poll TB: "Before He Cheats" trilogy - which ages the best?

[Carrie-is-no-1]

Carrie's first 3 albums' pop-crossover revenge track, which one has a more lasting appeal? 

 

 

 

 

[Cherish]

Before He Cheats > Last Name > Undo It

 

[naval23]

The one that was actually a hit "Before He Cheats"

[fridayteenage]

pop?

 

didn't she purposefully not send any song except bhc to pop?

[abrahamjmr]

44 minutes ago, fridayteenage said:

pop?

 

didn't she purposefully not send any song except bhc to pop?

That don't mean they didn't have a poppier sound.

[getback]

Undo It is not part of BHC/LN and I stand by what I said   

[enchanted0]

Undo It is trash  Replace it with Good Girl

[Nightingale]

Before He Cheats > Undo It > Last Name

 

Cowboy Casanova and Good Girl deserve to be mentioned too

[Carrie-is-no-1]

7 minutes ago, Nightingale said:

Cowboy Casanova and Good Girl deserve to be mentioned too

i think the strategy around the 3 tracks in this thread is the same - they're all 3rd country single from each album with very similar sound. CC and GG are both lead singles.

 

1 hour ago, fridayteenage said:

didn't she purposefully not send any song except bhc to pop?

"Some Hearts" was released to Pop i think. BHC was not initially released to Pop but got picked up later.

[SoulfulWings]

Undo It still holds up.

[pearlmercury]

Before He Cheats > Last Name > Undo It

[ithinkheknowsoutsold]

Good Girl >>

[GiftFromGod]

Last Name > Before He Cheats > Undo It