Jump to content
Login issues ×
The ATRL Grammys are back! ×

Reminder of "viral" thresholds

Xtina vs. Avril… Bigger career?

Mr. Stratus

By Mr. Stratus
in Base

 Share

Xtina Vs. Avril - Bigger Career?  

269 members have voted

  1. 1. Who has the bigger career?

    • Avril
      168
    • Xtina
      101

Recommended Posts

lestat111 Rising Star

lestat111

Posted
Posted (edited)

The one who has more number 1s and grammys. Also, this thread is like heaven for Britney Spears fans, they can hate in here all they want, cuz not much is happening with instagram circle dancer.

Edited by lestat111

  • Replies 387
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Majka Jeżowska

    97

  • ProudLBS

    66

  • Power love

    22

  • Intuition

    15

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

ProudLBS Grand Master

ProudLBS

Posted
Posted

 

1 minute ago, Majka Jeżowska said:

Say Something  (LEAD SINGLE) - (top 5 in Xtina third decade of career + GRAMMY) has more streams than Avril's last 3 albums combined :gaycat3::gaycat7::bibliahh:

:ahh:

 

 

and that's not even true

 

Say Something - 946,158,909

AL + HAW + LS - 1,157,840,817

Majka Jeżowska Collaborator

Majka Jeżowska

Posted
Posted

Youtube:

716,453,418 195,340 2013/03
439,101,803 176,291 2009/10
501,482,851 172,522 2009/12
633,475,813 131,192 2013/11
218,517,017 84,532 2009/10
564,818,340 73,569 2013/07
781,408,610 71,106 2011/08
260,229,629 64,264 2009/11
173,150,426 60,778 2011/04
254,949,320 49,299 2009/10
143,678,824 48,251 2009/11

 

585,675,270 280,039 2010/02
622,790,648 90,425 2009/10
467,887,491 77,547 2011/09
507,218,119 70,866 2009/10
247,080,502 64,805 2010/03
241,137,486 60,791 2010/03
237,997,450 50,179 2010/03
Bloodflowers. Grand Master

Bloodflowers.

Posted
Posted

Xtina is forgotten, she is the Paula Abdul of her generation, her songs didn't stand test of time as evidenced by her horrible streaming stats

 

Avril had bigger peak and longevity

 

GoatGly Mentor

GoatGly

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, R. Ramirez said:

Last decade, Xtina has spawned MUCH more impressives accolades than Xtina. A DIAMOND song being one of the most successful hits in history according to BH100 All-Time Chart, a 6x platinum song that won a GRAMMY, another quadruple platinum single released the same year. Like when was the last time the Complicated singer had a top 10? :dies:

 

Christina stayed a successful businesswoman despite her decline, she could buy two AvrilS and still remain a multimillionaire.

 

I'd rather go with the girl with 20 weeks atop of BH100 than the one who only has one chart-topper. :rip:

 

z0ny.jpg

 

 

9gkx.jpg

 

 

 

:ghostface:A career

Majka Jeżowska Collaborator

Majka Jeżowska

Posted
Posted (edited)
4 minutes ago, ProudLBS said:

 

:ahh:

 

 

and that's not even true

 

Say Something - 946,158,909

AL + HAW + LS - 1,157,840,817

:gaycat7: SOLD MORE*

 

3 minutes ago, Bloodflowers. said:

Xtina is forgotten, she is the Paula Abdul of her generation, her songs didn't stand test of time as evidenced by her horrible streaming stats

 

Avril had bigger peak and longevity

 

GEp9O8m.thumb.gif.1744fbb81a5ce57a086979

Edited by Majka Jeżowska
ProudLBS Grand Master

ProudLBS

Posted
Posted
8 minutes ago, Love Again said:

Avril is a fraud who pretended to be above her pure pop peers while throwing misogynstic digs at them only to turn around and use the same writers and producers those girls used for her own projects. She’s a hypocrite

ignoring the rest of the nonsense, so the other girls could work with Avril's producers but Avril couldn't work with theirs? :ahh: 

and btw what producers and songs are you talking about? Max Martin's 2 bonus tracks on The Best Damn Thing and the 4 tracks on Goodbye Lullaby that still sound 100% Avril?

ProudLBS Grand Master

ProudLBS

Posted
Posted (edited)
6 minutes ago, Majka Jeżowska said:
716,453,418 195,340 2013/03
439,101,803 176,291 2009/10
501,482,851 172,522 2009/12
633,475,813 131,192 2013/11
218,517,017 84,532 2009/10
564,818,340 73,569 2013/07
781,408,610 71,106 2011/08
260,229,629 64,264 2009/11
173,150,426 60,778 2011/04
254,949,320 49,299 2009/10
143,678,824 48,251 2009/11

 

585,675,270 280,039 2010/02

so Complicated is outdoing every Xtina song and collab on YouTube, is that what you're showing us?

Edited by ProudLBS
GoatGly Mentor

GoatGly

Posted
Posted (edited)
7 minutes ago, Bloodflowers. said:

Xtina is forgotten, she is the Paula Abdul of her generation, her songs didn't stand test of time as evidenced by her horrible streaming stats

 

Avril had bigger peak and longevity

 

 Xtina has more monthly listeners than Avril dosen’t she

 

2 minutes ago, ProudLBS said:

ignoring the rest of the nonsense, so the other girls could work with Avril's producers but Avril couldn't work with theirs? :ahh: 

and btw what producers and songs are you talking about? Max Martin's 2 bonus tracks on The Best Damn Thing and the 4 tracks on Goodbye Lullaby that still sound 100% Avril?

AL sounds like a Katy Perry-reject album at points let’s not lie

Edited by GoatGly
Majka Jeżowska Collaborator

Majka Jeżowska

Posted
Posted
1 minute ago, ProudLBS said:

so Complicated is outdoing every Xtina song and collab on YouTube, is that what you're showing us?

No, that Xtina has more hits (which we all know) :clap3:

At the moment Xtina has 2 bigger songs on this streaming platform. (collab and lead)

ProudLBS Grand Master

ProudLBS

Posted
Posted (edited)
10 minutes ago, GoatGly said:

Xtina has more monthly listeners than Avril and has 

Avril is almost outstreaming Xtina's entire album discography with 1 album

 

and as a Taylor stan you should know how the monthly listeners metric works :rip:

 

10 minutes ago, GoatGly said:

AL sounds like a Katy Perry-reject album at points let’s not lie

yes, the bad songs are bad, but she didn't work with Max Martin or any other major Pop producer on those

 

You can see very well which ones were always supposed to be on the album and which ones Epic pressured her to include.

 

8 minutes ago, Majka Jeżowska said:

No, that Xtina has more hits (which we all know) :clap3:

must be why Avril has more songs above 100M on the platform, all solo except one, and all of them as the lead artist.

Edited by ProudLBS
Bloodflowers. Grand Master

Bloodflowers.

Posted
Posted
7 minutes ago, GoatGly said:

 Xtina has more monthly listeners than Avril dosen’t she

 

AL sounds like a Katy Perry-reject album at points let’s not lie

 

All those more monthly listeners, and yet none are streaming her own panned discography outside of Pitbull and Maroon 5 songs. Well that's sad, huh?

 

ERASED!

 

Sharamee6 Rising Star

Sharamee6

Posted
Posted (edited)

No matter how you spin this, injected by the biggest amounts of delusion.. Avril Lavigne is and never will be near the stardom or peak Xtina reached throughout her career, in every single aspect: music, vocals, soundtracks, hits, smash collabs, acting, endorsements, critical acclaim, fashion, make-up, music videos, versatility, magazine covers, business ventures & more. She's done better and proved much more on every metric whereas Avril has and will always be one-dimensional and boxed up in what she does aka phony pop-rock.

 

Also, for that one member that put streaming numbers, of course you'd leave out physical CD numbers and GRAMMY awards, where X easily detsroys Avril. Bye girl. 

 

Like seriously .. You hate Xtina so much, that delusion has literally blinded you from FACTS. 

Edited by Sharamee6
GoatGly Mentor

GoatGly

Posted
Posted
1 minute ago, Bloodflowers. said:

 

All those more monthly listeners, and yet none are streaming her own panned discography outside of Pitbull and Maroon 5 songs. Well that's sad, huh?

 

ERASED!

 

You can’t erase a legendary career :celestial2:

 

That’s why both Avril and Xtina still relevant to this day :ghostface:

Majka Jeżowska Collaborator

Majka Jeżowska

Posted
Posted
1 minute ago, ProudLBS said:

Avril is almost outstreaming Xtina's entire album discography with 1 album

 

and as a Taylor stan you should know how the monthly listeners metric works :rip:

 

yes, the bad songs are bad, she didn't work with Max Martin or any other major Pop producer on those

 

You can see very well which ones were always supposed to be on the album and which ones Epic pressured her to include.

 

must be why Avril has more songs above 100M on the platform, all solo except one, and all of them as the lead artist.

And this year Xtina will have more videos with +100m views than Avril. :celestial3:

ProudLBS Grand Master

ProudLBS

Posted
Posted (edited)
8 minutes ago, Sharamee6 said:

Avril Lavigne is and never will be near the stardom or peak Xtina reached throughout her career

Avril surpassed Xtina's stardom and peak with her first era :rip: and after that Xtina never had a more successful era than Avril.

 

6 minutes ago, Majka Jeżowska said:

And this year Xtina will have more videos with +100m views than Avril. :celestial3:

good for her, but it hasn't happened yet and Avril is still outviewing her :dies:

 

Edited by ProudLBS
Erreur2 La Nature Grand Master

Erreur2 La Nature

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, ProudLBS said:

and Xtina too with her solo material :rip:

That was rude :bibliahh:

Intuition Community Regular

Intuition

Posted
Posted
Just now, ProudLBS said:

Avril surpassed Xtina's stardom and peak with her first era :rip:

 

good for her, but it hasn't happened yet and Avril is still outviewing her :dies:

 

Definitely not in the States. Christina has always been a bigger celebrity.

Avril would not be able to negotiate even half the salary that X had while on The Voice.

Avril also didn't have a lot of appeal for older generations and is generally seen as having last prestige. 

Robburro Mentor

Robburro

Posted
Posted
11 minutes ago, Sharamee6 said:

No matter how you spin this, injected by the biggest amounts of delusion.. Avril Lavigne is and never will be near the stardom or peak Xtina reached throughout her career, in every single aspect: music, vocals, soundtracks, hits, smash collabs, acting, endorsements, critical acclaim, fashion, make-up, music videos, versatility, magazine covers, business ventures & more. Shexs done better and proved much more on every metric whereas Avril has and will always be one-dimensional and boxed up in what she does aka phony pop-rock.

 

Also, for that one member that put streaming numbers, of course you'd leave out physical CD numbers and GRAMMY awards, where X easily detsroys Avril. Bye girl. 

 

Like seriously .. You hate Xtina so much, that delusion has literally blinded you from FACTS. 

Let Go outsold every Xtina album sis, Xtina could barely compete against Jessica Simpson lmao

Majka Jeżowska Collaborator

Majka Jeżowska

Posted
Posted
Just now, ProudLBS said:

Avril surpassed Xtina's stardom and peak with her first era :rip:

 

good for her, but it hasn't happened yet and Avril is still outviewing her :dies:

 

 

2 minutes ago, ProudLBS said:

Avril surpassed Xtina's stardom and peak with her first era :rip:

 

good for her, but it hasn't happened yet and Avril is still outviewing her :dies:

 

In real world:

Xtina>Avril

Atrl: Avril>Christina

 

Xtina sold more records, sold more tickets, won more important awards. End of discussion. :flower:

Impact? More iconic moments? Even a stupid recognizable outfit? Xtina>>>>Avril

60m views (and there are several videos of this type on tiktok with +3m likes)

 

 

 

Power love Grand Master

Power love

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, JustHoran said:

Doesn't mean anything

Suddenly it doesn’t mean any:deadbanana4:thing. I’d make sure to remember that when it’s about Xtina next time Britney stan :rip:

Robburro Mentor

Robburro

Posted
Posted

Xtina peak can go against Avril's third most successful album and call it a day I guess.

 

 

Robburro Mentor

Robburro

Posted
Posted
Just now, Majka Jeżowska said:

 

In real world:

Xtina>Avril

Atrl: Avril>Christina

 

Xtina sold more records, sold more tickets, won more important awards. End of discussion. :flower:

Impact? More iconic moments? Even a stupid recognizable outfit? Xtina>>>>Avril

60m views (and there are several videos of this type on tiktok with +3m likes)

 

 

 

so can you tell us the last time Xtina entered any chart, please? :heart:

Majka Jeżowska Collaborator

Majka Jeżowska

Posted
Posted
2 minutes ago, Robburro said:

so can you tell us the last time Xtina entered any chart, please? :heart:

Weekly charts

 

Chart (2022) Peak

position

Argentina Latino (Monitor Latino)[50] 19
Chile Pop (Monitor Latino)[51] 10
Costa Rica Latino (Monitor Latino)[52] 18
Dominican Republic Pop (Monitor Latino)[53] 7
Ecuador Pop (Monitor Latino)[54] 16
El Salvador (Monitor Latino)[38] 6
El Salvador Pop (Monitor Latino)[55] 5
Germany (Official German Charts)[56] 80
Guatemala (Monitor Latino)[31] 3
Guatemala Pop (Monitor Latino)[32] 1
Hungary (Rádiós Top 40)[57] 38
Hungary (Single Top 40)[42] 17
Latin America (Monitor Latino)[29] 6
Latin America (Latino) (Monitor Latino)[30] 6
Mexico Airplay (Billboard)[58] 22
Mexico Espanol Airplay (Billboard)[59] 8
Mexico Pop (Monitor Latino)[60] 13
Nicaragua Pop (Monitor Latino)[61] 14
Panama (Monitor Latino)[36] 6
Panama (PRODUCE)[37] 7
Panama Pop (Monitor Latino)[62] 4
Panama Urbano (Monitor Latino)[63] 6
Peru (Monitor Latino)[39] 9
Peru Pop (Monitor Latino)[64] 4
Peru Urbano (Monitor Latino)[65] 5
Puerto Rico (Monitor Latino)[33] 6
Puerto Rico Pop (Monitor Latino)[34] 1
Puerto Rico Urbano (Monitor Latino)[35] 7
Spain (PROMUSICAE)[43] 72
Suriname (Nationale Top 40)[66] 21
Venezuela Pop (Monitor Latino)[67] 9
Venezuela Urbano (Monitor Latino)[68] 12
US Hot Latin Songs (Billboard)[24] 24
US Latin Airplay (Billboard)[25] 12
US Latin Pop Airplay (Billboard)[26] 3
US Latin Rhythm Airplay (Billboard)[27] 7

Year-end charts

 

Chart (2022) Position
US Latin Rhythm Airplay (Billboard)[78] 45
US Latin Pop Airplay (Billboard)[77] 24
Puerto Rico Pop (Monitor Latino)[76] 20
Puerto Rico (Monitor Latino)[75] 78
Paraguay Pop (Monitor Latino)[74] 77
Panama (Monitor Latino)[73] 34
Guatemala (Monitor Latino)[40] 20
El Salvador Pop (Monitor Latino)[72] 83
Dominican Republic (Monitor Latino)[41] 24
Chile Pop (Monitor Latino)[71] 38
Bolivia (Monitor Latino)[70] 58
Argentina (Monitor Latino)[69] 67
Intuition Community Regular

Intuition

Posted
Posted (edited)
37 minutes ago, Bloodflowers. said:

Xtina is forgotten, she is the Paula Abdul of her generation, her songs didn't stand test of time as evidenced by her horrible streaming stats

 

Avril had bigger peak and longevity

 

Paula Abdul has a legendary career as a choreographer and is widely considered one of the best dancers in the industry.

She also won a Grammy and Emmy among other accolades.

Your "legacy" will be having over 100k posts on a music forum.....

Edited by Intuition
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing

Obsessed with Pop Culture. Copyright © 1999-2024, ATRL

Navigation

About Us

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.