Bigger pop icon: Gwen Stefani or Kelly Clarkson?

[k4rmabutterfly]

Both of these ladies dominated 2004 - 5 with their albums LAMB and Breakaway, but who's the bigger icon overall? Discuss

[rebeltwat]

Gwen by far, she had a whole 10-year career pre LAMB

[wastedpotential]

Kellegend, obviously 

[popmusicisdead]

Gwen obviously. even before her solo career she was already a 90s icon. 

[Gorjesspazze9]

Gwen. Lol 

 

[LikeATattoo]

Gwen. And it's not even close.

 

This comparison does feel very random though lol

[Danny789]

Can ATRL please stop comparing Gwen to early 2000 girls, they are not her peers. 

[Princess Aurora]

Gwen Stefani of course

[Jaimon]

Gwen set trends, Kelly Clarkson follow trends, it's that easy. 

[Nights]

I prefer Kelly's voice and music personally and Kelly definitely is a HUGE icon but I think Gwen has the edge here.

[camilacabelloslaps]

Kelly for this one 

[TeemoR]

Tough one.

 

I feel like Kelly has the bigger career, but Gwen is more "iconic" and left a bigger mark. 

[Ewan Chaos]

Gwen, even if you pretend her No Doubt career before LAMB didn't exist.

[UrMom]

GWEN 

[ReH2o]

Gwen 

[supertiffany]

Kelly still has clout in social media and even Youtube and of course having a daily talkshow that also guest big Hollywood celebrities. 

 

 

[Escape]

Gwen Stefani for sure.