Search the Community

Both debuted around 2008. Both were monster chart toppers in the 2010's. Both have iconic eras and smashes. Both are far removed from their commercial peaks. ATRL decides once and for all. Vote accordingly

Who would be a good candidate for Yoruba priestess, lawyer, and life coach Iyanla Vanzant to fix?

Which album is better to your ears?

Obsessed vs Born To Die I Got It Bad vs Ultraviolence 2 Die 4 vs Honeymoon Nothing On (But the Radio) vs Lust for Life It Could've Been U vs Norman ******* Rockwell! Von dutch a. g. cook remix feat. addison rae vs Chemtrails over the Country Club Diet Pepsi vs Blue Banisters Aquamarine vs Did You Know That There's a Tunnel Under Ocean Blvd

As we know Gaga's upcoming album was originally envisioned as a dark, underground project packed with high-energy 'rah rah' bops. But with recent events (FAD, Harlequin) and Disease's concerning performance on the charts, should Gaga consider shifting direction and make LG7 full of HAC-friendly anthems that the general public is eager for? Would ATRL root for GaGa in this scenario?

Before Elon, pedaling NFTs, and liking white supremacist posts on Twitter, Grimes was on the cutting edge of music. Which is the more game-changing and superior body of work between her two cult-classic albums?

Recently on ATRL there's been lots of discussion surrounding Lady Gaga and Katy Perry about whether both stars are in the "same boat". However, with much of this discussion focused on their music release, what with recent releases from both stars having shaking starts (or in some cases, filing to even start), I thought it would be interesting to compare the acting careers of both of them, and discuss who clears in that area, or if they're "boatmates" here as well.Included below is a selection of both stars' filmographies, not comprehensive by any means bc i cba to sift through all the "appears as herself" roles in each filmography to decide what was worth including. Feel free to compare both the selection below and their full filmographies (linked in each of their names) for yourself. Lady Gaga: Film: Machete Kills (2013), supporting role Sin City: A Dame To Kill For (2014), supporting role Gaga: Five Foot Two (2017), documentary A Star Is Born (2018), main role House of Gucci (2021), main role Joker: Folie à Deux (2024), main role TV: American Horror Story: Hotel (2015), main role American Horror Story: Roanoke (2016) (guest star) Katy Perry Film: The Smurfs (2011), main role, voice (Smurfette) Kety Perr: Pert of Me 3D (2012), documentary The Smurfs 2 (2013), main role, voice (Smurfette) TV: How I Met Your Mother (2011) guest stay, 1 episode Raising Hope (2012) guest star, 1 episode Who has the best acting career? Whose is bigger, and who has displayed superior acting abilities? Research, vote and discuss.

Which one released the better collab hit this year, the New York chanteuse or the Pennsylvania songstress?

Which pop girl would you assign to Earth, Fire, Water and Air?

A simple question which is the bigger lead single? On the Hot 100 Disease has currently peaked at #27 but is very stable on streaming with 47m Spotify streams and has a strong chance of becoming a slow and steady sleeper hit. Xtina's Not Myself Tonight got to #23 on the Hot 100 and is just shy of being certified Gold and has 38 million streams on Spotify. I feel like Disease will surely surpass NMT, but then again Bionic was too ahead of its time so if it's time comes soon it's over for the other girls. Both songs were big moments in stan culture for certain reasons and made a big impact. What do you think ATRL?

Well... GoldDerby (ATRL's Version)

Madonna's iconic second studio album Like A Virgin, produced by Nile Rodgers, turns 40 today. What's your favorite song + video from this era, ATRL? Notable achievements: - Referred to as the album that made Madonna a global superstar. - 40 million equivalent album sales. - The first album by a solo female artist to sell over five million copies in the United States (10x platinum as of 1998). - Five international hits: "Like A Virgin" (#1), "Material Girl" (#2), "Angel" (#5), "Into The Groove" (U.K #1) & "Dress You Up" (#5). - Selected for preservation in the United States' National Recording Registry by the Library of Congress due to it being considered "culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant".

Some of these artists haven't had a solo #1 in years, others in nearly a quarter century. Who would shock you most with a solo #1 hit? I picked artists that were popular when we were kids.

What is your fave album out of these ones that missed the #1 (only studio albums count)

Which Max Martin produced, monochrome album is your pick? Discuss

Which female singer is the ultimate MOTHER of alternative music?

Since 2020 Ms Icy has been teasing her album Pretty ***** Music and has released several singles. We are now almost in 2025 and still no sign of an album release date is it ever going to happen? Even Normani released her album eventually lol. Will a Saweetie album ever get released? Will you be streaming/buying if it comes out?

Quintessential 80s dance-pop albums Control vs. Madonna Provocative, artistic and boundary-breaking albums Rhythm Nation 1814 vs. Like a Prayer Sexual and House-influenced albums Janet. vs. Erotica Experimental and critically beloved albums The Velvet Rope vs. Ray of Light Back to fun and less pretentious albums All for You vs. Music

Even tho they may compete in different fields (feel-good pop, disco-pop revival, eletropop-diva), which undeniable gem does it better for you?

Rosé and Bruno are smashing with "APT." We are on the fourth week of 2025, and it looks like Rosé could make history as the first Korean female to hit the BB YEC. Here is where she is at currently: 2025, Week 2: 184 2025, Week 3: 153 2025, Week 4: 129 The #100 for 2024 was Chihiro by Billie Eilish with 1,390 points (1.38M song units and 0.0B airplay). Can Rose make it?

A number one on TRL Countdown's chart dated July 20, 2006. Unironically one of her biggest hits as well. Do you remember it?

I was bored, so I thought let's have a good ole finished FOLK OFFFFFF *Pew pew pew pew * *sirens everywhere* *cash register noise*. So, our first fighter of this symphonic jamberry is Folklore, the cult classic, Midsomer dreams album of global cult leader and all-around girl's girl T-Swizzle *^*. Our next fighter is an old timer, a true blast for the past, and the underdog in this auditory battle for supremacy, Tales of Us, a warped, folky, trans dimensional nature spirits inducing, nocturnal breeze by the underground but sometimes mainstream duo Goldfrapp. Fighters to your positions!!!....... Now ATRL, the power is in your hands to determine who will take the L and who is the Folksy Champion this week. Disclaimer, listen to at least the Disc 1 of BOTH albums before making your decisions. Ok, Time for the Folk OFFFFF to begin. FIGHT!!!!!!

Any others I didn't name you think are deserving

What's your input?