Diarrhoea Posted June 20, 2020 Posted June 20, 2020 42 minutes ago, DevonRoars said: Also also @thecptz Oblivion’s points are definitely getting halved, right? In Ireland it reached #92 ?? Wikipedia says ‘promo single’ but she was at the stage where there’s basically no distinction imo we might put this to a vote? I could see someone sending this in good faith but personally I think it breaks the rules
Dessy Posted June 20, 2020 Posted June 20, 2020 Just now, LGBTQQ2IAAA+ said: Wikipedia says ‘promo single’ but she was at the stage where there’s basically no distinction imo we might put this to a vote? I could see someone sending this in good faith but personally I think it breaks the rules I mean if they're using the Wikipedia themselves then they have no way of knowing the distinction, especially when "promo singles" were allowed in the first place
Diarrhoea Posted June 20, 2020 Posted June 20, 2020 Just now, Dessy said: I mean if they're using the Wikipedia themselves then they have no way of knowing the distinction, especially when "promo singles" were allowed in the first place Yeah which is why I’m :/ like I would not call it a promo single as someone who followed the rollout but Wikipedia says otherwise, I don’t wanna penalise someone because I disagree with the Wikipedia classification. let me checking the other allegation in here x
Diarrhoea Posted June 20, 2020 Posted June 20, 2020 11 minutes ago, Noah said: and Au/Ra - Panic Room charted in Belgium, Ireland, Scotland, and the UK @LGBTQQ2IAAA+ @thecptz okay well this one is defo getting halved x
clue Posted June 20, 2020 Posted June 20, 2020 28 minutes ago, Velvet said: I thought that rule was only for singles tho Oblivion was a promo single yassss get them
Velvet Posted June 20, 2020 Posted June 20, 2020 (edited) I mean I followed the release of Visions and while Oblivion was released 5 months before only Genesis got an official single treatment by 4AD following the success she found on social media it's very much a technicality considering her indie status and the label tho so however people feel is fine Edited June 20, 2020 by Velvet
Noah Posted June 20, 2020 Posted June 20, 2020 10 minutes ago, LGBTQQ2IAAA+ said: it didn’t, the Hot charts in NZ are a bit like the Spotify Viral charts and don’t count. neither does Scotland oh ok mess wellitsover.jpg
Diarrhoea Posted June 20, 2020 Posted June 20, 2020 5 minutes ago, Velvet said: I mean I followed the release of Visions and while Oblivion was released 5 months before only Genesis got an official single treatment by 4AD following the success she found on social media I mean with indie acts like that’s all singles/promo singles are all the same really, it’s more of a distinction for pop acts and whether a single gets a radio push or not. So I’d personally say it’s a single but if whoever sent that song saw differently I’d say it’s a grey area I don’t wanna really punish someone for x
XO_Life Posted June 20, 2020 Posted June 20, 2020 Yeah. I am definitely getting eliminated. At least I reached the overall Top 3 and was #1 in my group.
Diarrhoea Posted June 20, 2020 Posted June 20, 2020 1 minute ago, Fruity said: not a green area Do I look like I can read? I’m gay
Fruity Posted June 20, 2020 Posted June 20, 2020 well I feel kinda bad for the panic room girl, maybe they assumed remixes didnt count But the Camelphat version was pretty big here. Lemme give it 12 points.
Velvet Posted June 20, 2020 Posted June 20, 2020 Yes I also feel bad for the panic room chanteuse But both versions got combined for the charts
Tom Vercetti Posted June 20, 2020 Posted June 20, 2020 51 minutes ago, LGBTQQ2IAAA+ said: it didn’t, the Hot charts in NZ are a bit like the Spotify Viral charts and don’t count. neither does Scotland I think we all need further clarification on what specific Country's hot charts count and what doesn't count via a list or something because I wouldn't have known about NZ nor Scotland's until now. Also need some further clarification on if promo singles that charted in multiple countries in any position are eligible @thecptz.
ATRL Moderator Element Posted June 20, 2020 ATRL Moderator Posted June 20, 2020 3 minutes ago, Tom Vercetti said: I think we all need further clarification on what specific Country's hot charts count and what doesn't count via a list or something because I wouldn't have known about NZ nor Scotland's until now. Also need some further clarification on if promo singles that charted in multiple countries in any position are eligible @thecptz. a list of charts would be helpful tbh +1
Diarrhoea Posted June 20, 2020 Posted June 20, 2020 38 minutes ago, Tom Vercetti said: I think we all need further clarification on what specific Country's hot charts count and what doesn't count via a list or something because I wouldn't have known about NZ nor Scotland's until now. Also need some further clarification on if promo singles that charted in multiple countries in any position are eligible @thecptz. well Scotland isn’t an independent country so it’s like... if California has a chart and if you look at the NZ chart you can see it’s clearly not the official one
Recommended Posts