Jump to content
Login issues ×
Fall Emoji Are Back! ×

Reminder of "viral" thresholds

Lover vs Midnights

Forever Winter

By Forever Winter
in Base

 Share

Lover vs Midnights  

141 members have voted

  1. 1. Better album overall?

  2. 2. Better album cover?


Recommended Posts

YellowRibbon Veteran

YellowRibbon

Posted
Posted

Midnights clears I'm sorry

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 63
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Forever Winter

    5

  • State of Grace.

    3

  • WildHeart

    2

  • Fuecoco

    2

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

  • ATRL Moderator
Bloo Grand Master

Bloo

Posted
  • ATRL Moderator
Posted

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

————

 

Midnights: 12

Lover: 8

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Tusk Grand Master

Tusk

Posted
Posted

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Michael196 Grand Master

Michael196

Posted
Posted

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

10-10

her best pop albums :clap3:

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
State of Grace. Grand Master

State of Grace.

Posted
Posted
17 minutes ago, Artistofthedecade said:

Neither of them has

 

:gaycat2:

kskkfjsks im-

 

billie-eilish-is-fucking-OVER.thumb.gif.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
TaylenaStan Veteran

TaylenaStan

Posted
Posted (edited)

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing :zzz:

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

Loser 9 
MIDnights 11
a close mid off between her 8th and 9th best albums :jonnycat:
billie-eilish-is-fucking-OVER.thumb.gif.

Edited by TaylenaStan
Link to comment
Share on other sites
FENTY. Community Regular

FENTY.

Posted
Posted

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris (neither ew)

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

For a second I thought Lover was going to win :rip:

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Beyonceist Experienced

Beyonceist

Posted
Posted

I haven't listened to either in full, I'll just compare the ones I know 

 

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

London Boy / Karma

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

ME! / Paris - Haven't listened to Paris but anything is better than ME!

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

 

Lover: 5

Midnights: 6

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • ATRL Moderator
wehavetostan Grand Master

wehavetostan

Posted
  • ATRL Moderator
Posted

 

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

10-10

Midnights wins overall.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Britney Is Fierce Community Regular

Britney Is Fierce

Posted
Posted

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

Lover: 6

Midnights: 14

 

I love both albums, though. Midnights is definitely more cohesive and consistent, one of Taylor's best albums in that regard, but Lover has quite high highs. I adore all the highlighted songs. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Arrows Veteran

Arrows

Posted
Posted

 

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

8/11

Link to comment
Share on other sites
terrorblade Grand Master

terrorblade

Posted
Posted

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

10 vs 10

a true mid off

Link to comment
Share on other sites
rancidgirl Apprentice

rancidgirl

Posted
Posted (edited)

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it (overplayed VS)

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

    London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

Only The Young / Would've Could've Should've

All Of The Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

Need / Hits Different

 

Lover - 15/21

Midnights - 12/21

 

Edited by rancidgirl
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Klein Grand Master

Klein

Posted
Posted

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon (hardest one)

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

8 - 12

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Lorenzo22 Mentor

Lorenzo22

Posted
Posted

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

4 vs 16

:rip:

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Achilles. Grand Master

Achilles.

Posted
Posted

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

Lover: 5

Midnights: 15

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Forever Winter Grand Master

Forever Winter

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)
6 hours ago, Bloo said:

 

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

————

 

Midnights: 12

Lover: 8

Not us having the exact same choices except for Cruel Summer/Maroon AOTGYLB / Dear Reader :clap3:

Edited by Taeyong
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Homebrand Mentor

Homebrand

Posted
Posted

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

Its close, but Loser by a fraction 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
JonginBey Grand Master

JonginBey

Posted
Posted

Midnights for both.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
pavi Experienced

pavi

Posted
Posted

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

Lover: 10

Midnights: 6

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Carter Proficient

Carter

Posted
Posted

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

midnight: 12

lover: 8

Link to comment
Share on other sites
 Share
Go to topic listing

Obsessed with Pop Culture. Copyright © 1999-2024, ATRL

Navigation

About Us

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.