celeb news Elton John to Charlie Puth: "Your music sucked in 2019. It wasn't good."

[americanlife]

Elton John is such a rude, jealous, petty man.

[magazine]

This sounds like an ATRL that suddenly likes his music because it's charting 

 

I Warned Myself is better than anything he's been putting out 

[Katamari]

5 minutes ago, Tropez said:

Elton doesn’t write his songs. I don’t think he’s ever written a song. He’s more of a composer. 

Elton and Bernie write together and for other acts. What  you mean  

[Sam96]

[mlaredoperez]

2 hours ago, Nikko said:

Not a lot has changed

This...

It's not like he's now making superb tracks...

[Vespertine]

Some of the replies in here... worms for brains on this forum, I swear

 

Elton John is a musician. He writes/composes music. The fact that he is not a lyricist is irrelevant. 

[Tropez]

1 hour ago, Katamari said:

Elton and Bernie write together and for other acts. What  you mean  

Elton does not write. How do you not know this? I expected a pop forum to know this knowledge. 
 

https://www.cheatsheet.com/entertainment/elton-john-once-admitted-why-he-doesnt-write-his-own-lyrics.html/

[babyforlife]

True. 
Last Charlie’s good music is One Call Away.

[Katamari]

19 minutes ago, Tropez said:

Elton does not write. How do you not know this? I expected a pop forum to know this knowledge. 
 

https://www.cheatsheet.com/entertainment/elton-john-once-admitted-why-he-doesnt-write-his-own-lyrics.html/

There is more to songwriting than lyrics  

[KingJay]

Yea his music is pretty bad tbh. Like his songs have good parts, but most of his songs as a whole suck.

[Planet Mars]

The most annoying thing about his music is his voice, it's ridiculously grating, makes Justin Bieber sound like Luther Vandross. He sounds like he's trying to take a s*it the entire time. Literally what ruined Attention for me (that and radio playing it every 5 minutes).

[Tropez]

57 minutes ago, Katamari said:

There is more to songwriting than lyrics  

You know what I meant. So why are you quoting me…

[Bussea]

Just in 2019?

[D_Man3379]

I mean, he wasn’t wrong. 

[PoisonPill]

6 hours ago, Kimi said:

Elton knows a thing or two about releasing shitty music 

Does he though?

[SavagePapi]

3 hours ago, Bloodflowers. said:

J.Lovers to J.Lo when telling her about her 2009 music output  @SavagePapi

Don't remind me! 

 

THE HORROR when I heard "Flopuboutins" & "Flop Out The Oven" on my college laptop for the first time. I still can't unhear it. I remember hearing it with a friend and being visibly disappointed.

[Katamari]

56 minutes ago, Tropez said:

You know what I meant. So why are you quoting me…

i could say the same about you  

[Genius1111]

Interesting to see this topic being resurrected after the Great Forum Reset.

 

---

 

I would respectfully disagree. I Warned Myself and Cheating on You are so mich better than Light Switch and Hilarious.

[Digitalism]

Those tracks were all mid

But the ones aren't that much better 

[JCsNumba1Fan]

Voicenotes was a good pop boy album. But I must admit I haven’t been interested in anything after that. He’s a talented musician but it seems like he’s struggling to please the GP. He’s chasing a huge hit that may never come, which is why he keeps scrapping and reworking his album. Trying to chart is holding him back, imo. 

[Snoopy]

Elton is correct

[yassskween]

the annoyings are fighting

[Forever Winter]

4 hours ago, Bussea said:

Just in 2019?

[Into The Void]

9 hours ago, Dragonfly said:

so we have Elton to blame for the long wait?  

I Warned Myself and Cheating on You were amazing

Probably scrapped the album because of him but I don't care. Based on the snippets on tok I can't wait

[Into The Void]

5 hours ago, Planet Mars said:

The most annoying thing about his music is his voice, it's ridiculously grating, makes Justin Bieber sound like Luther Vandross. He sounds like he's trying to take a s*it the entire time. Literally what ruined Attention for me (that and radio playing it every 5 minutes).

Really I love his voice