poll Lover vs Midnights

[YellowRibbon]

Midnights clears I'm sorry

[WildHeart]

43 minutes ago, State of Grace. said:

jail 

Neither of them has

 

[Bloo]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

————

 

Midnights: 12

Lover: 8

[Tusk]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

[Michael196]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

10-10

her best pop albums 

 

[State of Grace.]

17 minutes ago, Artistofthedecade said:

Neither of them has

 

kskkfjsks im-

 

[Dystopian]

Midnights for all except Cruel Summer > Maroon 

[TaylenaStan]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing 

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

Loser 9 
MIDnights 11
a close mid off between her 8th and 9th best albums 

Edited March 19, 2023 by TaylenaStan

[FENTY.]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris (neither ew)

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

For a second I thought Lover was going to win

[byzantium]

Midnights for both.  Easy

[Beyonceist]

I haven't listened to either in full, I'll just compare the ones I know 

 

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

London Boy / Karma

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

ME! / Paris - Haven't listened to Paris but anything is better than ME!

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

 

Lover: 5

Midnights: 6

[wehavetostan]

 

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

10-10

Midnights wins overall.

[Britney Is Fierce]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

Lover: 6

Midnights: 14

 

I love both albums, though. Midnights is definitely more cohesive and consistent, one of Taylor's best albums in that regard, but Lover has quite high highs. I adore all the highlighted songs. 

[Arrows]

 

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

8/11

[terrorblade]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

10 vs 10

a true mid off

[rancidgirl]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it (overplayed VS)

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

    London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

Only The Young / Would've Could've Should've

All Of The Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

Need / Hits Different

 

Lover - 15/21

Midnights - 12/21

 

Edited March 20, 2023 by rancidgirl

[Iceland]

You neeed to calm down alone >>>

[Klein]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon (hardest one)

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

8 - 12

[Lorenzo22]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

4 vs 16

[Achilles.]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

Lover: 5

Midnights: 15

[Brooklyn Baby]

6 hours ago, Bloo said:

 

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

————

 

Midnights: 12

Lover: 8

Not us having the exact same choices except for Cruel Summer/Maroon AOTGYLB / Dear Reader 

Edited March 20, 2023 by Taeyong

[Homebrand]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

Its close, but Loser by a fraction 

[JonginBey]

Midnights for both.

[pavi]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

Lover: 10

Midnights: 6

[Carter]

I Forgot That You Existed / Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer / Maroon

Lover / Anti-Hero

The Man / Snow on the Beach

The Archer / You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows / Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince / Question...?

Paper Rings / Vigilante S*it

Cornelia Street / Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts / Labyrinth

London Boy / Karma

Soon You'll Get Better / Sweet Nothing

False God / Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down / The Great War

Afterglow / Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! / Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend / High Infidelity

Daylight / Glitch

 

Bonus:

Need / Would've, Could've, Should've

All of the Girls You Loved Before / Dear Reader

 

midnight: 12

lover: 8