base talk Main Pop Girls: Best Discography

[Cleanromantic]

These are the main pop girls that have released more than 3 albums and have been in the game for at least a decade. (Included Katy even though she's no longer one, but she has an extensive discography anyways)

Best discography.

[AlexStexaul]

Gaga 

[Solaria]

Beyoncé by far. She has never once missed on her main studio albums and ST and Lemonade are MILES miles ahead of the rest of the MPGs their albums.

[Aramis]

I think it's clear.

[John Slayne]

Madonna by far

 

out of the girls mentioned Gaga by far

[RihannaLoverrr]

Beyoncé’s is the strongest

[Badgalbriel]

Taylor has the better discography. A real Immaculate Collection. Perfect from album 1 to album 9.

[bestfiction]

Madonna

but out of these Taylor and Bey

[GoodGuyGoneGhetto]

Of the girls listed.

 

Objectively:

 

1) Adele

2) Beyonce

3) Taylor Swift

4) Rihanna

5) Lady Gaga

6) Ariana Grande

7) Katy Perry

 

Subjectively:

 

1) Beyoncé & Rihanna

2) Adele

3) Ariana Grande

4) Taylor Swift

5) Lady Gaga

6) Katy Perry

Edited April 22, 2022 by GoodGuyGoneGhetto

[My Tears Ricochet]

Taylor

Ariana

Gaga

Beyonce

Katy

Rihanna

Adele

[Diesel is Desire]

4 minutes ago, GoodGuyGoneGhetto said:

Of the girls listed.

 

Objectively:

 

1) Adele

2) Beyonce

3) Taylor Swift

4) Rihanna

5) Lady Gaga

6) Ariana Grande

7) Katy Perry

 

Subjectively:

 

1) Beyoncé & Rihanna

2) Adele

3) Ariana Grande

4) Taylor Swift

5) Lady Gaga

6) Katy Perry

Sneaking Adele at the top over Bey Taylor and Rihanna is a choice 

[Filpo]

Lil Billie's will be the one. I voted Adele here, because none of the others are discographies that I plan to listen to in their entirety. I feel like Madonna's could be eligible for this title.

[GoodGuyGoneGhetto]

If we included all “MPG’s”, including those from the 20th century.

 

Objectively:

 

1) Janet Jackson

2) Madonna

3) Mariah Carey

4) Adele

5) Beyonce

6) Taylor Swift

7) Rihanna

8) Lady Gaga

9) Celine Dion

10) Whitney Houston

11) Ariana Grande

12) Katy Perry

 

Subjectively:

 

1) Madonna

2) Janet Jackson

3) Rihanna

4) Beyoncé

5) Mariah Carey

6) Adele

7) Whitney Houston

8) Celine Dion

9) Taylor Swift

10) Ariana Grande

11) Lady Gaga

12 Katy Perry

 

Edited April 22, 2022 by GoodGuyGoneGhetto

[State of Grace.]

Taylor has the strongest and most consistent discography out of these girls. She has also delivered immaculate records in 3 different genres. Bops, heart-wrenching ballads, kindergarten spelling anthems, you name it..

 

Ariana and Gaga are 2nd. Ariana's last 3 albums are great and she's pretty consistent too. Gaga has fantastic highs and some duds but she has it in her. 

[State of Grace.]

Lana is not considered a MPG (depends on the thread and narrative Ig) but she has one of the strongest discographies this century too.

Edited April 22, 2022 by State of Grace.

[byzantium]

taylor>beyonce>Adele>Rihanna>Ariana>Katy>Gaga

[Erreur2 La Nature]

The thread makes no sense. Voting for Katy in that list. 

[Antisocialites]

Beyoncé, duh.

[Kiss It Better]

Mariah Carey has the best discography main pop girl or not of all time, but out of the list then Rihanna 

 

 

Rihanna > Taylor > Beyonce > Katy = Gaga > Adele > Ariana

 

[dabunique]

Madonna overall

 

Rihanna in this list, b!tch has been gone for 80 years and her hits still stick, others can't relate

[smoothkarmel]

Beyonce

[kindararenext]

all i know top 3 is beyoncé, ariana and taylor 

 

rihanna has THEE HITS but i don’t care for her albums except anti 

Edited April 22, 2022 by kindararenext

[Taylucifer]

Tay, Rih, Ari >>>> the rest

[Delirious]

No-one voting for Ariana i- 

[West Coast]

Taylor and ari