celeb news BBC: Katy's comeback, Joker 2 biggest flops of 2024

[Polgg48]

latest added doa flop santa claus is coming to town to the 2024 achievement, happy engagement news for gaga indeed. family time will be the happiest periods of her life

[Mariano]

14 minutes ago, ChooseyLover said:

Can you stop name dropping Britney in threads that are completely unrelated to her? The obsession is insane. Go spend some time with your loved ones or something.

  the meltdown, the user is a Britney stan who is in every Gaga thread trying it, his fav catching strays is completely normal, you're literally on ATRL.  I couldn't care less about Britney, though I do wish her well and sympathize with her    So I should go spend time with my loved ones, but you shouldn't? You should continue posting on atrl instead?  

 

OT: Gaga was not mentioned anywhere in that article, Queen  

[Colmillo]

48 minutes ago, bjorn said:

Let's compare Katy and Gagas projects in 2024

 

Successes:

Katy - 0

Gaga - DWAS (promo single)

 

Flops:

Katy -

Woman's World, Lifetime (Singles)

143 (Album)

 

Gaga -

Disease (Lead single)

Joker FAD (Movie)

Joker FAD Soundtrack 

Harlequin (Jazz Album) 

 

Let's be for real. Gagas bombs this year are in the majority! 

 

 

Mind you Gaga's "flops" are way more successful than Katy's

[bjorn]

I'm just waiting for the mods to close this thread like they do with all gaga related ones 

[Kiel D-01]

Some of you really serve mental illness. Yuck.  
 

 

[AvadaKedavra]

My main main faves are Gaga,Katy Perry,Kesha and Rihanna. Love them since 2007-2008-2009
All of em are a flop or retired. 
Bring me back to the year of 2010-2011 when they were all smashing
Pray 4 me sistrens.

Edited yesterday at 03:01 PM by AvadaKedavra

[Eternal220]

1 hour ago, bjorn said:

Let's compare Katy and Gagas projects in 2024

 

Successes:

Katy - 0

Gaga - DWAS (promo single)

 

Flops:

Katy -

Woman's World, Lifetime (Singles)

143 (Album)

 

Gaga -

Disease (Lead single)

Joker FAD (Movie)

Joker FAD Soundtrack 

Harlequin (Jazz Album) 

 

Let's be for real. Gagas bombs this year are in the majority! 

 

 

even her Jazz album flopped without collab with Tony. 
 

she really has 0 solo star power in 2024

[ericcartman]

To be honest, the list should have specifically included Gaga. I know it includes JFAD which is related to Gaga but it's about the movie flopping. Gaga herself had flop movie, flop album with flop single, flop lead single of next year's album, flop tour film, flop Olympic performance 

 

Edit: Forgot she also released a Christmas song that flopped

Edited 23 hours ago by ericcartman

[bjorn]

38 minutes ago, Kiel D-01 said:

Some of you really serve mental illness. Yuck.  
 

 

[CoolNebraskaGuy]

The article doesn't even mention Lady Gaga by name. I knew some of you were bad readers but this is really embarassing for you guys!

 

 

Anyway, back to reality where Gaga is currently scoring one of the biggest smashes of the decade. Like she has every single decade of her career.

Edited 23 hours ago by CoolNebraskaGuy

[KeirGrey]

 

15 minutes ago, CoolNebraskaGuy said:

The article doesn't even mention Lady Gaga by name. I knew some of you were bad readers but this is really embarassing for you guys!

 

 

Anyway, back to reality where Gaga is currently scoring one of the biggest smashes of the decade. Like she has every single decade of her career.

Yet her face is front & center

Edited 23 hours ago by KeirGrey

[CoolNebraskaGuy]

2 minutes ago, KeirGrey said:

It literally has

Yet her face is plastered right on there?

So why didn't the article say "Gaga's JFAD was a huge flop" the way it explicitly called Katy Perry's comeback album a bomb? Maybe it's because Gaga is only blamed for the movie bombing on ATRL and 4Chan?

 

That's funny that you mention the pictures though. Only feeding into the rumors that OGHs are semi-literate at best

 

[MESSIAH13]

[MESSIAH13]

[Solaria]

Fadty the biggest flop of all time. Her fall from grace is unprecendeted. Going from 2 Diamond singles to not even cracking the the top 10 with ur lead single is a disgrace. She's finally over for good

[masochizm]

in all retrospect, both katy and gaga are khias in this day and age… NEXT!

[Azealia Banks]

14 hours ago, Vroom Vroom said:

Even in a flop year, Gaga always wins 

[bjorn]

1 hour ago, CoolNebraskaGuy said:

So why didn't the article say "Gaga's JFAD was a huge flop" the way it explicitly called Katy Perry's comeback album a bomb? Maybe it's because Gaga is only blamed for the movie bombing on ATRL and 4Chan?

 

That's funny that you mention the pictures though. Only feeding into the rumors that OGHs are semi-literate at best

 

The mental gymnastics 

[Bhabylon]

1 hour ago, Eternal220 said:

even her Jazz album flopped without collab with Tony. 
 

she really has 0 solo star power in 2024

If you think Harlequin is jazz, you need to listen to more than just oonts oonts poppers music

[campelo]

I love how little monsters think gags is beneath anyone let alone beneath Katy, when they are peers 

[Maroonx]

we already new mrs katie perry was the biggest loser of 2024 x

[Zaram]

14 minutes ago, campelo said:

I love how little monsters think gags is beneath anyone let alone beneath Katy, when they are peers 

I love how you can't even read and understand the article 

[Onyxmage]

10 hours ago, Mariano said:

 

Disease is outstreaming Katy Perry's entire album which just got a deluxe version, and yet Gaga's one song is still outstreaming it daily. 
 

Basically Katy Perry made sure they don't talk about Disease by bombing so hard that it made Disease look like a big success, hope this helps, Brit Brit stans  

Nice deflection. It peaked at #27 and was in free fall after that. It should have been included in the list of flops because well it flopped. 

Edited 21 hours ago by Onyxmage

[Just a Gay on ATRL]

Gaga doesn't deserve to be here. Joker FAD didn't bomb because of her, Disease flopping is whatever when it's a good song. DWAS is one of the biggest hits of the year, that alone should exclude her.

[KOMH]

Gaga with 2 entries