poll Joanne vs 30

[byzantium]

Neither are great albums but Gaga at least tried something interesting. 

[Forever Winter]

34 minutes ago, Smarticle said:

You do ?

[GraceRandolph]

The superior album released during the artist’s thirties is winning all 3. Yay!

 

Edited April 17, 2022 by GraceRandolph

[manuelalex9810]

Joanne is a horrible album, so 30 for all. 

[JustHoran]

Joanne for all

 

30 is Adele's weakest and worst album yet.

[Jay07]

I'm a certified OJH but it's still a better and more interesting album than the snoozefest that is 30.

[UnusualBoy]

You know atrl is on a hate train when they vote in favor of the boring and awful Joanne…

[Romantica]

Joanne

[Nick_317]

The one with Just Another Slay

[foreverwinter13]

Joanne is bigger, more sucessful. 

[LittleMonster2012]

The one with Just Another Slay on it

[LittleMonster2012]

26 minutes ago, Nick_317 said:

The one with Just Another Slay

I swear I didnt see your comment. 

I-

 

[Arrows]

I still think Joanna is one of Gaga’s best albums! Along with the The Fame/The Fame Monster it’s my favorite.

[perfillusion]

Joanne for all. It has PI >>>

[Johnny Jacobs]

The thread only  shows how many fans those two have.. Not an actual album vote 

 

I only liked one song from each album (the leads) 

 

It's 30 for me but both albums ain't it

[Hot Volcano]

41 minutes ago, Johnny Jacobs said:

The thread only  shows how many fans those two have.. Not an actual album vote 

 

I only liked one song from each album (the leads) 

 

It's 30 for me but both albums ain't it

Not really, Gaga lost a ton of polls in this site, especially when it comes to her impact, classics

 

Joanne wins everything for me. 

 

Gaga tried something new and she delivered with most of the songs.

[little legend]

Weeks in top 50:

30 - 20 weeks

Joanne - 21 weeks 

Not Joanne also winning in all the 3 polls

I would have never expected Joanne to win over a new Adele album. 

I love Adele but this era unfortunately was a non event. The biggest mistake was EOM being the leaf single. It's not a bad song but it's so flat. I listened to it like 5 times and not a single one i couldn't finish it cause it was just so boring. Come on Adele you are a legend , you can do better than this. 

 

Also songs like Perfect Illusion and Million Reasons are masterpieces but of course ATRL will underestimate them cause they weren't smashes

Edited April 17, 2022 by little legend

[Nick_317]

2 hours ago, LittleMonster2012 said:

I swear I didnt see your comment. 

I-

 

Well the SLAYAGE that the song brings is unanimously agreed upon and also great minds think alike

[Forever Winter]

1 hour ago, little legend said:

Weeks in top 50:

30 - 20 weeks

Joanne - 21 weeks 

Not Joanne also winning in all the 3 polls

I would have never expected Joanne to win over a new Adele album. 

I love Adele but this era unfortunately was a non event. The biggest mistake was EOM being the leaf single. It's not a bad song but it's so flat. I listened to it like 5 times and not a single one i couldn't finish it cause it was just so boring. Come on Adele you a legend , you can do better than this. 

 

Also songs like Perfect Illusion and Million Reasons are masterpieces but of course ATRL will underestimate them cause they weren't smashes

[Diocles]

Joanne for all, by miles.

 

30 is unlistenable, the only good song is EOM.

[AlexStexaul]

Joanne by far

[Winged]

30 x3

 

IDW is better than anything Gaga has ever released

Edited April 17, 2022 by Winged

[1989]

30 by far for all, easily.