news Taliban bans windows near women

[Communion]

On 12/31/2024 at 1:20 PM, Frozen99 said:

why are you putting words in my mouth?  whether we accept portions of those women (which is unthinkable) those horrible things will continue to happen to other women that won't be able to escape (which is the vast majority). so you wanna deport all the afghan women away?... like i said, one of the stupidest takes, i've seen.

1) No one is putting words in your mouth. You're arguing over the logical conclusions for the view you're putting forward (not supporting political asylum). If you believe women who do not want to live under a certain interpretation of Islam are being politically subjugated, the logical conclusion would be to aid them via political asylum.

 

2) You're now arguing that concepts like political asylum or refugee status shouldn't exist unless all of a population can be given it. You see how that looks like trolling, right?

 

3) You're now actually arguing something specific. Yes, Afghanistan has a large population, but that requires further questions. It's a land mass essentially the size of the American South with over 40M people. How centralized is the actual Taliban and its resources? How is the daily lives of the average Afghan impacted and ruled over by the Taliban? How many women actually want to leave the country? Of course you can't have all the women of a country be refugees (20M~), but also, you seem uncomfortable with the reality of why in-practice there likely wouldn't be 20M women seeking asylum in other nations. 

 

You've not yet made any actual argument debunking why offering political asylum is an essential form of aid and intervention in the issue of human rights. It also begs the question on if you think the vast majority of countries are also not already using multiple forms of aid, whether it be bargaining humanitarian aid or the threat of sanctions.

 

Also like... aren't you literally Czech? This exposes the weird hypocrisy in all of this. You have a burning hatred of what you consider to be Muslim tyranny yet 1) your nation isn't going to be the one to invade Afghanistan and 2) your country has one of the smallest non-European refugee populations. You have a lot of opinions for someone with little solutions, no?

[Inverted]

On 12/30/2024 at 1:50 PM, Trent W said:

Completely ridiculous and inhuman

 

That religion is disgusting honestly 

 

Not one good thing has ever come from it 

 

I don't care about a culture that does this level of damage to humans

There are 49 Muslim-majority countries in the world. Not all of them have a Taliban running it and they don't share "a culture." A West Asian/Mediterranean country like Turkey's culture is absolutely nothing like that of a Central Asian country like Afghanistan. And if you're going to have that bold with your attitude, at least be consistent. Your own background's religion is disgusting also and has committed the most depraved acts worldwide include the rape and torture of indigenous women (often juvenile girls actually) in the Americas, Asia and Africa. Modern day Hispanics exist today thanks to the systematic rape of their ancestors.

 

(I'm of neither religion thankfully.)

Edited Thursday at 12:02 AM by Inverted

[Trent W]

5 minutes ago, Inverted said:

There are 49 Muslim-majority countries in the world. Not all of them have a Taliban running it and they don't share "a culture." A West Asian/Mediterranean country like Turkey's culture is absolutely nothing like that of a Central Asian country like Afghanistan. And if you're going to have that attitude, at least be consistent. Your own background's religion is disgusting also and has committed the most depraved acts worldwide include the rape and torture of indigenous women in the Americas, Asia and Africa. Modern day Hispanics exist today thanks to the rape of their ancestors.

 

(I'm of neither religion thankfully.)

I'm not religious

 

But THAT religion is currently the worst one

 

[Darkgalord]

Disgusting