Dessy Posted March 3, 2020 Posted March 3, 2020 1 hour ago, Genio said: Team: of course Dessy will pick a sex round send Spoiler
luckystrike Posted March 4, 2020 Author Posted March 4, 2020 Spoiler PAIR 1 Rihanna: Oh wow this was a very great song! i had never listened to it, I really enjoyed the production and the overall vibe of the song, it obviously fits the theme you gave perfectly Ariana Grande: maybe the best song on Sweetener, this song gives me so many emotions when I listen to it, I'm very happy you sent this and made something with it Overall Concept: I really liked your concept! The two songs work amazing together and work perfectly to showcase what you presented in your story, you kept it cute and simple but nailed it, great job PAIR 2 Miguel: I was bopping to this! It was a good song, maybe lost me a bit towards the end but still good nontheless Fantasia: amazing she did that, I always love the emotion she puts into her vocals so yeah great song Overall Concept: well your concept was okay, I definitely see how you connected the songs and made them work but it felt a little lazy to me, you did the challenge but not as strong as others, the songs fit the story you gave but I feel like you could maybe have explained a bit more PAIR 4 Lana Del Rey: this was cute, it's a very good track and on point with what you wanted to represent Nicki Minaj: I was not a fan of this, it started out good but it bored me as it kept playing, I didn't really find it interesting, I liked some aspects like that guitar on the chorus but... yeah Overall Concept: well you sent two songs about practically the same thing, but you didn't really create a storyline with it, it just feels like two songs on the same theme and that's it, you couldve found a way to make it like a sequel but you missed it PAIR 5 Marina: I hadn't listened to this in sooo long omg the memories, it's a very fun song and classic old Marina, nails the part of your story that you chose Demi Lovato: truly a heartbreaking song, you can feel her emotions through her voice and it's just so haunting and powerful Overall Concept: well so you had my favorite concept out of everyone, I love how you showcased this and the deep explanation makes it feel like these two songs are actually part 1 ans part 2 of the story you're presenting, amazing job PAIR 6 Lorde: very cute! a chill laid back song, it's very fitting for what you're showcasing and it's a good song overall Céline Dion: well the lyrics are obviously on point for your theme, the song overall was just okay, didn't catch my attention a lot but it was not bad at all, it had its interesting bits Overall Concept: I loveeeeed what you two did with this, this was very original and your choices worked perfecly together, you connected the songs in every way possible and that was exactly what I wanted, great job PAIR 7 Janelle Monáe: oh wow this song was very good, I enjoyed it and bopped to it the whole time, it's very fun Katy Perry: this is a bop, hate Migos on this though, but I think people hate on this song too much, its a cute bop Overall Concept: here's the thing, I really liked what you did here with all the food imagery and all that, but I feel like there was a little something missing, the songs work great together and you had a good concept but you didn't go as deep as you should've for it to work 100%, see the Lana and Nicki critique above, you have 2 songs about the same thing that match but didn't really create anything with it, although you found more ways to connect it with the food thing, I still missed something PAIR 8 Kacey Musgraves: this is a cute song, it's lovey and fun and works very well with with your theme Alicia Keys: oh wow I actually loved this, everything about it was great, from lyrics to production to everything, amazing song Overall Concept: Very cute! I love how you even gave the story a title, it's very creative and fitting, although your concept was simple you executed it very well with both songs and your story, well done! PAIR 9 HyunA: this song was okay, it started out fine but it lost me abit, the lyrics work perfectly though so good job Ellie Goulding: oh wow this is such a great song, the production was so good, I really enjoyed it, I loved the darkish vibe Overall Concept: You went straight to the point and did what y'all had to do, cute! Your songs matched very well and you explained it very straightforward, great choices PAIR 10 Kelly Clarkson: I enjoyed this, it definitely feels very fitting to your theme and it was a nice song, simple but good LOONA: so the song was okay, now I don't know if it was the translation but I'm not too crazy for this, it kinda fits but something isn't clicking to me nnn sorry Overall Concept: It was okay, I don't know if the LOONA song worked 100% for me according to your explanation, but it was not bad, I totally see the strory within the songs but maybe just not as strong as in other groups, but you had a story and matched your songs so good job Spoiler @EriKills @Touch It @boys @icy @Staryu @Rence @Mr. Duff@Sabbath @PinkBox @Noah @Dessy@kiiwii @thecptz @Not Like The Movies @touya kinomoto @Alena @Legend E @K$Ellie
thecptz Posted March 4, 2020 Posted March 4, 2020 i thought you already listened to golden hour we- but yeah listen to it astro :grammy:
thecptz Posted March 4, 2020 Posted March 4, 2020 26 minutes ago, Overprotected said: Oop I might not be the last judge this time PYC
Overprotected Posted March 4, 2020 Posted March 4, 2020 Spoiler Rihanna and Ariana: I had never heard Miss Rihanna’s song before, it’s quite dull and dated but eh it works for the theme. Better Off it’s one of my least faves from Sweetergod, I think I gave it a 0 on her discog rate kii, but I do like it better in this context especially following such a bad song. Anyways I really liked the subtle but cute little storyline you guys worked with and that’s what matters. Miguel and Fantasia: Ok I did not like that Miguel song what happened there, lyrically it works but I don’t know, sonically it doesn’t sell the love part of the storyline unless you guys searched for cohesive songs in which case, good job. Fantasia ha song was way better in comparison. Overall the storyline serves creativity but then also the task was to “connect them as if they were a story sung by the same artist” so yeah Lana and Nicki: Lana, cute song. Nicki, cute aswell. Ok so reading your explanation it seemed like there was no storyline at all, just a theme cohesiveness which is good but not all that was asked from you guys. Now, listening to the songs I guess there’s a little bit of progression in the sense that Lana seems to be a bit blinded by the love and in Nicki’s song the character is more self aware? That’s me doing the work though. Marina and Demi: A team that did everything they were asked to right? Yup! I’m not in love with the songs, they’re alright but you guys did a great job with the explanation, theme and storyline. Cerdine and Lorde: See above. Similar themes though, very inchresting, I guess when it comes down to it the previous team did a better job formatting their explanation x Janelle and Katy: LUV Take A Byte top 3 from Dirty Janelle. Bon Appetit a guilty pleasure bop ngl. Now when I saw those selections I thought they would barely work together outside the eating references but the explanation sold the theme and storyline so good job there. Kacey and Alicia: I fear for when you run out of Golden Hour songs but we’re not there yet so I stan. Never heard this Alicia song before, it’s really cute. I like your explanation and the fact the way you present your theme makes it sound less basic than it is. That being said, the storyline is still not the most creative but at least you guys followed instructions so there’s that. Ellie and Hyuna: Ok this is so far the best out of a toxic relationship pair, cute theme and storyline (done in a more creative way imo thanks to the lyrics of the songs) and surprisingly good songs. I especially like how in HyunA’s song the monotone vocals work for the feeling trapped part and then you have Miss Ellie belting about how she’s free now, it probably wasn’t intentional but it’s a cute little detail. Kelly and LOONA: Ok I know you guys were the first to send so I can’t and won’t drag you for doing yet ANOTHER toxic relationship theme but can you come up with something else.gif Anyways Kelly served with her song, love the vocals. Loona a cute lil’ bop. I guess I’m not loving the huge musical contrast between the songs so that sets you apart from the other teams but not exactly in a good way.
EriKills Posted March 4, 2020 Posted March 4, 2020 51 minutes ago, Overprotected said: Oop I might not be the last judge this time Not the last but def the WORST omg
touya kinomoto Posted March 4, 2020 Posted March 4, 2020 miss OP serving taste?!? I could not believe it. but werk miss number 1 moo stan!
Recommended Posts