Pluto6 Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 11 minutes ago, Born to Run said: Call her God doesn’t change the fact that she’s always been the BACK member of TWICE with a dating scandal and fan hating history I literally stan TWICE but I’ll never understand what’s the point of faking sales for the MOST unpopular member who caused TWICE rapid decline. Can you elaborate on these parts?
Mitsuki Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 But talking about Jihyo, I genuinely love her album. Curiously, 'Killin Me Good' remembers me of TWICE's new sound. While Nayeon's 'POP' remembers me of early TWICE.
Green Tea Is Green Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 18 minutes ago, Born to Run said: Call her God doesn’t change the fact that she’s always been the BACK member of TWICE with a dating scandal and fan hating history, now she’s outselling Nayeon and BP members (from 2021) with a song nowhere to be found on the chart. If you are a real ONCE you should know TWICE’s Korean title/solo NEVER served NOT IN on MelOn for ONCE. Here we have Park Jihyo pulling 200k sales from nowhere in an hour when the song is N/A from every possible chart. Don’t deluded yourself into thinking international fans (if they exist outside of Twitter) bought these - Hanteo first day sales are basically Korean/Chinese oriented. 1M YouTube views in 3 hours, 30k Chinese pre-orders, 1613 likes on MelOn withOUT charting, doesn’t translate into 2nd best selling solo of all time. Like, all sales are fraudulent now, I literally stan TWICE but I’ll never understand what’s the point of faking sales for the MOST unpopular member who caused TWICE rapid decline. "All sales are fraudulent now" > proceeds to single out Jihyo Just say you hate her and go although all the points you brought up clearly show this is just out of hatred It's kinda insane the amount of people who randomly hate her in here, the way its a lot of people who "like Twice" too, what did she even do 2 2
Born to Run Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 6 minutes ago, Mitsuki said: So her sales don't need to "match digitals" to exist. So whose sales need to match digital exactly? Good to know we can all agree sales are useless. 4 minutes ago, Pluto2022 said: Can you elaborate on these parts? No. Google or live in KTRL’s own bubble.
Born to Run Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 Just now, Green Tea Is Green said: "All sales are fraudulent now" > proceeds to single out Jihyo Just say you hate her and go although all the points you brought up clearly show this is just out of hatred It's kinda insane the amount of people who randomly hate her in here, the way its a lot of people who "like Twice" too, what did she even do I’ve been hating her since the dating scandal, now what? Sales are fraudulent, digital is bombing, now we are just waiting for Spotify updates. 1
Green Tea Is Green Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 3 minutes ago, Born to Run said: I’ve been hating her since the dating scandal, now what? Sales are fraudulent, digital is bombing, now we are just waiting for Spotify updates. This applies to Twice's latest release as a group too, nothing new
Odette Violet Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 This might be Hyo's visual peak yet. Miss Ma'am is channeling J.Lo and prime Britney Spears hard with this lewks 3
Odette Violet Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 I just listened to Miss Jihyo's song. Yeah it's basic but it's not even that bad, people are doing too much as usual here
Mitsuki Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 3 minutes ago, Born to Run said: So whose sales need to match digital exactly? Good to know we can all agree sales are useless Literally no one need to match anything to prove for K-pop stans the legitimacy of their numbers. Jihyo is just one example.
Pluto6 Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 (edited) What's up with people in here hating on Jihyo constantly today? Like I didn't know my sis was this much panned in here? I just thought that we didn't like her vocal tone sometimes and nothing more? And what's up with these so called people claiming to "stan" TWICE apparently, and yet trowing these fraud allegation towards Jihyo? Sorry but it seems like some of you are pretending to stan TWICE right now just so that your arguments against Jihyo's sales can seem more objective and not as subjective, and basically hiding behind TWICE to shade and discredit Jihyo so that it won't be too obvious. Edited August 19, 2023 by Pluto2022 3
sunmimi imfurst Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 I would say Momo’s singing and dating history did way more damage than anything Jihyo has ever done in Korea I think it hurt Kang Daniel more at that time lol. I think Jihyo has a lot of fans in the west and even if she isn’t the number one bias of many people, Twice is still a huge girl group and Jihyo is quite high on a lot of peoples lists IDK where this narrative is coming from.. 4
Born to Run Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 Just now, Green Tea Is Green said: This applies to Twice's latest release as a group too, nothing new Set Me Free, the massive bomb it is, at least CHARTED on MelOn. Park Jihyo outsold Misamo (TWICE top line) first week sales in a day. Nayeon had a 100k Chinese pre-order, first day sales - 123,835. Jihyo 30k - 361,104.
Mitsuki Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 Her performances for the debut era are very mesmerizing. I love Jihyo on stage 4
Pluto6 Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 (edited) 30 minutes ago, Born to Run said: I’ve been hating her since the dating scandal, now what? Sales are fraudulent, digital is bombing, now we are just waiting for Spotify updates. Why so mad over someone dating? Are you mad that she "stole" your Kang Daniel Oppa from you or what? Edited August 19, 2023 by Pluto2022 1 2
Green Tea Is Green Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 2 minutes ago, Pluto2022 said: What's up with people in here hating on Jihyo constantly today? Like I didn't know my sis was this much panned in here? I just thought that we didn't like her vocal tone sometimes and nothing more? And what's up with these so called people claiming to "stan" TWICE apparently, and yet trowing these fraud allegation towards Jihyo? Sorry but it seems like some of you are pretending to stan TWICE right now just so that your arguments against Jihyo's sales can seem more objective and not as subjective, and basically hiding behind TWICE to shade Jihyo so that it won't be too obvious. No I've seen them around and they do like Twice at least, its just a Jihyo thing which I really don't get, it feels so random Just now, sunmimi imfurst said: I would say Momo’s singing and dating history did way more damage than anything Jihyo has ever done in Korea I think it hurt Kang Daniel more at that time lol. I think Jihyo has a lot of fans in the west and even if she isn’t the number one bias of many people, Twice is still a huge girl group and Jihyo is quite high on a lot of peoples lists IDK where this narrative is coming from.. It was a mix imo, it started with Sana's IG post getting randomly hated on because she was "supporting Japan">Jihyo's feminist scandal>Momo's encore, literally a 1-2-3 punch, the first 2 especially putting them on the bad side of korean men and korean girls were never into them like that so... but at least they started pandering to women 3 minutes ago, Born to Run said: Set Me Free, the massive bomb it is, at least CHARTED on MelOn. Park Jihyo outsold Misamo (TWICE top line) first week sales in a day. Nayeon had a 100k Chinese pre-order, first day sales - 123,835. Jihyo 30k - 361,104. Misamo released in Japan let's not be dense there 2
Tomek Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 22 minutes ago, Born to Run said: I’ve been hating her since the dating scandal, now what? Sales are fraudulent, digital is bombing, now we are just waiting for Spotify updates. how can you say that without feeling any shame 2 3
Odette Violet Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 (edited) Can Ryan or any mods can do something about the quoted posts from users we put on mute? the obsession of that one user ever since they joined this sub is worrying. How miserable you can be that the sole purpose you enter this thread is to come up with conspiracy theories and made up stats to shade groups or members you don't even like Edited August 19, 2023 by Odette Violet 3
Born to Run Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 3 minutes ago, Green Tea Is Green said: Misamo released in Japan let's not be dense there Just another example of real fanbase vs. ghost sales. We all know Jihyo outselling Nayeon is ridiculous at the end of the day. Gonna put a weekly reminder for this thread that Jihyo is the FISRT Korean release by TWICE that didn’t chart. She’s killing their kareer too good.
Born to Run Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 1 minute ago, Odette Violet said: Can Ryan or any mods can do something about the quoted posts on users we put on mute? the obsession of that one user ever since they joined this sub is worrying. How miserable you can be that the sole purpose you enter this thread is to come up with conspiracy theories and made up stats to shade groups you don't even like Stfu I don’t even mind your endless YouTube/Twitter link spamming, token SNSD stanning is not even a personality in 2023. If you want to be a cupcake, be one, just don’t accuse others making up stats or theories on something YOU don’t know. 1
DelRey Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 (edited) Btw I dont hate Jihyo and I didn't say anything bad about her or her single/album quality. I just find the number unrealistic for her popularity in the group. Edited August 19, 2023 by DelRey
jqnetto Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 so what is going to be the graph when Chaeyoung reaches 1M sales first day next.
Born to Run Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 Just now, DelRey said: Btw I dont hate Jihyo and I didn't say anything bad about her or her single/album quality. I just find their number unrealistic for her popularity in the group. Like.. kids here think I’m sending death threats to Jihyo, or aespa for most of the time when I just post their chart facts for a quick shade and kii. 1
Gorjesspazze9 Posted August 19, 2023 Posted August 19, 2023 (edited) All this outrage for Jihyo album salesit ain’t that deep KTRL but when these freshly debut boy groups and male solo’s sell millions without any hits, same people are real quiet. the math don’t add up At the end of the day it’s all fans, so what are we even doing. Y’all acting brand new, we know. plus she is literally in the best selling girl group in Kpop history. It’s not that shocking she is selling well. I’d understand if it was some nugu, but a twice soloist selling 100k-300K ain’t that mind blowing for y’all to pull the fraud card. I don’t even Stan twice anymore, but it’s really not a big deal😆 momo could sell 2 million. Crying about it ain’t gonna do anything. Deal with it Edited August 19, 2023 by Gorjesspazze9 2 2
Recommended Posts