Loud (Rihanna) vs Teenage Dream (Katy)

[Josh]

vs

 

Both were MPG pop albums that dominated 2010-2011 - but which album do you prefer and which era had the bigger singles? 

[Diesel is Desire]

Loud sweetie...

[Roberto]

Loud. 

[kyliefever2002]

i think i might like td's singles better but for sure loud as an album 

[Maxxie]

Loud

[byzantium]

Add in Speak Now and this was basically my second half of 2010.  

[JohnWayneHolland]

I wanna say Loud because it has S&M and Man Down 

[ninasayers]

Literally listening to Loud rn. And i prefer it over TD. TD's singles were bigger overall, ofc.

[Power love]

TD for me. It’s such a great album. 

[schnetzka]

They are both fantastic albums but Loud pulls ahead for me. It is my absolute favorite Rihanna era.

[naval23]

Both are amazing eras and my fav eras from both, but TD takes this one

[Nightingale]

Teenage Dream is more consistent for me

[znake]

The one with 6th #1s smash hits 

[PopKills]

Teenage Classic by far. Loud only has a few singles I still use.

Edited February 8, 2023 by PopKills

[Gladiator]

Teenage Dream, but this was a tough comparison. Loud was a significant album in my life at one point in time, but I don't revisit it much apart from a few songs whereas I do still revisit Teenage Dream.

[DiamondHoe]

Teenage Dream is era defining. 6 classics and some great album tracks too. 
 

Loud has lower highs but also much lower lows (Raining Men)

 

TS easily wins

[Winged]

One is a Pop Bible (Teenage dream) and 6 #1’s

 

 

the other one just has red colour wig and Only Girl and try hard S&M remix

[Rhiannon]

Katy's TD. Loud aged so bad.

[Cheers]

What’s My Name alone clears

[Baby Boy]

Loud’s singles but TD is better as a whole. 

[Danes]

Loud

[Diocles]

Loud.

 

TD -apart from TOTGA- is terrible and it aged like goat milk.

[A.R.L]

Katy of course