NoOneDiesFromLove Posted November 20, 2024 Posted November 20, 2024 1 hour ago, gatito said: we really did dodge a bullet with this c-list stunt casting we'd probably have gotten jennette mccurdy as glinda The superior Sam and Cat protagonist? I would've seen the movie then
50thStateofMind Posted November 20, 2024 Posted November 20, 2024 Just now, cyberraga said: I agree, thankfully the same happened with Beyoncé's role in A Star Is Born. I agree...I am thankful Beyonce was not in that film
cyberraga Posted November 20, 2024 Posted November 20, 2024 1 minute ago, 50thStateofMind said: I agree...I am thankful Beyonce was not in that film God is good. There would've been no Oscar noms and less than half the BO if she was in it.
vuelve88 Posted November 20, 2024 Posted November 20, 2024 (edited) 46 minutes ago, MCMXCV said: Lady Gaga was objectively praised for her role in JFAD. Y'all still trying it with the praised in a panned film argument. Edited November 20, 2024 by vuelve88 17 3
50thStateofMind Posted November 20, 2024 Posted November 20, 2024 6 minutes ago, cyberraga said: God is good. There would've been no Oscar noms and less than half the BO if she was in it. same with Gaga in wicked yikes! praise god. 7 5
Edonis Posted November 20, 2024 Posted November 20, 2024 (edited) 6 minutes ago, vuelve88 said: Y'all still trying it with the praised in a panned film argument. I mean, objectively speaking, the acting in the film was not the primary point of criticism Why do you guys keep trying to make it out that she killed the movie? Why do so many of y'all have a hard-on when it comes to bashing Lady Gaga? It's not like she's cozying up with sex predator music producers in 2024 or paying Proskauer Rose millions in Insertion Orders to distance themself from accusations of assault and battery like a ton of Hollywood A-listers do There are worse people in the entertainment industry, and some of y'all stan them Edited November 20, 2024 by Edonis 2
Matchatea Posted November 20, 2024 Posted November 20, 2024 30 minutes ago, lgaga1fan said: The implication from the article title that Shawn would be Glinda is so funny even though that's obviously not what they were going for I mean maybe we can get that version on wicked.com! 3
MCMXCV Posted November 20, 2024 Posted November 20, 2024 13 minutes ago, vuelve88 said: Y'all still trying it with the praised in a panned film argument. Nope! Reviews that panned the movie praised her, that is reality. No amount of hoops you jump through will change that. 2 1 2
MCMXCV Posted November 20, 2024 Posted November 20, 2024 8 minutes ago, Edonis said: I mean, objectively speaking, the acting in the film was not the primary point of criticism Why do you guys keep trying to make it out that she killed the movie? Why do so many of y'all have a hard-on when it comes to bashing Lady Gaga? It's not like she's cozying up with sex predator music producers in 2024 or paying Proskauer Rose millions in Insertion Orders to distance themself from accusations of assault and battery like a ton of Hollywood A-listers do There are worse people in the entertainment industry, and some of y'all stan them ATRL users have Stan war brain rot and think that since the underperformance of music is on the shoulders of the artist, that must mean that underperformance of a movie = on the shoulders of the actors. JFAD's acting was praised, the plot/pacing/writing is what was panned and unfortunately for users like @vuelve88, neither Lady Gaga or Joaquin Phoenix had anything to do with those things. 1 1
Capris Groove Posted November 20, 2024 Posted November 20, 2024 Gaga's a fine singer but she would have sounded strained on the climax of Defying Gravity. 1
cyberraga Posted November 20, 2024 Posted November 20, 2024 17 minutes ago, 50thStateofMind said: same with Gaga in wicked yikes! praise god. Highly unlikely (read impossible) that it would do any worse than the last *actual* lead role Beyonce had ($68 million box office) Especially when you consider this was in development at the same time as ASIB.
cyberraga Posted November 20, 2024 Posted November 20, 2024 9 minutes ago, Sexyzinger said: Box office BOMB averted!!
50thStateofMind Posted November 20, 2024 Posted November 20, 2024 2 minutes ago, cyberraga said: Highly unlikely (read impossible) that it would do any worse than the last *actual* lead role Beyonce had ($68 million box office) Especially when you consider this was in development at the same time as ASIB. Sure hunny keep believing 2
cyberraga Posted November 20, 2024 Posted November 20, 2024 3 minutes ago, 50thStateofMind said: Sure hunny keep believing Facts are facts, Beyoncé's last movie where she actually played the lead only grossed ~70m total. I fear 20 minute voice cameos carried by Disney do not count. 1
KOMH Posted November 20, 2024 Posted November 20, 2024 They really dodged a bullet. Lady GaGa is box office poison. 4 4
Oktober Knight Posted November 20, 2024 Posted November 20, 2024 Damn, Monsters are REALLY gonna hate this movie now 3
Doctor Dick Posted November 20, 2024 Posted November 20, 2024 3 hours ago, gatito said: not anymore not after joker FAD Before JFAD when these things were happening y'all claimed she was never a top choice at all and now that she's proven to have been you claim "she'll never be again." 1
Doctor Dick Posted November 20, 2024 Posted November 20, 2024 1 hour ago, KOMH said: They really dodged a bullet. Lady GaGa is box office poison.
Giorgoc Posted November 20, 2024 Posted November 20, 2024 1 hour ago, KOMH said: They really dodged a bullet. Lady GaGa is box office poison. Meow.
ICLDXU4HS Posted November 20, 2024 Posted November 20, 2024 Would have been better than Erivo, that's for sure! 2 1
BlossomSoul Posted November 20, 2024 Posted November 20, 2024 No Gaga fans allowed acting like the thought of her playing the green witch instead of Harley hasn't been on their mind the past month 2
Recommended Posts