Enough time has passed; can we now admit that Gaga needs to go back to RedOne?

[BlackoutZone]

Absolutely not, his stuff is unlistenable now and the last time they worked together most of the material was horrible. She is better than that

[Domination]

Disease is better produced than Judas and BR/Alejandro are anomalies in his production discography. 

[GraceRandolph]

We want fresh producers please  

[Illuminati]

Aside from what he has worked on with Gaga, RedOne hasn't made good music since On The Floor.

 

Let's not act like you wouldn't be the first one to call their collab dated

Edited 1 hour ago by Illuminati

[fab]

When was the last time RedOne produced anything of note? pls 

[ChooseyLover]

I don't think she's that desperate to seek every single one of the producers from her hey days to make something reminiscent of the past. If that happened, it needs to come from a genuine place. I'm the first who'd like to hear some Cherry Cherry Boom Boom but I don't think that's what she or her audience or the GP wants.

[Katy.Kat.23]

If by RedOne you really meant to say Fernando Garibay, then yes 

[CameraFlashes]

she needs to go back to collab again with Bradley/Ariana/blackpink/Bruno

[JustHoran]

I don't get how she use to make AMAZING pop music like Just Dance, Bad Romance, Telephone, etc. and now just isn't making as catchy music anymore? I feel like she thought Disease was like those but it's not at all catchy like those. So yes, she needs to go back to Red One imo. I love Gaga, I think she's great and talented but the music has not been sticking for me for a few years now. I still listen to Bad Romance.

 

Edit: I just saw RedOne ain't had a hit in forever  So maybe not RedOne, but she needs to go back to doing really catchy pop music again because Disease ain't it.

Edited 3 hours ago by JustHoran

[Alldeezy]

gosh yes I miss her dark pop 

[Booyah]

His sound is really dated now but its true that they create magic together.

[Dante Silva]

I suspect RedOne is burnt out which is why no-one is citing other artists with catchy tunes who have worked with him recently.

 

Given that for a long time Max Martin was seen as the 'go to' producer for hits and "Stupid Love" did not meet with universal approval, I'd say he's burnt out too.

 

There simply does not appear to be a hot producer writing maximalist/ well produced dance/ pop tunes at present.

 

Would fans want her to work with A.G. Cook or is he considered 'too edgy'?

 

Alternatively would fans want her to work with Bonnie McKee?

 

It would be quite upsetting if she was ever rumoured to be working with Jack Antonoff. 
 

Would fans want her to hook back up with DJ White Shadow, if they were to work from the production template of the BTW album (as opposed to Artpop)?

 

Back in the day Rick Nowels used to write maximalist pop tunes for Belinda Carlisle. Could he do the same for Gaga but with a dance edge (as opposed to soft rock)?

 

Its inevitable that someone will suggest a hot producer I've not mentioned, but if I check that producer out, am I going to find someone capable of writing catchy and melodic verse/ chorus/ bridge structures or will that person simply be currently considered 'cool'?

[burninredhot]

No the public doesn't want anything from her unless it's a joint effort with a successful popstar

[popmusicisdead]

that would be a reverse Ava Max experience