poll Xtina vs. Avril… Bigger career?

[Mr. Stratus]

Following the trend, thought these two could make a good discussion 

[shyboi]

Avril was the most influential 2000s pop girl AFTER Britney and Beyoncé. You can still see their influence everywhere. 

 

Also, her streams still pretty solid as well. 

 

So, Avril and not even close.  

Edited April 16, 2023 by shyboi

[ProudLBS]

not this thread again

 

Avril: bigger peak, bigger sales (of her own material and despite having a shorter discography), more longevity, bigger impact.

 

The streaming numbers don't lie:

1. Let Go - 1,542,085,276
2. The Best Damn Thing - 875,486,265
3. Stripped - 847,655,624
4. Goodbye Lullaby - 722,143,327
5. Christina Aguilera - 589,043,766
6. Avril Lavigne - 539,263,647
7. Back To Basics - 456,251,259
8. Under My Skin - 451,326,410
9. Burlesque - 371,583,258
10. Head Above Water - 366,247,597
11. Love Sux - 251,759,251
12. My Kind of Christmas - 221,333,686
13. Mi Reflejo - 190,023,691
14. Lotus - 189,447,476
15. Liberation - 172,815,191
16. Bionic - 137,983,419
17. AGUILERA - 95,995,131
18. Just Be Free - 1,459,716

Avril: 4,748,311,773 (7 albums, 115 songs)
Xtina: 3,273,592,217 (11 albums, 177 songs)

Edited April 16, 2023 by ProudLBS

[R. Ramirez]

6 minutes ago, ProudLBS said:

not this thread again

 

Avril: bigger peak, bigger sales (of her own material and despite having a shorter discography), more longevity, bigger impact.

 

Christina is a 7 time GRAMMY winning artist (mind you she has a MAJOR field), considering one of the best voices in the music industry by the likes of Whitney Houston, Tina Turner, Cher, Celine, etc.. There's no way in hell Avril is more ACCLAIMED than her...

 

Also Xtina is FAR more influential.

 

 

[collin]

Omg the quarterly resurgence of this topic  It’s close but Avril.

[Erreur2 La Nature]

Great thread idea !

 

Avril stomps on Christina Aguilera !

 

[R. Ramirez]

Last decade, Xtina has spawned MUCH more impressives accolades than Xtina. A DIAMOND song being one of the most successful hits in history according to BH100 All-Time Chart, a 6x platinum song that won a GRAMMY, another quadruple platinum single released the same year. Like when was the last time the Complicated singer had a top 10? 

 

Christina stayed a successful businesswoman despite her decline, she could buy two AvrilS and still remain a multimillionaire.

 

I'd rather go with the girl with 20 weeks atop of BH100 than the one who only has one chart-topper. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[Robburro]

can someone please tell me when was the last time Xtina charted on the hot 100 alone? oh yeah, almost 11 years ago.

9 minutes ago, R. Ramirez said:

Christina is a 7 time GRAMMY winning artist (mind you she has a MAJOR field), considering one of the best voices in the music industry by the likes of Whitney Houston, Tina Turner, Cher, Celine, etc.. There's no way in hell Avril is more ACCLAIMED than her...

 

Also Xtina is FAR more influential.

 

 

lol

[Both Sides Now]

 

22 minutes ago, ProudLBS said:

not this thread again

 

Avril: bigger peak, bigger sales (of her own material and despite having a shorter discography), more longevity, bigger impact.

 

The streaming numbers don't lie:

1. Let Go - 1,542,085,276
2. The Best Damn Thing - 875,486,265
3. Stripped - 847,655,624
4. Goodbye Lullaby - 722,143,327
5. Christina Aguilera - 589,043,766
6. Avril Lavigne - 539,263,647
7. Back To Basics - 456,251,259
8. Under My Skin - 451,326,410
9. Burlesque - 371,583,258
10. Head Above Water - 366,247,597
11. Love Sux - 251,759,251
12. My Kind of Christmas - 221,333,686
13. Mi Reflejo - 190,023,691
14. Lotus - 189,447,476
15. Liberation - 172,815,191
16. Bionic - 137,983,419
17. AGUILERA - 95,995,131
18. Just Be Free - 1,459,716

Avril: 4,748,311,773 (7 albums, 115 songs)
Xtina: 3,273,592,217 (11 albums, 177 songs)

To add to this, Let Go alone (~942k daily) nearly outstreams all Xtina albums (~1.081M daily)! 

[ProudLBS]

Just now, Both Sides Now said:

 

To add to this, Let Go alone (~942k daily) nearly outstreams all Xtina albums (~1.081M daily)! 

actually Let Go has been getting 1M+ updates lately   it hit 1,058,012 on Friday

[James_Joint]

Def Avril 

[shyboi]

4 minutes ago, Both Sides Now said:

 

To add to this, Let Go alone (~942k daily) nearly outstreams all Xtina albums (~1.081M daily)! 

 

1 minute ago, ProudLBS said:

actually Let Go has been getting 1M+ updates lately   it hit 1,058,012 on Friday

 

 

[R. Ramirez]

17 minutes ago, Erreur2 La Nature said:

Great thread idea !

 

Avril stomps on Christina Aguilera !

 

Well.. Doesn't look like it.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[Power love]

All I’m seeing is streams to prove Avril is bigger but with basic elementary school comprehension it’s “CAREER”.

 

Xtina has found success in music, (more #1s hits), television (the voice is a success), soundtrack(Burlesque & reflection, LRB), movies (burlesque), & she’s a seven time Grammy winner & in the top 10 of best Grammy performances. 
 

Christina has never been an opening act for anyone.

 

Christina has the #1 tour of 2007. 

 

Xtina has a diamond certified single in Spanish and English.

Xtina has never been dropped from a label 

 

Christina had a successful Vegas residency.

 

I could go on & on Xtina career is much more impressive & this is coming from someone who loves both.

[legendlavigne]

This again  

 

OT: The one currently on the sold out European tour: Avril Lavigne. 

Edited April 16, 2023 by legendlavigne

[R. Ramirez]

17 minutes ago, Both Sides Now said:

 

To add to this, Let Go alone (~942k daily) nearly outstreams all Xtina albums (~1.081M daily)! 

 

 

Moves Like Jagger - 1,066,848,489

Say Something - 946,158,909

 

Avril could only dream of pulling these numbers. 

Edited April 16, 2023 by R. Ramirez

[lovemehateme]

Avril BY FAR.

[XAMJ]

how many times are we going to say Xtina?

[ProudLBS]

Just now, R. Ramirez said:

Christina is a 7 time GRAMMY winning artist (mind you she has a MAJOR field), considering one of the best voices in the music industry by the likes of Whitney Houston, Tina Turner, Cher, Celine, etc.. There's no way in hell Avril is more ACCLAIMED than her...

 

idk why you're bringing "acclaim" into this conversation, but since you wanna go there:

 

Average score:

Xtina - 61

Avril - 64

 

Highest score:

Xtina - 71

Avril - 74

 

Green scores:

Xtina - 2/6

Avril - 5/7

 

Yellow scores:

Xtina - 4/6

Avril - 2/7

 

5 minutes ago, R. Ramirez said:

Also Xtina is FAR more influential.

Who was the blueprint for Olivia and Billie, the Disney girls of the 2000s, Paramore, etc? 

[Intuition]

1 minute ago, ProudLBS said:

idk why you're bringing "acclaim" into this conversation, but since you wanna go there:

 

Average score:

Xtina - 61

Avril - 64

 

Highest score:

Xtina - 71

Avril - 74

 

Green scores:

Xtina - 2/6

Avril - 5/7

 

Yellow scores:

Xtina - 4/6

Avril - 2/7

 

Who was the blueprint for Olivia and Billie, the Disney girls of the 2000s, Paramore, etc? 

Alanis. Just as she was for Avril, Pink, Michelle Branch, etc. 

[ProudLBS]

2 minutes ago, R. Ramirez said:

Moves Like Jagger - 1,066,848,489

Say Something - 946,158,909

 

Avril wishes she could pull these numbers. 

and Xtina too with her solo material 

[Smarticle]

be careful i got a trolling wp for doing kelly vs. avril

[vale9001]

As "non fan" of both but casual listener who appreciate both i can't really decide.

Seems to me they have similar years of success- Number of hits etc .

[naval23]

They seem pretty equal. Avril had more commercial success though 

[ProudLBS]

7 minutes ago, Power love said:

Xtina has never been dropped from a label 

you've been called out multiple times for spreading that outright LIE.

 

8 minutes ago, Power love said:

more #1s hits

that are very well remembered

1. Complicated - 643,529,048
2. Sk8er Boi - 442,894,828
3. Girlfriend - 357,680,068
4. What the Hell - 315,363,583
5. Genie In a Bottle - 296,329,294
6. I'm with You - 219,300,913
7. Head Above Water - 211,368,439
8. Here's to Never Growing Up - 196,423,004
9. When You're Gone - 193,731,351
10. My Happy Ending - 176,595,733
11. Wish You Were Here - 126,343,825
12. Keep Holding On - 102,208,517
13. What a Girl Wants - 89,723,137
14. Smile - 86,201,206
15. Bite Me - 85,954,175
16. Come on over Baby (All I Want Is You) - 85,585,171