Rank Their Discographies: Mariah Carey vs Beyoncé vs Lana Del Rey

[Brooklyn Baby]

 

 

[sasashite]

Lana > Beyoncé >>>>>>>>>>> Mariah

[Burn]

Beyoncé > Mariah > Lana

 

All three are immaculate though.

[Schami66]

Mariah > Beyoncé > Lana

 

All three are immaculate though.

[Melancholy]

Lana Unreleased Included > Mariah (all) > Lana without Unreleased > Beyonce

[ChooseyLover]

Mariah's 90s discography alone stomps, mercilessly. And that's saying a lot because the others are also really strong (didn't listen to Lana's because it's not my genre tho).

[LittleCupid]

Mariah > Beyonce > Lana

 

 

[rebeltwat]

Lana > Bey > Mariah

[GraceRandolph]

Mariah >>>>> Beyoncé >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Lana 

[Loca]

Lana >>>> Beyonce >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Mariah

[dumbsparce]

Mariah and Lana sweeties

[AxelFox]

Mariah slightly edges out Beyonce still imo. If act III is another great project that might change.

 

Lana del rey's musical output is nowhere close to that level, unlike what some of the homosexuals on here would want us to believe. Not sure why she's being compared to the former 2. 

[Harsh2256]

Mariahs run from debut to rainbow is still unmatched in music except for Madonna. The disrespect. Also, not the least talented singer winning 

[charot]

Mariah >>> Lana (and I don't even listen to her) >>> Beyonce (unlistenable music since 4 idc what the critics say)

Edited 1 hour ago by charot

[Slamless]

Moo > Bey >= Lana

[ScorpiosGroove]

Lana & Bey > the other one 

[ontherocks]

Lana by far.

[BTS]

Mariah >Lana >Bey 

 

This was a hard one, they have very different discographies 

[Richie.Valdez]

Lana clears every single female music act 

[JoeAg]

Mariah > Lana > Bey

 

all have great discographies, but ever since issuing a Mariah stan card and becoming a lovely little lamb, I've kinda realized that she doesn't have a single weak album. it's actually kind of insane  I've distanced myself a bit from Lana's music, but I can still recognize that Born to Die, Ultraviolence, Honeymoon, NFR!, Blue Banisters, and Did You Know… are all excellent albums. Bey has some awesome albums starting with 4 up until now, but her albums before then all had at least two filler songs each which would bring them down just a bit! I think the three best albums here are NFR!, TEoM, and Bey self-titled, but Mariah's consistency is something on a whole other level if we're being honest

 

the whole run of Daydream through Caution is actually insane 

[byzantium]

Mariah > Lana > Beyonce.  
 

But this is ultimately mostly a question of what you as a listener prefer from music.  I'm not invested in the lyrics and melodies so I'll gravitate more towards the songwriters.  

[superben]

Lana >>>>> Mariah >> Beyonce