26 minutes ago, SchmoodRing said:

Do we know for a fact that was the case or are we just assuming 

Source: We have ears

[Post Malone]

Okay but the fact that Lisa's "Yeah" from the trailer is in the DEMO but NOT in the final 

Or was that the demo singer all along 

[Post Malone]

where is @TaylenaStan in this EMERGENCY

 

[SchmoodRing]

32 minutes ago, k.money said:

 

I do remember Rose being in the studio a lot a few years back (in LA). She’s my favorite anyways so I need her to serve some features. 

Halsey featuring Rosé 

2 hours ago, whirly said:

Honestly... The other version might be better  I think it's a demo by Chaennie when they went to LA because it has Rosé (and someone else) but no Lisoo

Wait a demo version is out there

2 hours ago, k.money said:

I’ll just insert Lisa’s rap 💅🏼 and make my own version. 

What is happening 

2 hours ago, whirly said:

Honestly... The other version might be better  I think it's a demo by Chaennie when they went to LA because it has Rosé (and someone else) but no Lisoo

So the collective opinion is that the extended version is better? Why was the song shortened for if the original length and version seems superior ******* tiktok

2 hours ago, whirly said:

I'm sat here listening to both at the same time, one in each ear  I prefer the original verse and Lisa could've easily copied that instead of whatever fast rap they decided to give her instead

I love Lisa fast rapping Eminem was real quiet 

1 hour ago, k.money said:

The 3:31 is 100% a demo singer.

 

Intro is definitely not Jennie.

Pre-Chorus is definitely Rose.

 

Chorus is combination of "not Jennie" and Rose.

 

From what I recall, Rose was in the studio with him Ryan Tedder at some point, but IDK if any of the other girls were with them.

 

Listening again to the 3:31 version with headphones, it sounds like an edit. It goes from Outro/Empty Bridge at 2:39 back to the pre-chorus with off timing.

There's no Rose pre-chorus after the second verse, and the final chorus that it ends with has a different instrumental.

 

All that said, I don't know where the 2:38 one came from. It's them, but it doesn't sound finished. I can only assume it was released in game...?

The empty bridge was probably space for a feature or a dance break instrumental breakdown. This whole release being so messy is tragic. Rosé should've done the pre chorus again after the second because it's actually good and their should've been a proper outro dance break or something because the song is actually good and then ends so climactically

1 hour ago, whirly said:

Yeah the shorter one was released in-game and is releasing on digitals Friday 12am EST

So how many versions of the song are there? What was released and what are we actually getting. I'm getting so confused by this release and discourse 

1 hour ago, Josh said:

that intro tagline is deffo from BOOMBAYAH 

Again do yall know that for a fact? Why can't it be new? It's the same person Jennie saying and probably was just produced by the same person why would it sound any different???

47 minutes ago, whirly said:

Source: We have ears

Okay so no confirmation, say less

44 minutes ago, Post Malone said:

Okay but the fact that Lisa's "Yeah" from the trailer is in the DEMO but NOT in the final 

Or was that the demo singer all along 

This is such a messy release. Can people do a mega mix version with all the little details and extended outro please because this back and forth is getting me tight lol 

[SchmoodRing]

On 8/10/2023 at 4:52 AM, TOKYO. said:

he makes **** music nowadays, he can keep the song

No he doesn't. The only decline in his artistry has been him releasing short songs but his pen and vocals are still it and he just scored another hit, get real

On 8/10/2023 at 4:53 AM, LCTV said:

Not the Apologize singer being involved.

He's world renowned why are you trying to discredit him

On 8/10/2023 at 4:57 AM, ariesgroove said:

i can’t even get too happy about this cause i know yg is gonna chuck this onto their 3rd album to reach an 8 track limit again ala ready for love  

they even had aiiyl as a hidden track on the square up physical i don’t trust them 

Why are they managed like this? The scarcity is their discography is honestly pathetic 

On 8/10/2023 at 8:47 AM, whirly said:

I can't trust Mr Ryan on this one because didn't he also think that some of the songs he worked on with Rosé and Jennie would be on Born Pink?  It looks this is just a BPTG exclusive song at the moment

That's not his fault though. We were also promised 10 plus tracks and got 1 Rosé solo sneaked in, Ready For Love, Pink Venom and only got 4 new songs only, sad

On 8/11/2023 at 12:34 PM, Post Malone said:

But imagine if this were on the Born Pink tracklist 

 

The Happiest Girl

The Girls

Typa Girl

 

Soon enough they'll debut their Forbidden Love serve but with a something-girl title

 

We deserved this song over Rosé solo being sold as a group song is weird as **** 

[SchmoodRing]

On 8/18/2023 at 9:48 AM, k.money said:

I think it's just going to be the go to sound. KTL, DDDD, etc. It'll sound like what Aespa has been putting out and I feel I'll be disappointed about having to wait for whatever it is.

 

(This is just my opinion based on the BP stuff I like, but I feel it might resonate with some others)

I'd love for Blackpink and Aespa to officially collaborate 

On 8/18/2023 at 10:05 AM, whirly said:

They used to record the Japanese versions with the original but they didn't for Born Pink. They probably won't bother at all. They were always half-assed anyway so I won't miss them

That's such a waste. They should be recording and releasing new music tf

On 8/20/2023 at 9:11 AM, TaylenaStan said:

Another 2016 demo
Just disband already if you refuse to set foot into a studio for years and years 

It wasn't made in 2016 sis

On 8/20/2023 at 9:22 AM, whirly said:

You mean the same way that 90% of kpop groups are dropping English singles to cash in on those $$$ when most of them don't speak English and those songs chart better than most of their Korean songs? 

 

I kind of expected better from America

As they should cause kpop deserves to be global and become international ideas like Jeon Somi and Chung Ha

 

[SchmoodRing]

On 8/21/2023 at 6:49 AM, everytime said:

ai?? the same production throughout, the overproduced vocals… sounds real enough to me  

 

  Hide contents

why am i still bopping though

Because it is a bop lol

On 8/21/2023 at 1:24 PM, Frozen99 said:

she looks like a soccer mom, not this  

I high key miss her bangs

21 hours ago, whirly said:

 

we can't even blame the corny lyrics on ryan and co because chaennie are credited  (assuming they're credited as writers and not producers)

How are lyrics about being a badass boss ***** corny?

15 hours ago, rivingtonrebel said:

This is decent. Ice Cream is still their worst song compared to this so...

A Selena Gomez feature wasted on a juvenile song about getting your ***** ate was not it with that aesthetic and beat

 

[SchmoodRing]

13 hours ago, GAGAISTHEBESTYA said:

the fact none of this applied 

It is a trap pop bp kind of bop

11 hours ago, Flomik said:

So who was supposed to be the featuring artist? Was it really Ice Spice!? 

Again that girl doesn't deserve this YET Nicki, Missy, Doja would've been miles better

10 hours ago, Adama said:

Hmm imo I get why the song wasn’t added… it doesn’t fit the vibes of BP. Would have matched better with THE ALBUM 

How when this is in the same lane as Pink Venom and Shut Down

6 hours ago, GAGAISTHEBESTYA said:

overall this is actually so good don't know why it's not included in Born Pink lol 

Because YG hates them and successful women in general 

6 hours ago, Post Malone said:

I'm way too occupied at trying to determine whether Jennie actually sings her first verse fully, I swear it sounds like a ghost singer at some parts

... why would their be a ghost singer in a girl group 💀 this isn't a Britney Jean situation 

6 hours ago, samybertoni said:

I’m obsessed with the verses and Lisa’s rap, I wish there were a bridge but oh well it’s an OST and it’s a BOP 

This short song ttend needs to end we got cheated out of a bridge and a even an outro

4 hours ago, k.money said:

There are two versions of this, both different for some reason...

One is 3:31 and the other is about 2:45.

The 3:31 doesn't have Lisa's rap so idek which one is the "real" one.

Why was the 3:31 version scrapped i hate it here 

 

[WeFoundWill]

my gawd a big fat BOP