base talk GaGa continuously has Soundtrack hits, Bey and Taylor couldn't. Why?

[Scotland]

Shallow - #1

Hold My Hand - #50-something, rising.

 

Spirit - Flop.

Brown Skin Girl - Flop.

 

The Taylor song for "Cats" - Let's not even mention it.

 

Edited June 7, 2022 by Scotland

[Steve Johnson]

I knew this thread was coming after HMH went #53 on hot 100. 

OT: HMH is not a hit. 

[terrorblade]

[Bimbo]

Stop setting her up *****

[Kayseri Mantisi]

Continuously ≠ one song being a hit

[lovedaddy]

[sugarysunflower]

Fixed it. 

Bey and Taylor continuously has Studio Album smashes, Gaga couldn't. Why?

[outoftime]

Till it Happens to You: flop

ASIB: fluke

HMH: flop

 

I don't think so

[Kayseri Mantisi]

1 minute ago, sugarysunflower said:

Fixed it. 

Bey and Taylor continuously has Studio Album smashes, Gaga couldn't. Why?

[Taylor Sniffs]

If HMH is a hit, then Safe & Sound is a hit as well. 

[Steve Johnson]

3 minutes ago, sugarysunflower said:

Bey and Taylor continuously has Studio Album smashes, Gaga couldn't. Why?

[Holy Ground]

I Don't Wanna Live Forever a smash!

[simplywohoo]

Maybe we should wait to see if it's actually gonna be a hit 

It's too early to tell

But I love the sing ngl 

[JorgeM]

This set up to Gaga is nasty. The movie is smashing hard and the only way to keep a float the song is though radio

[Queenyoncee]

30 minutes ago, Scotland said:

Brown Skin Girl - Flop.

The song was not even a single. 

 

19 minutes ago, sugarysunflower said:

Fixed it. 

Bey and Taylor continuously has Studio Album smashes, Gaga couldn't. Why?

[Ms. Togekiss]

21 minutes ago, sugarysunflower said:

Fixed it. 

Bey and Taylor continuously has Studio Album smashes, Gaga couldn't. Why?

[ahauntingnearu]

I hate GaGa

[PrudenceHCharmed]

Let me bop to Check On It and Independent Women then listen to Listen. 

[OhRly?]

So... are we pretending that Check on It does not exist?

 

 

 

[Great808]

When it comes to soundtrack songs, they require the artist to be kind of forced to make something serious, not just sonically but conceptually and when it comes to Gaga she understands the assignment every time. Spirit was a very serious song but not’s not quite Beyonce’s strong point in music. The Taylor song I’ve never heard but if its anything like her hits then yeah, nah.

[Icarus]

Even ELECTRIC was a relatively bigger success than Hold My Hand, the OP could have used his actual fave for this thread 

[Steve Johnson]

Not you comparing Beautiful Ghost to this. BG was attached to a flop, critically panned movie. HMH on other hand is used multiple times in a movie which is smashing hard at box-office. 

[OrgVisual]

Check On It - a smash hit

Listen - a classic

 

[Steve Johnson]

 

Well this was highly successful. 

[thetea]

31 minutes ago, outoftime said:

Till it Happens to You: flop

ASIB: fluke

y'all are so inventive in your reasoning. by this logic, any artist who has a huge era had a fluke.

 

OT: stop making threads like this, it sets gaga up to be dragged by trolls like this