Jump to content

Taylor, Billie, Adele only MPGs to win AOTY, why?


Recommended Posts

Posted

With only Taylor winning it thrice (we all know Adele Isn’t getting **** for whatever 30 was supppsed to be.

Posted

Grammys only favor bland music made by white women who appeal to a broad demographic

Posted

Grammys only favor acclaimed music made by talented women who appeal to a broad demographic

Posted

why?

 

....do we really need to say? 

Posted
Just now, Beyonnaise said:

Grammys only favor acclaimed music made by talented women who appeal to a broad demographic

None of Taylor’s music was acclaimed till folklore. Try again

Posted

The Grammys have a strong preference for artists who write their own music, and most other pop stars do not do so to the same extent that these three do; they all have widely acknowledged reputations for writing all of their own material. 

Posted
Just now, pieceofgök said:

None of Taylor’s music was acclaimed till folklore. Try again

Year End Lists

#5 - 1989 (2014)

#21 - RED (2012)

 

Decade End Lists (2010s)

#15 - RED

#16 - 1989

 

All Time Lists:

#99 - RED

#345 - 1989

Try again.

Posted
3 minutes ago, pieceofgök said:

None of Taylor’s music was acclaimed till folklore. Try again

uhhh what?

Posted
4 minutes ago, pieceofgök said:

None of Taylor’s music was acclaimed till folklore. Try again

The way a quick Google search proves this statement is factually incorrect :deadbanana4:

Posted
7 minutes ago, pieceofgök said:

None of Taylor’s music was acclaimed till folklore. Try again

Both of her other AOTY winners are some of the most awarded, recognized, and acclaimed albums of all time :bibliahh:

Posted

Celine and Whitney tho

 

 

Posted
9 minutes ago, pieceofgök said:

None of Taylor’s music was acclaimed till folklore. Try again

The way literally all her albums are acclaimed, even her debut and Lover got pretty much only average to good reviews :swan:

Posted
2 minutes ago, greento said:

The way literally all her albums are acclaimed, even her debut and Lover got pretty much only average to good reviews :swan:

Scores in the 70 on Metacritic is not critical acclaim. Artists like Björk, Kate Bush etc were acclaimed for their time. Not Taylor

Posted
13 minutes ago, pieceofgök said:

None of Taylor’s music was acclaimed till folklore. Try again

Fearless had the best metacritic score of any of the AOTY nominees the year it won. :toofunny3:

Posted
2 minutes ago, Achilles. said:

Fearless had the best metacritic score of any of the AOTY nominees the year it won. :toofunny3:

Which wasn’t high which proves the Grammys nominated non acclaimed bland music, your point being?

Posted

White mediocrity triumphs often. Same with Celine.

Posted

Did they each deserve to win AOTY 1 time? I guess yeah. But awarding Taylor with 3 and Adele with 2 AOTYs respectively was bs and they were favored over extremely important, great, and simply better outputs by African American artists such as Kendrick and Bey

Posted
20 minutes ago, Miss Americana said:

Year End Lists

#5 - 1989 (2014)

#21 - RED (2012)

 

Decade End Lists (2010s)

#15 - RED

#16 - 1989

 

All Time Lists:

#99 - RED

#345 - 1989

Try again.

:gaylorcat2::gaylorcat1:

Posted

Grammys only favor acclaimed music made by talented women who appeal to a broad demographic

Posted

You forgot:

 

Celine Dion - Falling Into You

Whitney Houston - The Bodyguard

celine-dion-grammys-1997-170129-inline-0

ER_YDKtXYAAK4LO.jpg

 

OT: The grammys have never been favorable towards female artists in general categories, especially females that do pop music so it's not surprising only so few pop girls have managed to do it

Posted
38 minutes ago, pieceofgök said:

Scores in the 70 on Metacritic is not critical acclaim. Artists like Björk, Kate Bush etc were acclaimed for their time. Not Taylor

Do you know what acclaimed even means?? Doesn’t mean they have to be some of the best of all time (even though Red and 1989 are literally on loads of decade and all time lists)

Posted

What about Whiney and Celine?

Posted
45 minutes ago, Achilles. said:

Fearless had the best metacritic score of any of the AOTY nominees the year it won. :toofunny3:

Metacritic is kinda pointless, who cares what 30 journalists have to say?

 

Winning AOTY means thousands of actual musicians voted for your work as the best of the year, much better criteria for acclaim imo.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.