smholiv Posted February 2, 2020 Posted February 2, 2020 3 hours ago, touya kinomoto said: i am not seeing shinee. what happened @minho? Someone said they’d be tanking kpop I didn’t want GODnee to be subject to racist hate
Staryu Posted February 2, 2020 Posted February 2, 2020 z. f(x) - déjà vu This is a cute bop, it had my hips shaking y. indila - dernière danse She has a nice voice and this is cute, but just cute. x. blackpink - DDU DU DDU DU One of the kpop songs I actually know and love, a smart choice! w. angèle - flou I enjoyed this song alot, it's one of the few I listened to twice. It was very pleasant. v. era istrefi - bonbon Yas I remember this bop u. suzane - l'insatisfait I liked this, it has a nice beat/rhythm to it. t. utada hikaru - 俺の彼女 Utada has a pretty voice, I love her KH song. This song is kinda long, I got a little bored. s. shakira - la tortura The male vocals on this annoy me. And Shakira's vocals tbh idk sometimes her vocals get a little grating.
touya kinomoto Posted February 2, 2020 Posted February 2, 2020 41 minutes ago, minho said: Someone said they’d be tanking kpop I didn’t want GODnee to be subject to racist hate the nerve of that person... view would easily stomp the competition
smholiv Posted February 2, 2020 Posted February 2, 2020 1 hour ago, touya kinomoto said: the nerve of that person... view would easily stomp the competition this would’ve been well received too well maybe next time
Navyofbadgals Posted February 2, 2020 Author Posted February 2, 2020 Bagels' Critiques First up, if you have not sent your rankings, PLEASE do so You have 24 hours and then some left Please send, or let me know if you need more time Spoiler @Element @rl231 @kiiwii @Overprotected @Moonlightbae @Psycho @Staryu @Alena @luckystrike @shelven @thecptz @minho @Legend E @PinkBox @Not Like The Movies @Hug @Clueless @Astronomy @Disruptive @prézli @touya kinomoto GROUP 1 Quote a. Britney Spears - Coupure électrique - pff when this came out I remember some french peepz on my tl mocking it; https://www.huffingtonpost.fr/2016/08/26/britney-spears-coupure-electrique-paroles-francais_n_11715750.html this too I just think that this was not the right choice for this round at all.. and in all fairness, it wasn't the right choice for any round. It goes nowhere b. angèle - balance ton quoi - ugh I'm a sucker for some good pop in French. Angèle was one of my favorite discoveries of last year so I'm happy to see her back (twice!). I really like this song as well, like pretty much every song she released so far. I feel like there were better options that you could pick, but this is still a good pick c. kali uchis - nuestro planeta - yes this bops not my fav song from the album, but still like it. d. alexandra stan - noi 2 - this is a betty who 2.0 I don't know why anyone would send in an artist like that, if they bombed pretty hardcore the last time they were sent in This is.. not good. It does nothing for me, it's not catchy, it's not beautiful, it's not that fun.. so like what does it want to achieve? No clue, but it ain't trying to achieve a high ranking, that's for sure e. kali uchis - solita - this is cute, like it a bit more than the other kali song this round. She sounds a bit more engaged with the track. A cute bop f. f(x) - 4 walls - this song comes from one of the few KPop albums I listened to so it's fun to see it back I think this is a really solid track in general, and one of the better kpop songs sent in this szn. Not sure if the rapping was needed, but the rest of the song is great g. alma - requiem - one of my favorite ESC songs of all time, and dare I say one of my fav songs of all time too I love this **** yup yup yup! h. paty cantu - el sexo y amor - I was gonna say nice instrumental, but I feel like at points (esp in the verses) it doesn't match that well? I think this is still a nice choice though, it's interesting, and one of the few songs this round that I don't recognize i. aya nakamura - pookie - it's a bop, but I don't think it's that great of a song either Very modern and on-trend though, and not a bad pick, but with the groups being so small now, this prolly ends up lower than it would in previous rounds (relatively speaking) GROUP 2 Quote z. f(x) - déjà vu - yeah I'm bopping I think the rapping works better here, though the production is more 'timeless' on the other f(x) track this round. Nice pick still though y. indila - dernière danse - this is really a stunning track oh wow. The way it bops but is also beautiful at the same time.. miss indila her mind.. x. blackpink - DDU DU DDU DU - I will say that I think this is a fun track. But on the other hand I just.. expected more for this round. Not like everybody was that outgoing this round as I expected, but I feel like this is like.. the easiest pick for a song this round A bit of a disappointing choice, but still a nice song nevertheless w. angèle - flou - yes just yes v. era istrefi - bonbon - when this became a lowkey smash, because people thought rih sang the chorus rih sweetie! I'm SO sorry. This is a fun bop, though it has aged for me a biT u. suzane - l'insatisfait - something is missing here? Idk what but it's not fully here for me. I think it's a fun song, but it's not blowing me away. Like the breakdown though t. utada hikaru - 俺の彼女 - probably the most out there track, this round, I appreciate that. Her vocal delivery on this is stunning, but I think the song drags a biT s. shakira - la tortura - it's cute ; queen of singing and tax evasion
Navyofbadgals Posted February 2, 2020 Author Posted February 2, 2020 13 hours ago, minho said: Which songs does bagel know I know all with the exception of the Utada song, the Suzane song and miss Paty Cantu
clue Posted February 2, 2020 Posted February 2, 2020 Spoiler Alexandra Stan - Lemonade Alexandra Stan - Noi 2 Alizée - Gourmandises Alma - Requiem Angèle - Balance ton quoi Angèle - Flou AURORA - Apple Tree Avril Lavigne - Girlfriend Avril Lavigne - Rock n Roll Aya Nakamura - Pookie Betty Who - All This Woman Betty Who - Taste Beyoncé - Crazy in Love (Homecoming Live) Beyoncé - Freedom Billie Eilish - i love you Billie Eilish - my strange addiction BLACKPINK - DDU-DU DDU-DU Britney Spears - Coupure électrique Carly Rae Jepsen - I Really Like You Carly Rae Jepsen - Julien Céline Dion - The Hard Way Charli XCX - Gone Chloe X Halle - Cool People Ciara - 1, 2 Step Def Leppard - Pour Some Sugar on Me Destiny's Child - Survivor Dido - Hell After This Doja Cat - Juicy Era Istrefi - Bonbon Estelle - American Boy Everglow - Moon Fickle Friends - Sugar FIESTAR - Apple Pie Florence + The Machine - Hunger Florence + the Machine - Queen of Peace f(x) - Déjà Vu f(x) - 4 Walls GFRIEND - Wish Giorgio Moroder - Tom's Diner Gorillaz - Out of Body Halsey - Now or Never Harry Styles - Kiwi Harry Styles - Watermelon Sugar Iggy Azalea - Fancy Indila - Dernière danse James Bay - Pink Lemonade Janelle Monae - Make Me Feel Jay Sean - Down Jordin Sparks - No Air Kali Uchis - Nuestro Planeta Kali Uchis - Solita Kanye West - Monster Katy Perry - E.T. Katy Perry - Never Really Over Kelis - Milkshake Kelly Rowland - Motivation Kelsey Lu - Poor Fake Kerli - Legends Kesha - C'mon Kesha - Praying Lana Del Rey - Love Lana Del Rey - Norman ****ing Rockwell LÉON - Pink Louisa - YES Madonna - Beat Goes On Mariah Carey - Fantasy Mariah Carey - Honey MARINA - Orange Trees Meghan Trainor - Better Melanie Fiona - 4am Mia Martha - Beast Miley Cyrus - The Most Miley Cyrus - Unholy N.E.R.D. & Rihanna - Lemon Namie Amuro - First Timer Nelly Furtado - Promiscuous Nick Jonas - Numb Nicki Minaj - Your Love OOHYO - Pizza Paty Cantu - El Sexo y Amor P!nk - (Hey Why) Miss You Sometime Pia Mia - Do It Again Pussycat Dolls - Wait a Minute Red Velvet - In & Out Red Velvet - LP Rihanna - Work Robin Schultz - Sugar Robyn - Honey Selena Gomez - Good for You Self Esteem - I'm Shy Shakira - La Tortura Shawn Mendes - Mercy Sia - Alive Sigrid - basic Sigrid - Never Mine Suzane - L'INSATISFAIT SZA - Love Galore The Cardigans - Happy Meal II The Chordettes - Lollipop The Pussycat Dolls - Buttons Tinashe - 2 On Tinashe - Party Favors Tove Lo - Mateo Tove Lo - Stay Over Troye Sivan - Plum Turnover - Number on the Gate Twice - Trick It Utada Hikaru - 俺の彼女 VÉRITÉ - body in my bed Weyes Blood - A Lot's Gonna Change Weyes Blood - Wild Time WJSN - You Got Yeule - An Angel Held Me Like a Child Друг (Drug) feat. anna severnee - деньночь Updated song list @Navyofbadgals
clue Posted February 2, 2020 Posted February 2, 2020 Quote Round 4: The Scammys Round 4 - Entries - Results Round 5: World Tour Round 5 - Entries - Results @Navyofbadgals
Navyofbadgals Posted February 2, 2020 Author Posted February 2, 2020 23 minutes ago, Clueless said: Reveal hidden contents Alexandra Stan - Lemonade Alexandra Stan - Noi 2 Alizée - Gourmandises Alma - Requiem Angèle - Balance ton quoi Angèle - Flou AURORA - Apple Tree Avril Lavigne - Girlfriend Avril Lavigne - Rock n Roll Aya Nakamura - Pookie Betty Who - All This Woman Betty Who - Taste Beyoncé - Crazy in Love (Homecoming Live) Beyoncé - Freedom Billie Eilish - i love you Billie Eilish - my strange addiction BLACKPINK - DDU-DU DDU-DU Britney Spears - Coupure électrique Carly Rae Jepsen - I Really Like You Carly Rae Jepsen - Julien Céline Dion - The Hard Way Charli XCX - Gone Chloe X Halle - Cool People Ciara - 1, 2 Step Def Leppard - Pour Some Sugar on Me Destiny's Child - Survivor Dido - Hell After This Doja Cat - Juicy Era Istrefi - Bonbon Estelle - American Boy Everglow - Moon Fickle Friends - Sugar FIESTAR - Apple Pie Florence + The Machine - Hunger Florence + the Machine - Queen of Peace f(x) - Déjà Vu f(x) - 4 Walls GFRIEND - Wish Giorgio Moroder - Tom's Diner Gorillaz - Out of Body Halsey - Now or Never Harry Styles - Kiwi Harry Styles - Watermelon Sugar Iggy Azalea - Fancy Indila - Dernière danse James Bay - Pink Lemonade Janelle Monae - Make Me Feel Jay Sean - Down Jordin Sparks - No Air Kali Uchis - Nuestro Planeta Kali Uchis - Solita Kanye West - Monster Katy Perry - E.T. Katy Perry - Never Really Over Kelis - Milkshake Kelly Rowland - Motivation Kelsey Lu - Poor Fake Kerli - Legends Kesha - C'mon Kesha - Praying Lana Del Rey - Love Lana Del Rey - Norman ****ing Rockwell LÉON - Pink Louisa - YES Madonna - Beat Goes On Mariah Carey - Fantasy Mariah Carey - Honey MARINA - Orange Trees Meghan Trainor - Better Melanie Fiona - 4am Mia Martha - Beast Miley Cyrus - The Most Miley Cyrus - Unholy N.E.R.D. & Rihanna - Lemon Namie Amuro - First Timer Nelly Furtado - Promiscuous Nick Jonas - Numb Nicki Minaj - Your Love OOHYO - Pizza Paty Cantu - El Sexo y Amor P!nk - (Hey Why) Miss You Sometime Pia Mia - Do It Again Pussycat Dolls - Wait a Minute Red Velvet - In & Out Red Velvet - LP Rihanna - Work Robin Schultz - Sugar Robyn - Honey Selena Gomez - Good for You Self Esteem - I'm Shy Shakira - La Tortura Shawn Mendes - Mercy Sia - Alive Sigrid - basic Sigrid - Never Mine Suzane - L'INSATISFAIT SZA - Love Galore The Cardigans - Happy Meal II The Chordettes - Lollipop The Pussycat Dolls - Buttons Tinashe - 2 On Tinashe - Party Favors Tove Lo - Mateo Tove Lo - Stay Over Troye Sivan - Plum Turnover - Number on the Gate Twice - Trick It Utada Hikaru - 俺の彼女 VÉRITÉ - body in my bed Weyes Blood - A Lot's Gonna Change Weyes Blood - Wild Time WJSN - You Got Yeule - An Angel Held Me Like a Child Друг (Drug) feat. anna severnee - деньночь Updated song list @Navyofbadgals Thank you so much lemme update later cause mobile
ATRL Moderator Element Posted February 2, 2020 ATRL Moderator Posted February 2, 2020 Alexandra Stan being banned now :rolf:
Alena Posted February 3, 2020 Posted February 3, 2020 z. f(x) - déjà vu ehh, pretty boring. i've heard a million better K-Pop songs. y. indila - dernière danse it's alright, french is a very beautiful language uwu. x. blackpink - DDU DU DDU DU a k-pop CLASSIC w. angèle - flou beautiful song, reminds me of Tove Lo's melodies abit v. era istrefi - bonbon yassss, so catchy ♥ loves it. u. suzane - l'insatisfait ehh, most boring of the french songs so far. would not listen again :tellha: t. utada hikaru - 俺の彼女 meh :wendy3: s. shakira - la tortura i used to LOVEEEE this as a kid a slay!
kiiwii Posted February 3, 2020 Posted February 3, 2020 a. Britney Spears – Coupure Électrique it’s like, the most boring song on the album… not a fan. b. Angèle - Balance ton quoi this is kinda cute, the production is nice. c. Kali Uchis - Nuestro Planeta might not be the best on the album, but it’s chill. d. Alexandra Stan - Noi 2 most people are bashing it, but i think this is a cute bop. e. Kali Uchis - Solita she sounds so good on this. might be a bit slow for me, but that’s okay! f. f(x) - 4 Walls that rapping part was ugly. pretty mediocre song tho g. Alma - Requiem rather dull. not terrible, i guess h. Paty Cantu - El Sexo y Amor ooh, this is really cute. i like it a lot i. Aya Nakamura - Pookie wait, this kinda bops!
ATRL Moderator Element Posted February 3, 2020 ATRL Moderator Posted February 3, 2020 z. f(x) - déjà vu - the melody didn't click for me but the production was not bad y. indila - dernière danse - oh wow this was stunning! the instrumentation and her voice created a lot of drama and i loved it x. blackpink - DDU DU DDU DU - i remember listening to this awhile back and was underwhelmed, but i liked it a lot more listening to it here! w. angèle - flou - FANTASTIC. i would add this to my playlists tbh v. era istrefi - bonbon - i tried to send this for the food round but it wasn't about food laksjdlaks. anyway, a bop!! love u. suzane - l'insatisfait - her voice is kind of cool but overall the song wasn't doing it for me like some others t. utada hikaru - 俺の彼女 - this one lost my attention honestly... it definitely dragged s. shakira - la tortura - ok but why not chantaje???? i agree with others here tbh it got annoying at times
thecptz Posted February 3, 2020 Posted February 3, 2020 a. Britney Spears - Coupure électrique i- i really don't know how to feel about this. i mean its not THAT bad but i don't really like it either b. angèle - balance ton quoi i- ooh- ooh- WHEW. this is very interesting. the beat and her vocal c. kali uchis - nuestro planeta omg YASSSS i ADORE this song. urgh so good queen kali did tha! d. alexandra stan - noi 2 this is better than what was sent by element. i think it's okay. e. kali uchis - solita i prefer nuestro planeta to this but they are both a great song f. f(x) - 4 walls i actually like the rap lmao. great song! g. alma - requiem well its cute h. paty cantu - el sexo y amor well its cute [2] i. aya nakamura - pookie omg this is a big bop
Navyofbadgals Posted February 3, 2020 Author Posted February 3, 2020 @Overprotected @Moonlightbae @Not Like The Movies @Legend E @Disruptive @Astronomy @prézli @touya kinomoto if im not mistaken, you guys still need to send your rankings! You have a lil over 8 hours left to do so, let me know if you guys can make it and if you can, pls send
Navyofbadgals Posted February 3, 2020 Author Posted February 3, 2020 3 minutes ago, Clueless said: Coupure Electrique is high art
thecptz Posted February 3, 2020 Posted February 3, 2020 24 minutes ago, Clueless said: Coupure Electrique is high art
PinkBox Posted February 3, 2020 Posted February 3, 2020 50 minutes ago, Clueless said: Coupure Electrique is high art Very artsy fartsy
Overprotected Posted February 3, 2020 Posted February 3, 2020 a. Britney Spears - Coupure électrique I think I understand the thought process behind sending this but it just aged badly for me b. angèle - balance ton quoi Oh this is very cute I like it c. kali uchis - nuestro planeta Cute lil' bop but why did you send this lq audio unofficial video you flop d. alexandra stan - noi 2 This isn't as bad as I thought e. kali uchis - solita Period! it has a little too much english but the host accepted it so f. f(x) - 4 walls Um didn't like this as much g. alma - requiem bonjour mademoiselle, je porte des lunettes de soleil, je veux me venger, je hurle, oui oui baguette, bisous! It's afwul h. paty cantu - el sexo y amor It's lovely i. aya nakamura - pookie No thanks luv
miguel Posted February 3, 2020 Posted February 3, 2020 CRITIQUES this is by FAR the worst round so far, y'all need to step it tf UP! GROUP 1 Spoiler Britney Spears - Coupure électrique y'all really out here thinking of Britney Spears when asked for a song in another language, i'm- anyway, this is boring af. do better. angèle - balance ton quoi i don't care for this at all. it's kinda cute but kinda boring at the same time. kali uchis - nuestro planeta this is like trying to be a reggaeton song, but falling flat, like BIG time. the feature was lowkey the best part of the song. another boring ass song tbh. also, idk if she always sounds like that, but her voice sounds SO lazy. alexandra stan - noi 2 is this not on spotify? anyway, this is generic and boring. kinda at the top of my list rn which is absolutely tragic kali uchis - solita her voice really is like that, huh that said this is MUCH better than the previous kali song and well the best song so far. the beat actually comes through this time around and she actually does a bit more with her voice f(x) - 4 walls this falls on the higher end of the ranking, it bops a bit that said, it's generic af and i really wouldn't go back to it alma - requiem ok, this is nice. props for actually sending in a decent entry the bridge is probably the best part of the song btw, whew paty cantu - el sexo y amor WHY in the world is this song talking about love/sex between a 32 y/o man and a 16 y/o girl? anyway, if i pretend i don't understand the lyrics, the song is cute, i like the melody and her voice still a song i wouldn't go back to tho aya nakamura - pookie issa no from me GROUP 2 Spoiler f(x) - déjà vu i- cringy, dated, kidz bop realness indila - dernière danse this is quite cute. love her voice and how the song built up, whew. Great entry, good job blackpink - DDU DU DDU DU needless to say, issa generic ass BOP. almost everyone else has done worse so props to you! angèle - flou this is better than the other angèle song, it's fairly cute era istrefi - bonbon yup yup, a bop suzane - l'insatisfait eh, it's ok utada hikaru - 俺の彼女 not a vocaroo entrace, kii this is cute tho, i like it... maybe a bit too long tho shakira - la tortura when i saw this entry i thought there were so many better shakira songs that you could send (and there are) but seeing how this round turned out, well this easily one of the best songs sent considering both groups, great job, this issa classic Spoiler @Element @rl231 @kiiwii @Overprotected @Moonlightbae @Psycho @Staryu @Alena @luckystrike @shelven @thecptz @minho @Legend E @PinkBox @Not Like The Movies @Hug @Clueless
Recommended Posts